Aller au contenu

Photo

Mass Effect 3: From Ashes


13369 réponses à ce sujet

#8451
ArkkAngel007

ArkkAngel007
  • Members
  • 2 514 messages

BaronIveagh wrote...

J.amber wrote...

actually he's in the "core game" he's just a NPC not a squadmate or having a mission which is the DLC


Shepard, the checkpoint is under fire. 


From what? False information?  He is not in the main game.  At all.  End of story.  

#8452
didymos1120

didymos1120
  • Members
  • 14 580 messages

BaronIveagh wrote...

J.amber wrote...

actually he's in the "core game" he's just a NPC not a squadmate or having a mission which is the DLC


Shepard, the checkpoint is under fire. 


Yes, mission banter files.  We've been over this.

#8453
GuyIncognito21

GuyIncognito21
  • Members
  • 247 messages

ArkkAngel007 wrote...

The content wasn't cut from the main game.  When is that fact going to actually set in?


Maybe when a developer comes on here and says that without the ability to sell this content separately, it wouldn't exist. 

#8454
ArkkAngel007

ArkkAngel007
  • Members
  • 2 514 messages

fides5566 wrote...

BaronIveagh wrote...

For real hilarity: it's 'on disc' DLC, and was removed pretty late in development, as the audio tracks for the Prothean were included in the Demo.


Give me the evidence please, not just a link to someone post that it was included in the demo.
But how to get that audio tracks and where is that file in the demo.


The audio part is true, but the former statement is false.

#8455
DJBare

DJBare
  • Members
  • 6 510 messages

lastpawn wrote...

I think this is a simple issue, and one that doesn't need morality drawn into it.

Either you're OK with the model where you pay for first day DLC, or you're not. If you're not, you can elect to show that by either not buying the game or waiting till it's in the discount isle. It's your money, and we get the type of behavior from companies that we accept.

Yeah, but it's not near as much fun as standing on a soapbox shouting your displeasure at the man. B)

#8456
andrew252

andrew252
  • Members
  • 290 messages
honestly i wouldnt care as long as hes not the only living one,if it turns out hes the sole survivor then its a big nono but if you find a colony still living then i will let them get away with it.The only bad thing i c is that its a 1st day dlc,way around that is to stall it for bout 3-4 months

#8457
Mclouvins

Mclouvins
  • Members
  • 544 messages

GuyIncognito21 wrote...

ArkkAngel007 wrote...

The content wasn't cut from the main game.  When is that fact going to actually set in?


Maybe when a developer comes on here and says that without the ability to sell this content separately, it wouldn't exist. 




Jessica Merizan already said that on Reddit, which makes sense. If this content was developed outside the overall operating budget of the core game it has to be distributed it such a way that generates revenue.

#8458
Yuoaman

Yuoaman
  • Members
  • 3 660 messages

andrew252 wrote...

honestly i wouldnt care as long as hes not the only living one,if it turns out hes the sole survivor then its a big nono but if you find a colony still living then i will let them get away with it.The only bad thing i c is that its a 1st day dlc,way around that is to stall it for bout 3-4 months


Javik is the only one.

#8459
KBomb

KBomb
  • Members
  • 3 927 messages

obie191970 wrote...


C'mon KBomb.  We're going to charge you an extra $20 for a boy scout patch, a postcard sized art book, a robotic dog and a N7 hoodie.  But we'll give you an extra character and mission for free!!!!  Really?  It's obviously included as part of the extra $20 that CE buyers spent.  Everyone is going to different monetary values on those products but the fact remains that the DLC was included in that price.



 
I simply asked whether or not Casey Hudson said it came free or not. What I believe has nothing to do with the question I posed.


If Casey Hudson stated that the DLC came free with all CE purchases, and included the DLC in the price, regardless of what he says—then his statement about it being free is false.


If Casey Hudson stated the DLC came free with all CE purchases, then by common deduction: The swag is what cost the extra fee.


