Lotion Soronnar wrote...
ME2 felt like Tramsformers 2.
Hunter of Legends wrote...
Lotion Soronnar wrote...
ME2 felt like Tramsformers 2.
Lolno.
You detractors have got to stop being drama queens and using far too much hyberbole. ME2 may be different and not ME1 but by no means was it equal to the mindless dumb fun of Transformers.
That's just insulting. If any game is Transformers it's Modern Warfare 2/3.
Lotion Soronnar wrote...
Hunter of Legends wrote...
ME1's writing wasn't much different than ME2's.
In fact I'd argue it's gotten better.
You do stand up comedy often?
Lotion Soronnar wrote...
Taleroth wrote...
Well yes. It's not a dispute of my point. Lethal Weapon, Transformers, and the latest Star Trek all FEEL DIFFERENT. It doesn't mean they're not all action movies.Lotion Soronnar wrote...
but I will tell you that ME2 FELT DIFFERENT.
Action has breadth. ME1 took more cues from the 90s.
ME1 felt like a space opera.
ME2 felt like Tramsformers 2.
incinerator950 wrote...
Hunter of Legends wrote...
Lotion Soronnar wrote...
ME2 felt like Tramsformers 2.
Lolno.
You detractors have got to stop being drama queens and using far too much hyberbole. ME2 may be different and not ME1 but by no means was it equal to the mindless dumb fun of Transformers.
That's just insulting. If any game is Transformers it's Modern Warfare 2/3.
I almost read this in your voice, and laughed.
jmood88 wrote...
As I said in another thread, it's hilarious seeing the people who complain about the writing and then show their attempts at writing a scene. Most people here have no idea what good writing is, and that goes double for the fan-fiction writers on this site.
Saphra Deden wrote...
KotorEffect3 wrote...
Idiot, the games keep getting better but you whiners keep getting worse.
No, you. The game keeps getting worse but you think it's getting better.
Hunter of Legends wrote...
jmood88 wrote...
As I said in another thread, it's hilarious seeing the people who complain about the writing and then show their attempts at writing a scene. Most people here have no idea what good writing is, and that goes double for the fan-fiction writers on this site.
Thank you.
To date I have seen NO-ONE on this site write a decent SCENE let alone story. Half of them don't even understand basic writing terminology, like cliche and railroading.
Modifié par teh_619, 15 février 2012 - 08:35 .
teh_619 wrote...
Hunter of Legends wrote...
jmood88 wrote...
As I said in another thread, it's hilarious seeing the people who complain about the writing and then show their attempts at writing a scene. Most people here have no idea what good writing is, and that goes double for the fan-fiction writers on this site.
Thank you.
To date I have seen NO-ONE on this site write a decent SCENE let alone story. Half of them don't even understand basic writing terminology, like cliche and railroading.
So what's your verdict on Bioware writing on ME3 mister expert?
And are you seriously saying that people shouldn't judge Bioware's writing if they're not proffesionals or something?
Because you're fooling yourself.
Hunter of Legends wrote...
teh_619 wrote...
Hunter of Legends wrote...
jmood88 wrote...
As I said in another thread, it's hilarious seeing the people who complain about the writing and then show their attempts at writing a scene. Most people here have no idea what good writing is, and that goes double for the fan-fiction writers on this site.
Thank you.
To date I have seen NO-ONE on this site write a decent SCENE let alone story. Half of them don't even understand basic writing terminology, like cliche and railroading.
So what's your verdict on Bioware writing on ME3 mister expert?
And are you seriously saying that people shouldn't judge Bioware's writing if they're not proffesionals or something?
Because you're fooling yourself.
They should be more realisitc. Insinuating that they themselves can write better and that Bioware writers are terrible is hilarious at best.
When they don't even understand basic concepts like "cliche" and "character archetypes" yes they shouldn't be talking about how the writing is. If I am not a rocket scientist I shouldn't be commenting on how the rocket should be built.
As for me, their writing has always been on the better side of the business. Is it flawless? No. Is it better than most games out their? Hell yes.
Dear God you people need to play more games if Bioware's writing is "bad". What the hell do you call 2kgames or Infinity Wards then?
