RiouHotaru wrote...To put it simply, this argument falls completely flat. Why? Because those other features you mentioned? Aren't optional. They are core features. You're fabricating a possible what-if scenario in an attempt to make the situation appear worse. It's true, there's a possibilty (though infintessimally small) that a company could decide to chop a game up like that. But it hasn't happened yet. Hasn't happened ever in the history of Bioware. And to say that we're "okay" with it implies they're doing something wrong.
If the anti Day-1 folks want to make an argument, do so without the slippery slope of "If you let them do this they WILL do this" or the "It's like buying a car with no wheels". None of those two examples fit, and you know it. It doesn't help your case.
"You're fabricating a possible what-if scenario in an attempt to make the situation appear worse."
Urm yeah, to highlight how the situation may be further down the line.
Isn't that what it is all about though? The situation has been and is getting worse. So where do they stop? Who decides what becomes core features and what becomes bonus content? At the moment the ratio may be 95/5 (C/B) but that is changing quickly.
"that a company could decide to chop a game up like that. But it hasn't happened yet."
A lot of people are claiming that this is exactly what is happening here, you don't offer anything to contradict that.
Instead of us having to make an argument however, lets for a change let a pro day 1 DLC argument be tabled.
Can you justify day 1 DLC, in what way is it good for you and/or the community? How would it be worse to not have day 1 DLC?