Aller au contenu

Photo

IGN Review in Progress (UPDATED: Review Part 3: Final Update! + Videos: The citadel, the brute)


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
806 réponses à ce sujet

#1
Abisco

Abisco
  • Members
  • 430 messages
 Here's their review in progress by IGN's Colin Moriarty, which will be updated a total of 3 times in the next 7 days:

Mass Effect 3 Review in Progress Part 1: The basics (This is just page 3-4 of the Q & A link below)
Mass Effect 3 Review in Progress Part 2: Q & A (19 Questions & Answers)
Mass Effect 3 Review in Progress Part 3: Final Update NEW

ARTICLES
The Galaxy Map
The Normandy
The Atlas Mech

VIDEOS
Exploring the Galaxy Map
Mars Combat
Hijacking an atlas (Video's background MAY be a spoiler)
A Tour of the New Normandy
Attempting to download From Ashes DLC (Not really that important since they fail)
Tour of the Citadel NEW (BLASTO!!!!) (1:02 - Sheppard AI?!)
Meet the Brute NEW

From the IGN Review in Progress - Day 1

On PS3 Issues
It's also worth noting that a few technical issues arise on the PS3 version as soon as you start playing, too. Fairly serious framerate issues plague the opening cinematic on Earth, and while this particular problem clears up as you play further through the game via future cutscenes, these hitches certainly concerned me early on. Likewise, lip-syncing is almost always off and characters sometimes appear stiff and can even flicker in and out of cutscenes when camera angles change. 

The good news is that these problems don't injure a title that relies almost entirely on its otherwise top-notch presentation. If you can get past these sorts of aesthetical hiccups, you'll find a title drowning in a deep, well-fleshed out story surrounded by intriguing characters, both familiar and unfamiliar.

On shooting mechanics
In fact, I rather enjoy Mass Effect 3's combat, and find it stronger than most third-person shooters. That speaks volumes about a game where story and role-playing sit paramount over actual gameplay. 

On war assets and Exploration
Now, your focus apart from questing is on developing and retaining precious war assets while scanning the known galaxy's solar systems for a much more limited array of planets to land on, items to find and more. 


From the IGN Review in Progress - Day 2 - Q & A


On touching moments
Colin answers... Mass Effect 3 portrays inter-character stories exceptionally well. So far during my playthrough, Mass Effect 3 has turned in some of the most touching moments in the entire series, and I expect more to come.

On how the PS3 version feels
But when you get into the nitty-gritty, undeniable technical problems present themselves in the game. The problems have subsided for me on PlayStation 3 the further I've gotten into the game, and I don't think it's because I've "gotten used to" what I am seeing. Things really seem to have improved. Why that is remains to be seen.

On reputation
The conclusion we've thus drawn is that Reputation contributes to your Paragon or Renegade standing generally, but that Reputation points in a vacuum are given neutrally and contribute to your character's slant. Either way, your Reputation seems to give you extra cachet with characters during conversations in addition to the typical Paragon and Renegade conversation options.

On Side Quests
One of the more unfortunate aspects of Mass Effect 3, therefore, is that a lot of the game's side quest have very little to do with that larger Reaper threat, and have more to do with ancillary tasks. Some of these tasks -- such as N7 missions -- do connect to the game's main narrative, but there's enough disconnected from the main story that many things admittedly seem out of place.

There are other concerns I have with side quests. One concern centers on the sheer amount of random side quests earned when running through places like the Citadel. Overhearing random characters speaking triggered side quests in past Mass Effect games, but in Mass Effect 3, this is brought to an almost absurd level. You can earn multiple side quests within a minute of each other by running through a new area of the Citadel, for instance, without having known to listen to the actual conversations for context. And the codex does a poor job of explaining your actual task. All of this comes off as a bit sloppy and unnecessary.

