203 réponses à ce sujet

[Shadowrun1177]

I don't really see how this is a spoiler though, cause we all knew this was coming it was even foreshadowed in the ME2 Legion/Tali argument that Shepard had to resolve. We just don't know how it will turn out in ME3 and are giving our opinions on who we would side with come to the final choice in this long standing war. Well like other's I hope the situation can be resolved peacefully, but if not I would side with the Quarian's over the Geth.

[RazorrX]

If no middle ground then Quarians.

[TexasToast712]

Justicar wrote...

TexasToast712 wrote...

They were created and fabricated as tools.

And depending on our religion, so were we.

They aren't a life form. They are machines.

You're confusing "life form" with "organic life form".

And you are confused with the idea that a machine can be considered a living thing.

[Adanu]

Geth are about as 'sentient' as Avina. That being said ,they will likely be the most useful in the war. I don't care about the morality of the Quarians/Geth debate. If one side has more to offer in the Galactic War, they're getting picked. If the other can't be reasonable, I'm not shedding a tear.

[Sailears]

If I had to then I'd side with geth, unless the quarians have any desire to acheive peace.

[AlexXIV]

Hate to break the party but likely you won't have to choose either side. Peaceful solution cannot be by siding on one side, because that would mean war. The Geth are not going to let the Quarians shut them off and the Quarians won't let the Geth wipe them out either. The only peaceful solution is to give both sides what they want most.

[Windninja47]

AlexXIV wrote...

Hate to break the party but likely you won't have to choose either side. Peaceful solution cannot be by siding on one side, because that would mean war. The Geth are not going to let the Quarians shut them off and the Quarians won't let the Geth wipe them out either. The only peaceful solution is to give both sides what they want most.

You mean the planet? I don't think they want to share. Besides, I think there's already a war going on.

[DJBare]

I certainly hope we are not forced to make a choice between one or the other without any other options, but if I have to choose, then it will be the quarians, not because I favour them on the contrary I prefer the geth, I'd choose the quarians because they have a culture the geth have barely achieved, I'd also choose the quarians because that dyson sphere does sound like a reaper!, I can just see the end scene and the camera zooming in on one of the larger geth hubs, we helped the organics defeat the reapers "we are the pinnacle of evolution!"

[DJBare]

Windninja47 wrote...

You mean the planet? I don't think they want to share. Besides, I think there's already a war going on.

What they want and whats good for them are two entirely different things, the geth don't want the quarian homeworld, they are just caretakers, the geths ultimate goal is the dyson sphere.

[Darth Malice113]

TexasToast712 wrote...

Justicar wrote...

TexasToast712 wrote...

They were created and fabricated as tools.

And depending on our religion, so were we.

They aren't a life form. They are machines.

You're confusing "life form" with "organic life form".

And you are confused with the idea that a machine can be considered a living thing.

By definition the human body is considered a machine. 

[Xivai]

Geth, unless new information leads me to pick the Quarians. They're completely justified in wanting freedom, and we learn they've been tending and fixing the planet that the Quarians ****ed up in their senseless war to make themselves feel better. Legion even says if they would be willing to talk, something could likely work out. They're waiting for the creators to return.

So what do the Quarians go and do? Go and blow the **** out of the Geth, again! Or attempt to, and I have a feeling it's going to end very poorly. Seriously think of all the damage they're going to do to their homeworld the Geth just fixed. They just cleaned the place up can you keep it clean for like 10 years you primitive space suit wearing things!

I think that states who's side I'm on. Quarians are acting like goddamn spoiled children who need to be put in time out. Or something.

Edit
If there's no middle ground option, I would rather no one die.

Modifié par Xivai, 21 février 2012 - 07:22 .

[Justicar]

Razorsedge820 wrote...

Really? Have you played the game yet? I'm sure even synthetics like the geth realize that if they dont join with organics they have no chance of surviving alone.

I'm pretty sure the Geth have a better chance than any other species in the Mily Way.

Just to give an idea as to the Geth numbers:

According to info from the Heretic Station, Heretic Geth populations there (and there only, I don't have a source for outside) is around 6.6 Million (software) copies, with 2.4 million platforms. Therefore, if we take as an example, that ALL Heretic Geth population (software) lives here (which is unlikely), then we can conclude that 5% of x[True Geth population] is 6.6 Million. 

