OdanUrr wrote...
Farbautisonn wrote...
OdanUrr wrote...
I'm afraid I do. There was no "surprise" effect for me, no "omg what" reaction, just a "seriously?" There was no need for the story to turn the Collectors into Protheans to make sense. After all, we learned in ME1 that Sovereign likely had other tools at its disposal. Saren and his geth, the Keepers, the Protheans who turned on their fellows, husks, etc. The Collectors could've simply been another race repurposed to suit the Reapers' needs and that would've been interesting too. Bringing back the Protheans in this fashion was unnecessary.
-Aha. So yet another generic alien race with chitcnious shells would have been the pinnacle of storytelling then. Right.
Casting the protheans in that role made sense, gave the story a twist, and elaborated on the fate of the protheans. Presto. Kinder egg.
Instead youd expect people to bond and empathze with a newly introduced race that got idoctrinated. Really? Thats your idea of great storytelling? Thats your idea of getting the audience involved and feeling a bond?
Tell me something. Have you ever played Pen and pager RPG's? Or read fantasy, or just fiction in general?
Now you're just being rude. You argued that it was essential for the Collectors to have been Protheans and I believe I have explained that is not so. Whether it's a nice twist or not is a subjective matter. You also seem to think that the mere inclusion of the Protheans constitutes great storytelling. I disagree. It would have been intriguing to learn more about another race, especially one older than the Protheans themselves, that had been repurposed by the Reapers and thus gain new insight on the exact process of indoctrination while, at the same time, learn about this new/old civilization. Imagine if they were the ones who brought down the derelict Reaper in ME2? That would have been a nice twist.
As to your other questions, I have not played pen and paper RPGs. As to my reading habits, I read science fiction, fantasy, historical novels, fiction, biographies, books on science, pretty much everything.
Sorry but thats why it is good not everybody writes stories they would be rediculously bad.
Another race older than the protheans? :/ come on you can't be serious about that.
There must be an oldest and you can't go back and back and back in time with new spiecies dude!
protheans where 50.000 years ago what do you come up with next then? 100.000 the Marathans, they are even more advanced they do not use mass relay's and the reapers? =/
most people don't have the great vision of the writers of such epic stories and that is why it is good they just ignore most of the talk about story here.
What is more important is that DLC on launch is not fair. Discuss about that





Retour en haut






