Bigaddygun wrote...
They all look like dreadnoughts both the red and purple. You said that the Art Book shows dreadnoughts without the two extensions on the main gun, then doesn't the red one like look the smaller dreadnought?
tez19 wrote...
Maybe it was another glaring error? Art people must be spending too much time with the writing department.Belhawk wrote...
Why did BW make a cruiser & dreadnought look so similar?
Well it only requires 2 voice actor's, are they really that unprofessional? Why didn't they come back to record one line? Are their lives really that busy? Pompous idiots.DJBare wrote...
This was already confirmed to be a scripting error, by the time they realised their mistake the VA's had gone home and it was too late to call them back in for another recording session.
tez19 wrote...
Pompous idiots.
Guest_Imperium Alpha_*
Belhawk wrote...
Why did BW make a cruiser & dreadnought look so similar?
GnusmasTHX wrote...
Bigaddygun wrote...
They all look like dreadnoughts both the red and purple. You said that the Art Book shows dreadnoughts without the two extensions on the main gun, then doesn't the red one like look the smaller dreadnought?
You may need glasses, just saying.
Belhawk wrote...
there are size differences and a difference on what weapons each ship can have on board. The battleship MO has 16 inch guns and u would never see them on a cruiser.
Busy lives, the cost of bringing them back in, take your choice, personally I'd go for the latter, I would not consider something like this worth the extra cost.tez19 wrote...
Well it only requires 2 voice actor's, are they really that unprofessional? Why didn't they come back to record one line? Are their lives really that busy?Pompous idiots.
Zandercode wrote...
Thanks, GnusmasTHX, that's what I was talking about, but I guess you're right, I was looking at a blurry YouTube video to rechecking the ship in the demo and to me it looked like that dreadnaught design, I didn't see the two spires you are talking about that make it a cruiser between the blurryness and the smoke of the Reaper laser. Still not that easy to tell the two apart though.
I notice that these capital ships are also flying in an atmosphere. Presumeably, Earth's.GnusmasTHX wrote...
Zandercode wrote...
The only difference in appearance between a dreadnaught and a cruiser is the dreadnaught has 4 thrusters like the Normandy instead of 2, and the main guns appear to be a part of the thrusters portions of the ship instead of the central hull like the cruisers, otherwise, they look damn similar. Notice how the ship in the demo is firing its guns from either side or "shoulder" instead of the big central portion - that proves it is a dreadnaught and not a cruiser, a cruiser fires from the center as seen in the final battle against Sovereign in ME1. So Ash/Kaidan were correct.
Now whether a dreadnaught should be able to get that low to the ground without crashing is debatable, as the lore says they can't land on planets, though this one doesn't exactly land and they are in a rather extreme situation where they may be willing to pull a few more dangerous moves like that.
You know if you actually look at the image from the Art Book, you'd see that the ship in the demo is a cruiser, rather than a dreadnought.
There are two jutting spires extending from the main center portion of the ship, akin to ME1, and like the image in the Art Book... of a cruiser.
The Art Book shows dreadnoughts without the two extensions on the main gun. To iterate my point:
The ship in red is a cruiser, and you'll find the profile matches the one in the demo. The ship in purple is a dreadnought.
Sylvf wrote...
We actually noticed this one. Ash and Kaidan's recording sessions were over by the time we had finalized art and realized that at the distance we could see the ship, there was no way it should be a dreadnought. Unfortunate, but there wasn't much we could do.
(I don't comment on this kind of thing too often, but it bothered one of our other writers quite a bit so I'd like to stick up on his behalf.)
I'm sure Bioware will be counting their profits though with glee and wringing their hands.DJBare wrote...
Busy lives, the cost of bringing them back in, take your choice, personally I'd go for the latter, I would not consider something like this worth the extra cost.tez19 wrote...
Well it only requires 2 voice actor's, are they really that unprofessional? Why didn't they come back to record one line? Are their lives really that busy?Pompous idiots.
tez19 wrote...
I'm sure Bioware will be counting their profits though with glee and wringing their hands.
Of course still for me to be right a dev would have to be wrong... Crap.
Locutus_of_BORG wrote...
I notice that these capital ships are also flying in an atmosphere. Presumeably, Earth's.
They should strive for perfection for their fans, especially considering the huge profit they will make from us all.didymos1120 wrote...
tez19 wrote...
I'm sure Bioware will be counting their profits though with glee and wringing their hands.
And I'm sure you'll still be excessively hostile and judgmental about what, in the grand scheme of things, is a minor script error.
Zandercode wrote...
@ bigaddygun - ooh, the plot thickets! I still have a chance at being right here.
tez19 wrote...
They should strive for perfection for their fans, especially considering the huge profit they will make from us all.
Retour en haut