I didn't say any of the above is how I felt about it. I asked if he did indeed, make that statement. If he did, and you believe everything Bioware tells you—then you must take this man at his word. No holds barred. You believe him, or you don't. What I believe wasn't part of the equation.  
Furthermore, it was more just a question if he said it. It was meant as a question—it was not a statement on my part. I don't understand why some people have an issue with that. Seems a bit pugnacious.

#8460
ArkkAngel007

ArkkAngel007
  • Members
  • 2 514 messages

GuyIncognito21 wrote...

ArkkAngel007 wrote...

The content wasn't cut from the main game.  When is that fact going to actually set in?


Maybe when a developer comes on here and says that without the ability to sell this content separately, it wouldn't exist. 




You don't have to go through the developers (basically just admitted you would not listen to them no matter what you're presented with anyways).  It's apparent in the final script in the demo files.  I realize people don't want to spoil the game for themselves, but sometimes risks have to be taken to make sure you are getting what you payed for.

It never got passed the concept and first draft with the original Prothean.  They reused those assets later to create Javik and write a new mission where he can be a squadmate and provide an alternate take on the lore that was retained in the final script for the retail copy.

#8461
lastpawn

lastpawn
  • Members
  • 746 messages

DJBare wrote...

lastpawn wrote...

I think this is a simple issue, and one that doesn't need morality drawn into it.

Either you're OK with the model where you pay for first day DLC, or you're not. If you're not, you can elect to show that by either not buying the game or waiting till it's in the discount isle. It's your money, and we get the type of behavior from companies that we accept.

Yeah, but it's not near as much fun as standing on a soapbox shouting your displeasure at the man. B)


got me there

#8462
GuyIncognito21

GuyIncognito21
  • Members
  • 247 messages

Mclouvins wrote...

Jessica Merizan already said that on Reddit, which makes sense. If this content was developed outside the overall operating budget of the core game it has to be distributed it such a way that generates revenue.


Her title is "community manager" which sounds to me a lot like "PR spin doctor."  I want someone who worked on the game to say it, one of the people responsible for the first two games in the series, back when we trusted Bioware not to hose us.

Modifié par GuyIncognito21, 25 février 2012 - 04:38 .


#8463
BaronIveagh

BaronIveagh
  • Members
  • 680 messages

Mclouvins wrote...

Once again img.gawkerassets.com/img/17eig06xukt8apng/original.png


You know, people keep brandishing that around like it has meaning, but the funny part is, it's wrong. 

http://s16.postimage...rrected_map.jpg

That's what it would look like in this case, because the Prothean was excised during production, not preproduction.

Modifié par BaronIveagh, 25 février 2012 - 04:39 .


#8464
ZX12r Ninja

ZX12r Ninja
  • Members
  • 212 messages

KBomb wrote...

Wrong. Someone posted this:


Did they say CE = free and SE = pay
http://social.biowar...705/336#9454657

No, he might have used the term free but no way you get it for free
http://social.biowar...705/336#9454704

But did he realy say that?
http://social.biowar...705/336#9454777

Don't be silly why do you believe that?
http://social.biowar...705/336#9454803

What did it mean however.. 0-day dlc zaeed bla bla. Swag with CE has a lot of value so how do they pay for DLC?
http://social.biowar...705/337#9454828

Free 0-day DLC is different. Swag might have great collectable value but little monetary value as can be manufactured in China for a few cents.
http://social.biowar...705/337#9454851

It was legitimate question and I'm a cynic
http://social.biowar...705/337#9454897

If you're a cynic then why do you assume they would make a difference between CE and SE buyers. Give Swag + DLC at great discount while SE has to pay premium.
http://social.biowar...705/337#9454947

Too lazy todo links as forum software sucks... You do the rest.

#8465
breadedpudding

breadedpudding
  • Members
  • 100 messages

BaronIveagh wrote...

Mclouvins wrote...

Once again img.gawkerassets.com/img/17eig06xukt8apng/original.png


You know, people keep brandishing that around like it has meaning, but the funny part is, it's wrong. 

http://s16.postimage...rrected_map.jpg

That's what it would look like inthis case, because the Prothean was excised during production, not preproduction.