I don't think that people need to be experts at all but they shouldn't be talking about writing when they have no idea what they're talking and the things they produce are full of cliches that are worse than what they are criticizing.teh_619 wrote...
Hunter of Legends wrote...
jmood88 wrote...
As I said in another thread, it's hilarious seeing the people who complain about the writing and then show their attempts at writing a scene. Most people here have no idea what good writing is, and that goes double for the fan-fiction writers on this site.
Thank you.
To date I have seen NO-ONE on this site write a decent SCENE let alone story. Half of them don't even understand basic writing terminology, like cliche and railroading.
So what's your verdict on Bioware writing on ME3 mister expert?
And are you seriously saying that people shouldn't judge Bioware's writing unless they're proffesionals or something?
Because you're fooling yourself.
Hunter of Legends wrote...
Lotion Soronnar wrote...
ME2 felt like Tramsformers 2.
Lolno.
You detractors have got to stop being drama queens and using far too much hyberbole. ME2 may be different and not ME1 but by no means was it equal to the mindless dumb fun of Transformers.
That's just insulting. If any game is Transformers it's Modern Warfare 2/3.
jmood88 wrote...
As I said in another thread, it's hilarious seeing the people who complain about the writing and then show their attempts at writing a scene. Most people here have no idea what good writing is, and that goes double for the fan-fiction writers on this site.
teh_619 wrote...
" If I am not a rocket scientist I shouldn't be commenting on how the rocket should be built."
Nobody's commenting on how they should write.
Everybody's just saying it's bad.
At least Bioware knows quite well the meaning of "cliches" though.
KotorEffect3 wrote...
tetrisblock4x1 wrote...
I expected Casey Hudson for ME3, not Shakespeare. But then TOR happened and ME2 and 3 got a bunch of ****s for writers. And now we get **** instead of 2 decent sequels of what started out as a promising new IP.
Idiot, the games keep getting better but you whiners keep getting worse.
Lotion Soronnar wrote...
jmood88 wrote...
As I said in another thread, it's hilarious seeing the people who complain about the writing and then show their attempts at writing a scene. Most people here have no idea what good writing is, and that goes double for the fan-fiction writers on this site.
It's even more hilarious when people throw together a quick concept as an example (that still works better than what's in the game), and you proceed to treat it like a fully-fleshed out piece of writing.
Hunter of Legends wrote...
They should be more realisitc. Insinuating that they themselves can write better and that Bioware writers are terrible is hilarious at best.
When they don't even understand basic concepts like "cliche" and "character archetypes" yes they shouldn't be talking about how the writing is. If I am not a rocket scientist I shouldn't be commenting on how the rocket should be built.
jmood88 wrote...
Lotion Soronnar wrote...
jmood88 wrote...
As I said in another thread, it's hilarious seeing the people who complain about the writing and then show their attempts at writing a scene. Most people here have no idea what good writing is, and that goes double for the fan-fiction writers on this site.
It's even more hilarious when people throw together a quick concept as an example (that still works better than what's in the game), and you proceed to treat it like a fully-fleshed out piece of writing.
If you're going to criticize something and attempt to put something out there that would work better, then it should be good. That example in the other thread was a horrible piece of writing and did not do anything to make the scene he was complaining about any better.
jmood88 wrote...
teh_619 wrote...
" If I am not a rocket scientist I shouldn't be commenting on how the rocket should be built."
Nobody's commenting on how they should write.
Everybody's just saying it's bad.
At least Bioware knows quite well the meaning of "cliches" though.
There are plenty of people commenting on how they should write and their examples of how scenes could be done "better". Also, if you are not a rocket scientist and have no idea how rockets function or how they are built, then you really shouldn't be commenting on how it should be made.
Troll be Gone.jaza wrote...
KotorEffect3 wrote...
tetrisblock4x1 wrote...
I expected Casey Hudson for ME3, not Shakespeare. But then TOR happened and ME2 and 3 got a bunch of ****s for writers. And now we get **** instead of 2 decent sequels of what started out as a promising new IP.
Idiot, the games keep getting better but you whiners keep getting worse.
YES! YES! LET THE FANBOYISM FLOW THROUGH YOU!
Retour en haut