The other complaint pertains to side quest timing. I've failed several side quests because I didn't do them soon enough, but you're never given much of an explanation of timeliness, or given fair warning that time is even a threat. So take heed from my experience, and knock out side quests as soon as you earn them. Otherwise, you may eventually get cut off from them forever.


From the IGN Review in Progress - Day 3 - Final Update


On comparison to ME2

Mass Effect 3 actually felt weaker in many ways when compared to Mass Effect 2 just because it set the bar so high. But now, my feelings have markedly changed.

This change only made itself clear 15 or 20 hours into the game, when it becomes overwhelmingly obvious how intricately woven the sum parts of the Mass Effect series are. I found myself continually shaking my head in awe as things came together, not only from Mass Effect 2, but from Mass Effect itself. Even though I'm playing "fresh" on PlayStation 3, my extensive experience with Mass Effect and Mass Effect 2 on Xbox 360 allowed me to appreciate all of the odes, both major and minor, being thrown out to characters, events and conversations that had occurred in previous games.


On overall thoughts

Mass Effect 3 marks the culmination of the most engrossing, engaging and entertaining story ever told in gaming's winding history. 


Modifié par Abisco, 02 mars 2012 - 03:39 .


#2
nickkcin11

nickkcin11
  • Members
  • 439 messages
Do they have an Xbox/PC one? No offense but the PS3 version is worse since your decisions can't carry over from ME1.

#3
Legion64

Legion64
  • Members
  • 2 126 messages
I heard IGN got a hold of one of the games from space or got a hold of ME3 somehow. Something like that. All I know is, they better be fair.

#4
FlashedMyDrive

FlashedMyDrive
  • Members
  • 1 153 messages
This guy sounds extremely bias. I don't doubt that he will give ME3 at least a 9 out of 10.

#5
Nathan Redgrave

Nathan Redgrave
  • Members
  • 2 062 messages

Legion64 wrote...

I heard IGN got a hold of one of the games from space or got a hold of ME3 somehow. Something like that. All I know is, they better be fair.


That makes sense; they would certainly have more free time and resources to go hunting the damn things down than your average layabout.

#6
Abisco

Abisco
  • Members
  • 430 messages
No no, they already got their copy
The space copy they plan on giving away.

#7
TexasToast712

TexasToast712
  • Members
  • 4 384 messages
 Mass Effect is the only series that IGN actually gives credit that is deserved. They genuinely love Mass Effect. Their reviews of other games are atrocious.

#8
Legion64

Legion64
  • Members
  • 2 126 messages
Pfffffh, I would rather hunt down a copy from space then go for a give away from IGN.

#9
nickkcin11

nickkcin11
  • Members
  • 439 messages
I saw them mark down Minecraft for its graphics... failure.

On a more serious tone,
"It's also worth noting that a few technical issues arise on the PS3
version as soon as you start playing, too. Fairly serious framerate
issues plague the opening cinematic on Earth, and while this particular
problem clears up as you play further through the game via future
cutscenes, these hitches certainly concerned me early on. Likewise,
lip-syncing is almost always off and characters sometimes appear stiff
and can even flicker in and out of cutscenes when camera angles change."

Uggg. BW, really? That's bushleague. If you were a man, I'd punch you. I'd punch you right in the mouth. Hopefully they fix the animations and textures and lip-syncing. And apparently full on cutscene problems. The hell?:sick:

Modifié par nickkcin11, 25 février 2012 - 01:58 .


#10
hotdogbsg

hotdogbsg
  • Members
  • 832 messages
Chris said they were aware of the framerate issues for the PS3 and they were being addressed.

However, nothing has been said since, which is worrying, two weeks from release.

#11
felipejiraya

felipejiraya
  • Members
  • 2 392 messages
There a nice video on the new Galaxy Map on their site.

#12
Texhnolyze101

Texhnolyze101
  • Members
  • 3 313 messages
Nobody cares about what those pro-sopa a**holes have to say.