No one has any proof that Prothy is plot essential until they play the game/DLC. Yes, he's a Prothean and I understand the importance of the race to some of us, the players, but how many characters in the game are going to believe he's a Prothean and not just a Collector or some other disguised or modified race? In game, no one really, truly knows WHAT Protheans even looked like 50,000 years ago. For that, how will they care? If they did believe, would they honestly believe he'd have some insight into how to defeat the Reapers, when the Protheans to begin with were more or less wiped out by them? Plus, you know... the galaxy is kind of going to hell in a hand basket, so I would think some folks would have more important things to worry about than some random alien popping up and claiming to be part of an extinct race. 

#8466
mogonk

mogonk
  • Members
  • 90 messages

GuyIncognito21 wrote...

Her title is "community manager" which sounds to me a lot like "PR spin doctor."


You have a real talent for deciphering titles, man.

That's EXACTLY what that means.

#8467
andrew252

andrew252
  • Members
  • 290 messages

Yuoaman wrote...

andrew252 wrote...

honestly i wouldnt care as long as hes not the only living one,if it turns out hes the sole survivor then its a big nono but if you find a colony still living then i will let them get away with it.The only bad thing i c is that its a 1st day dlc,way around that is to stall it for bout 3-4 months


Javik is the only one.

well now i can c more light on the other side argument,if hes the only one alive that makes him wee bit important now isnt it :P

#8468
BaronIveagh

BaronIveagh
  • Members
  • 680 messages

breadedpudding wrote...

No one has any proof that Prothy is plot essential until they play the game/DLC. Yes, he's a Prothean and I understand the importance of the race to some of us, the players, but how many characters in the game are going to believe he's a Prothean and not just a Collector or some other disguised or modified race? In game, no one really, truly knows WHAT Protheans even looked like 50,000 years ago. For that, how will they care? If they did believe, would they honestly believe he'd have some insight into how to defeat the Reapers, when the Protheans to begin with were more or less wiped out by them? Plus, you know... the galaxy is kind of going to hell in a hand basket, so I would think some folks would have more important things to worry about than some random alien popping up and claiming to be part of an extinct race.


What does that have ot do with what I wrote?  All it said was that they had the same preproduction phase and that teh protehan would have been excised in the production phase.  (since he does have audio in the game)

#8469
ArkkAngel007

ArkkAngel007
  • Members
  • 2 514 messages

breadedpudding wrote...

BaronIveagh wrote...

Mclouvins wrote...

Once again img.gawkerassets.com/img/17eig06xukt8apng/original.png


You know, people keep brandishing that around like it has meaning, but the funny part is, it's wrong. 

http://s16.postimage...rrected_map.jpg

That's what it would look like inthis case, because the Prothean was excised during production, not preproduction.


No one has any proof that Prothy is plot essential until they play the game/DLC. Yes, he's a Prothean and I understand the importance of the race to some of us, the players, but how many characters in the game are going to believe he's a Prothean and not just a Collector or some other disguised or modified race? In game, no one really, truly knows WHAT Protheans even looked like 50,000 years ago. For that, how will they care? If they did believe, would they honestly believe he'd have some insight into how to defeat the Reapers, when the Protheans to begin with were more or less wiped out by them? Plus, you know... the galaxy is kind of going to hell in a hand basket, so I would think some folks would have more important things to worry about than some random alien popping up and claiming to be part of an extinct race. 


Spoiler'd Commiserating Group would like a word with you ;)

I can understand why people want Javik to be important.  I just don't understand how they can't understand that their opinion doesn't supercede the writing in the game.

Modifié par ArkkAngel007, 25 février 2012 - 04:42 .


#8470
omnitremere

omnitremere
  • Members
  • 530 messages

obie191970 wrote...

I012345 wrote...

