450 réponses à ce sujet

[Ianamus]

While DA2 reviews may have been positive all of the issues present in the final game like the repetetive area's and tired combat were mentioned in reviews. This review on the other hand doesn't mention anything that could seriously lower the quality of the game, as the AI and graphics never bothered me that much.

[Gibb_Shepard]

Candidate 88766 wrote...

Guldhun2 wrote...

BatmanPWNS wrote...

BobSmith101 wrote...

BatmanPWNS wrote...

This is the highest they have given a ME game. So it's still all good.

They gave DA2 87%.....

And?

It's only worth a score of around 60%

I think you forgot to put the words 'in', 'my' and 'opinion' in there somewhere.

Actually, DA2 is one of the few objectively bad games out there.  Unfortunate, but true.

[Garrus30]

don-mika wrote...

tl: (there might be some not so well translated parts )

Graphics: -/10
+ fantastic animations
+ detailed characters
+ nice effects
- some boring/dull environments
? how good does the PC Version looks?

Sound: 10/10
+ very good german voices (not important here)
+ very good sound effects in surround sound
+ good atmospheric soundtrack
+ good ambient sounds

Balance: 9/10
+ 3 difficulty levels
+ good Weapon Balance
+ challenging (but no unfair) fights
- skills aren't so good balanced

Atmosphere: 9/10
+ complex and thought through World
+ unspent scenario
+ interesting squad members
+ big freedom of choice
- some lifeless levels (dunno how I can translate that)

Controls: -/10
+ useful hotbar
+ intuitive Keyboard & Mouse controls
+ tidied up interface
(dunno how I can translate that)

? how does the Keyboard & Mouse controls work? 

Complexity: 9/10 (dunno how I can translate that)
+ big galaxy, many showplaces
+ reasonable singleplayer playtime
+ many side quests
+ high replay value
+ Coop Mode

Quests/Story: 10/10
+ exciting and plot twisting (main) quests
+ epic story
+ lots of creeps moments
+ fantastic ending

Character System: 10/10
+ complex characters
+ cultures, races and politics
+ no clichés
+ good skill and influence system
+ cool character classes

Battle System: 8/10
+ easily accessible, fast-paced battles
+ Pause Mode
+ useful squad members
- stupid Enemy AI
- a lot of simple shooting

Items: 9/10
+ Biotics, drones, Ammunition types
+ weapon types, grenades and upgrades...
-... but only a few.

Modifié par Garrus30, 25 février 2012 - 02:28 .

[FluffyScarf]

Seems like a honest review to me. And simple shooting is a problem in both ME 1/2 anyway. Many thanks for the translation.

Modifié par FluffyScarf, 25 février 2012 - 02:21 .

[Bleachrude]

Um, no...DA2 is not "objectively bad"

Sword of the Stars 2 is objectively bad (doesn't work at release).

DA2 simply is "meh". Worth my money but basically forgettable...

From any other studio (even Obsidian), I think DA2 would've gotten a "shows potential, but needs some work" but this is Bioware...

As another poster mentioned, many of the reviews did make note of the "waves of enemies" and the "repeated environments" yet for many, it wasn't that big a deal...

[TenmaTaro]

What games are people playing that have such godly textures (consoles)?

[FluffyScarf]

Explain.

[lukex38]

AeonFrog wrote...

What games are people playing that have such godly textures (consoles)?

killzone 3, uncharted 2, best looking games on console

[FluffyScarf]

No love for UNC 3?

[Catsith]

I still want to know, in detail, what their complaints about the AI were, because the demo (both singleplayer and multiplayer) showed more intelligent AI than ME1 and ME2 combined.

[VinWizzy]

First of all I want to ask why are more people so far reviewing the game on the PS3. Colin Moriarty on IGN is reviewing it and said it had issues. Why isn't it that somebody who played both Mass Effect games playing it with an import Shepard. If its because they don't want to seem biased with a "fanboy" reviewing it then all I ask is look at Greg's Uncharted 3 review...

[FluffyScarf]

Maybe they had higher standards? The AI can now climb and aren't stumped by slightly elevated terrain like in a certain other fantasy argh-pee-gee.

[Rickin10]

Catsith wrote...

I still want to know, in detail, what their complaints about the AI were, because the demo (both singleplayer and multiplayer) showed more intelligent AI than ME1 and ME2 combined.

In the demo, even though i agree the ai was substantially better than the previous games - mostly more agressive, flanking etc, there were a few occasions when i got round behind them, and even though i was blowing the crap out of them, they ignored me and continued firing over cover at my teammates.

[ttchip]

Catsith wrote...

I still want to know, in detail, what their complaints about the AI were, because the demo (both singleplayer and multiplayer) showed more intelligent AI than ME1 and ME2 combined.

Compare that to games with actually good AI. Crytek games come to mind on that one.

[Wittand25]

Gibb_Shepard wrote...

Candidate 88766 wrote...

Guldhun2 wrote...

BatmanPWNS wrote...

BobSmith101 wrote...

BatmanPWNS wrote...

This is the highest they have given a ME game. So it's still all good.

They gave DA2 87%.....

And?

It's only worth a score of around 60%

I think you forgot to put the words 'in', 'my' and 'opinion' in there somewhere.

Actually, DA2 is one of the few objectively bad games out there.  Unfortunate, but true.

You either are joking or you have not played many games in your life.
DA2 might be disappointing because it was clearly rushed and they cut far to many corners but saying DA2 is bad, means you have to invent a new language to describe the myriad of games that are far, far, far worse than it.

[XyleJKH]

Review seems positive though

[Garrus30]

Well I think, for example  if in one game
 the AI is very good or actually the best at the current time, than they take this as a standard and compare it to this game on each review.

Modifié par Garrus30, 25 février 2012 - 02:39 .

[AngryFrozenWater]

The things summarized in the OP sound good. No game is perfect, but the list of positive things is long. I do keep my expectations low, though. I still remember the good reviews of DA2 and how the game turned out to be. Still, the list is impressive.

[Techlology]

ttchip wrote...

Catsith wrote...

I still want to know, in detail, what their complaints about the AI were, because the demo (both singleplayer and multiplayer) showed more intelligent AI than ME1 and ME2 combined.

Compare that to games with actually good AI. Crytek games come to mind on that one.

This, pretty much. While less retarded than the previous ME games, they are still nothing to write home about.

Modifié par Techlology, 25 février 2012 - 02:42 .

[FluffyScarf]

Crysis 2 isn't exactly known for having good AI. There are even YT videos mocking it, especially the alien AI.

And as for Crysis 1:

Of course, that was from the demo.

Modifié par FluffyScarf, 25 février 2012 - 02:42 .

[lukex38]

FluffyScarf wrote...

No love for UNC 3?

i love uncharted 3, but in some areas it didnt look as good as the rest of the game 
, the mission where you go to the french castle that cutscene didnt look very good, the textures were really bad in that bit, and there are a few other times, not alot though, but uncharted 2 was more consistant with its beauty

[Dormin]

This has lifted my spirits! The demo wasn't great to be honest.