She looks rather cartoony to me, that's all. Next to Kaidan/Ashley/Vega, she stands out, and not in a good way. Next to Liara, not so much, but Liara can rock the look (humanoid, yes, but still alien).
The texture is far superior to those of the CC, polished, and I do think that she looks good so I'll be using her, and I gotta say she looks stunning in some shots - in others, she looks like a fox out of a Disney cartoon. Her expressions sometimes, particularly the eyes, it's like Bambi when her mother got shot. So off. But all in all... yeah, I think they did a great job and I love her already. Just wish she looked more realistic (Ashley, Miranda... etc).
The freckles I suppose could be a bit subtler. The makeup itself doesn't bother me, it's the whole package, with the bright red hair, green eyes + freckles, really strong eyebrows and those huge eyes = bit over the top. Sometimes less is more, balance things out. But I'm being overly critic here, in the end, I do think they nailed it, she looks the part....it's just the cartoonish thing that bugs me sometimes, but nothing I can't get past .
Great job! =) Go Femshep!!!