I just read about this DLC and listened to the Totalbiscuits video. I'm a huge fan of DLC and have bought ever single DLC Bioware has ever released since the XBOX came out. And I gotta say this is a really ****ty move on their part. I believe Mr. Gamble when he says it was not part of the original game and that they developed it separately. But you chose to develop a goddamn Prothean squad member as optional content. Considering the lore of Mass Effect that's flat out ridiculous. And then you charge $10 for it? Sleazy. Pure, plain and simple.

I've always been quick to dismiss people who have said Bioware's partnership with EA is toxic. The ones who continually stated that EA would change Bioware's way of doing business and ultimately hurt the customers who have followed them all these years. But between this DLC, the Deception debacle, and the Dragon Age 2 disaster I'm seriously questioning whether or not the naysayers have been right all along. Again I've bought every Bioware game and DLC since KOTOR. So this isn't somebody standing on the sidelines pointing fingers at your content. This is a loyal rabid fan saying what you're doing is FLAT OUT WRONG.


Unfortunately, if they didn't charge for it, then everyone who puchased the CE would be up in arms.  Bioware put themselves between a rock and a hard place with this one.  It is a crappy situation for sure.  The way I look at it, I get more out of Bioware's games for my gaming buck so the extra $10, while completely uncalled for, is not that bad.


I don't have a problem with DLC that is exclusive to the Collector's edition.  I loved my Collector Rifle from ME2 and could care less about the people who didn't get it.  But a prothean squad member? That's just wrong. 

#8471
Monochrome Wench

Monochrome Wench
  • Members
  • 373 messages
CH says 'Free' must be absolute truth
CH says 'developed after main game finished' must be a lie

#8472
BaronIveagh

BaronIveagh
  • Members
  • 680 messages

ArkkAngel007 wrote...
Spoiler'd Commiserating Group would like a word with you ;)

I can understand why people want Javik to be important.  I just don't understand how they can't understand that their opinion doesn't supercede the writing in the game.


What's funny is it's clear no one bothered to look at the correct chart and just spouted garbage. 

#8473
ZX12r Ninja

ZX12r Ninja
  • Members
  • 212 messages

Monochrome Wench wrote...

CH says 'Free' must be absolute truth
CH says 'developed after main game finished' must be a lie


Give this guy a beer.

#8474
ArkkAngel007

ArkkAngel007
  • Members
  • 2 514 messages

BaronIveagh wrote...

breadedpudding wrote...

No one has any proof that Prothy is plot essential until they play the game/DLC. Yes, he's a Prothean and I understand the importance of the race to some of us, the players, but how many characters in the game are going to believe he's a Prothean and not just a Collector or some other disguised or modified race? In game, no one really, truly knows WHAT Protheans even looked like 50,000 years ago. For that, how will they care? If they did believe, would they honestly believe he'd have some insight into how to defeat the Reapers, when the Protheans to begin with were more or less wiped out by them? Plus, you know... the galaxy is kind of going to hell in a hand basket, so I would think some folks would have more important things to worry about than some random alien popping up and claiming to be part of an extinct race.


What does that have ot do with what I wrote?  All it said was that they had the same preproduction phase and that teh protehan would have been excised in the production phase.  (since he does have audio in the game)


He was excised in the pre-production phase.  Again, he never made it past concept.  It was a different Prothean than Javik.

Javik was created in the production/post-production phase to be solely DLC.  His VO session was done with the rest of the VO work, and certain markers had to be programmed into cinematics to designate his appearance, just like with other DLC characters in the past.

#8475
BaronIveagh

BaronIveagh
  • Members
  • 680 messages

ArkkAngel007 wrote...

He was excised in the pre-production phase.  Again, he never made it past concept.  It was a different Prothean than Javik.

Javik was created in the production/post-production phase to be solely DLC.  His VO session was done with the rest of the VO work, and certain markers had to be programmed into cinematics to designate his appearance, just like with other DLC characters in the past.


Eh, stop and think about what you just wrote.  All that audio and programming would still have taken place during the main games production phase to work.  Becasue it would ahve failed in the testing phase if they didn't have working code for the DLC to test it with.  Meaning they would have had to share a pre-production phase.