38 réponses à ce sujet

[In Exile]

Kaiser Arian wrote...
This thread isn't about everyone giving a game the same score. Not that kind of Standard.
If you think the story of a RPG is garbage, fine... that game shouldn't get 0/10 or 1/10. The story is part of the score but not the entirety of it (almost half the score is my reasonable suggestion). If the story is masterpiece but there is awful gameplay, C&C, graphic and very weak sound effects and music that game shouldn't get more than 5/10.

But you've pretty much described Bioshock infinite, though maybe I'd change it to mediocre gameplay, forgetable sound effects and music. 

[SlottsMachine]

Aravius wrote...

I love quality voice acting. IMHO, the Female Shep scores a 10, while the Male Shep scores a 3.

HAHAHAHAHA



HAHAHAHAHA

[spirosz]

I thought you meant like how to score, like compose. So I'll say, learn some music theory. Also, I'll score this post with a six out of ten with a 3/4 beat to compliment the rhythm of you saying all this out loud.

[Kaiser Arian XVII]

J. Reezy wrote...

Kaiser Arian wrote...

J. Reezy wrote...

Do you feel powerful posting this?

Seriously though, what are these scores proving besides critical acclaim? This has nothing to do with your standardization.

lolwut? fite me in RL...

Yes it does. No serious reviewer gives it a 5/10 or 2/10. Only random idiots or emotionally unstable gamers might have done that.

WTF? Oh I get it, you want people to be shills for games you prefer. No "serious" reviewer? What does that mean? No wait, I shouldn't ask you, because you're biased. If I found a review of BioShock Infinite that the reviewer scored a 2/10 you would wave it off as "that person's an idiot". Even if it's from a sound perspective. And so I repeat..."Lol at standardizing peoples' opinions."

Stop it five.

Mr. relativist lulz-A-lot who agrees with nothing.

Welcome to the reality. We're all biased... specially RPG gamers.
If someone score BioShock Infinite, KOTOR or New Vegas 2/10 something is really wrong with him.
Plain hatred toward their franchises or video games in general, being emotionally disturbed (by something in those games or in general) and being bribed to give BS score can be the reasons to hate these games and rate them 2/10.

Not many constructive comments yet.

[Get Magna Carter]

1) breaking down a game score into components assumes that all components are equally important to all games. In reality this isn't the case. Some games are all about story, other games have no story; some games are all about gameplay, others have little gameplay. Games should be judged for how well they do what they do mixed with the merits of what they do,
2) different people (including reviewers) have different tastes, different playstyles, different skill levels, different prejudices. If someone dislikes a genre that you like (or vice versa) does not mean there's anything wrong with them.
(Though I am bothered by one recent accusation that anyone who was NOT prejudiced against Japanese games was racist)

[Kaiser Arian XVII]

Your "1)" is what I'm trying to say. To compromise how important is a subject (e.g. story) in different genres (e.g. Racing or RPG) and then how much percentage it gets from the whole score. If you find the quality of story in a racing game or in a RPG low, mediocre or high you can rate it in accordance to their value (like 1/5 or 1/2 of total score) and consider other aspects of those games.

Your "2)" is the problem. Those who don't like a genre shouldn't bother scoring/reviewing them. It's just a waste of their times and readers'. As 1/10 means utter crap, a game should be really that bad to be scored that way, not because they don't like its genre.
If they're so eager to score anyway, they can at least try to listen to the last paragraph.

Modifié par Kaiser Arian, 30 décembre 2013 - 12:36 .

[AventuroLegendary]

I suggest...

Buy: Easy to get into for many people
Rent: It's a bit of a niche
Skip: Don't you dare

[Kaiser Arian XVII]

Thanks Cowboy Saunter. Good suggestion, still debatable...

I think I need to work more on this. I'm as structuralist as Russia! In few months or a year from now, I shall come with a systematic scoring no one can object.