#13
Pee Jae

Pee Jae
  • Members
  • 4 085 messages
Hmm. Most gaming sites get pre-release copies of the game for review anyway. Some of the things he's talking about may have been fixed in retail.

#14
LiquidLogic2020

LiquidLogic2020
  • Members
  • 402 messages

TexasToast712 wrote...

 Mass Effect is the only series that IGN actually gives credit that is deserved. They genuinely love Mass Effect. Their reviews of other games are atrocious.


That is probaly one of the most biased things I've read all day. 

#15
Vez04

Vez04
  • Members
  • 4 260 messages
That Mars Music is from the Voice Cast trailer!!!!!!!!!!

Ive wanted that as an MP3 ever since i heard it!

Someone extract that music please?!

#16
AxisEvolve

AxisEvolve
  • Members
  • 2 738 messages
Review previews? Pretty dumb idea.. Just post the review.

#17
Atakuma

Atakuma
  • Members
  • 5 609 messages
Well, the new video they posted of mars proves that the animations have not improved.

Modifié par Atakuma, 25 février 2012 - 02:05 .


#18
Nathan Redgrave

Nathan Redgrave
  • Members
  • 2 062 messages

FlashedMyDrive wrote...

This guy sounds extremely bias. I don't doubt that he will give ME3 at least a 9 out of 10.


The reviewer seems to have a noticible bias toward a positive impression, but not to the point where he fails to mention key flaws--even if he may not actually see them as flaws when mentioning them. So far, everything worth talking about seems accounted for, but just because you have a negative opinion on a given aspect doesn't mean everyone who looks at it is going to see it the same way.

#19
Nathan Redgrave

Nathan Redgrave
  • Members
  • 2 062 messages

Atakuma wrote...

Well the new video they posted of mars proves that the animations have not improved.


And anyone who really expected them to deserves diappointment.

Mind you, I still think they look fine when the characters are armored.

#20
Nathan Redgrave

Nathan Redgrave
  • Members
  • 2 062 messages

LiquidLogic2020 wrote...

TexasToast712 wrote...

 Mass Effect is the only series that IGN actually gives credit that is deserved. They genuinely love Mass Effect. Their reviews of other games are atrocious.


That is probaly one of the most biased things I've read all day. 


Well, it varies from reviewer to reviewer. I find myself disagreeing with IGN more often than not, but even a broken clock is right twice a day.

#21
Atakuma

Atakuma
  • Members
  • 5 609 messages

Nathan Redgrave wrote...

Atakuma wrote...

Well the new video they posted of mars proves that the animations have not improved.


And anyone who really expected them to deserves diappointment.

Mind you, I still think they look fine when the characters are armored.

They look better when armored but they are still worse than they were in ME2, which is kind of baffling to me.

#22
Guest_D3MON-SOVER3IGN_*

Guest_D3MON-SOVER3IGN_*
  • Guests

Atakuma wrote...

Well, the new video they posted of mars proves that the animations have not improved.


True, at least they added animations though

#23
Squallypo

Squallypo
  • Members
  • 1 348 messages
i has the sensation that me3 mp ruined the combat experience for me.
lets see if someone knows what i mean with that.

#24
Texhnolyze101

Texhnolyze101
  • Members
  • 3 313 messages
The regular movement speed is still garbage....i do NOT WANT TO SPRINT EVERY DAMN WHERE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

#25
LiquidLogic2020

LiquidLogic2020
  • Members
  • 402 messages

Nathan Redgrave wrote...

LiquidLogic2020 wrote...

TexasToast712 wrote...

 Mass Effect is the only series that IGN actually gives credit that is deserved. They genuinely love Mass Effect. Their reviews of other games are atrocious.


That is probaly one of the most biased things I've read all day. 


Well, it varies from reviewer to reviewer. I find myself disagreeing with IGN more often than not, but even a broken clock is right twice a day.


I've not trusted them since they slated chromehounds, that game was truly briliant.