So, 5% of x is 6,600,000. Therefore, if my calculations are correct (UNLIKELY ) the True Geth Numbers are around 132,000,000. Compared to humans in Mass Effect (at least on Earth), Geth numbers seem small in comparison (11,400,000,000). But then you realize that the Geth physical population COULD consist entirely of Dreadnoughts, for all we know.

I feel the Geth will be a very big help in the coming war, possibly outranking the Turians and Quarians.

Modifié par Justicar, 21 février 2012 - 07:24 .

[AlexXIV]

Windninja47 wrote...

AlexXIV wrote...

Hate to break the party but likely you won't have to choose either side. Peaceful solution cannot be by siding on one side, because that would mean war. The Geth are not going to let the Quarians shut them off and the Quarians won't let the Geth wipe them out either. The only peaceful solution is to give both sides what they want most.

You mean the planet? I don't think they want to share. Besides, I think there's already a war going on.

The Geth view themselves as caretakers and they need no atmosphere. Also they may build their dyson sphere somewhere in space. So matter of factly the Geth have what the Quarians want most, and they don't need it. And the Geth want to be left alone and that's really not asked much from the Quarians either. Well obviously war is going on since ME1 but that doesn't mean it needs to still go on and on.

[Justicar]

I like to consider Quarians Vs. Geth a hostile Cold War.

[Xayoz]

 Looking at the war assets, I think its likely you will have to choose just one of them to side with.

I will go with Quarians eitehr ways and put an end to the Geth menace.

[AlexXIV]

Justicar wrote...

Razorsedge820 wrote...

Really? Have you played the game yet? I'm sure even synthetics like the geth realize that if they dont join with organics they have no chance of surviving alone.

I'm pretty sure the Geth have a better chance than any other species in the Mily Way.

Just to give an idea as to the Geth numbers:

According to info from the Heretic Station, Heretic Geth populations there (and there only, I don't have a source for outside) is around 6.6 Million (software) copies, with 2.4 million platforms. Therefore, if we take as an example, that ALL Heretic Geth population (software) lives here (which is unlikely), then we can conclude that 5% of x[True Geth population] is 6.6 Million. 

So, 5% of x is 6,600,000. Therefore, if my calculations are correct (UNLIKELY ) the True Geth Numbers are around 132,000,000. Compared to humans in Mass Effect (at least on Earth), Geth numbers seem small in comparison (11,400,000,000). But then you realize that the Geth physical population COULD consist entirely of Dreadnoughts, for all we know.

I feel the Geth will be a very big help in the coming war, possibly outranking the Turians and Quarians.

I don't know the numbers but I assume (and hope) that your decision in ME2 whether to rewrite or blow up the heretics plays a role in their strength. The reason I didn't blow them up afterall was because I thought they were potential allies and better cannon fodder than organics.

Modifié par AlexXIV, 21 février 2012 - 07:45 .

[Windninja47]

Xayoz wrote...

 Looking at the war assets, I think its likely you will have to choose just one of them to side with.

I will go with Quarians eitehr ways and put an end to the Geth menace.

Yeah, I read the war assets- pretty spoilerific stuff. 

[WizenSlinky0]

Quarians.

[Justicar]

Xayoz wrote...

 Looking at the war assets, I think its likely you will have to choose just one of them to side with.

I will go with Quarians eitehr ways and put an end to the Geth menace.

Xayoz wrote...

I will go with Quarians eitehr ways and put an end to the Geth menace.

 

Xayoz wrote...

put an end to the Geth menace.

Xayoz wrote...

Geth menace.

wat

that ended 2 years ago

[Arppis]

Geth have valid claims imo and they got right to excist. I don't understand why this couldn't be resolved peacefully.

[Xayoz]

Justicar wrote...
wat

that ended 2 years ago

By 'Geth menace' I mean't the existence of Geth.

[Justicar]

Xayoz wrote...

Justicar wrote...
wat

that ended 2 years ago

By 'Geth menace' I mean't the existence of Geth.

Explain how they're a menace.

They might end up saving us from the Reapers.
The True Geth have been isolationist for 300 years.
They have an amazing and ideal form of 'government'.

[Annihilator27]

I want to have both of them help, But if it comes down to it im choosing the Geth,