980 réponses à ce sujet

[Arppis]

jreezy wrote...

Liara T wrote...

 

Wow. I can't believe I didn't notice the utter fail until now.

Yarps. It's not just her arms.

[Chromie]

makalathbonagin wrote...

Demonique wrote...

Her arms are way too skinny and she has no muscle definition

Something like this would have been much more appropriate

In case it doesn't show, it's a gif of cage-fighter Gina Carano getting ready for a pre-fight weigh-in

no hips
no ass
ugly manish body
huge ******
horseface
BSN: She's perfect!!

no thank you, i prefer my femshep to look like a woman

Thank you so much. I've been saving this.

 

[Arppis]

Ringo12 wrote...

Thank you so much. I've been saving this.

 

THAT was funny. Thank you for posting it! 

[Chromie]

makalathbonagin wrote...

^ and i rather have her as femshep than OP's fapfantasy

Why should male Shepard be all buff but female Shepard a pear? It's not like the chick look manish in any way. She still has breast (great pair), lean stomach and muscles just look at her arm.

Modifié par Ringo12, 28 février 2012 - 09:27 .

[Arppis]

Ringo12 wrote...

makalathbonagin wrote...

^ and i rather have her as femshep than OP's fapfantasy

Why should male Shepard be all buff but female Shepard a pear?

I guess female Shepard IS Bizzarro Shepard after all! She's the mirror of Male Shepard!

Look, other is like pear upside down and other is pear downside up...err... well you get he jist of it!

[_symphony]

both Shepards are bizarre.

[Arppis]

_symphony wrote...

both Shepards are bizarre.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bizarro

[Hassu]

What I learned from this thread is that no one here knows anything about female anatomy or how muscles work.

Sorry to burst your bubbles.

Modifié par Hassu, 28 février 2012 - 11:06 .

[Nizzemancer]

jreezy wrote...

tobynator89 wrote...

android654 wrote...

tobynator89 wrote...
So freaking what? It's roughly the same model shes always had. As a matter of fact I believe she shares the model with EVERY other humanoid female out there.

You don't see anything wrong with trashing the main character? She's the main character, she should have a different model than every npc, like John does. She also deserves a casual outfit that isn't ridiculous.

john has the same build as every other human male except vega and jacob as well.  Have you noticed that joker and shep are exactly alike for example? even though joker is sickly and weak.

Since when was Joker sickly?

Hello

[MsKlaussen]

Hassu wrote...

What I learned from this thread is that no one here knows anything about female anatomy or how muscles work.

Sorry to break your bubbles.

If you don't mind I'll consider what I've seen in the mirror for 3 decades knowledge enough until such time as I see something like Mick Jagger in there, complete with knee scraping bewbs - at which time I will either race madly to the computer to glean answers from your breathtakingly unilluminating post...or claw my own eyes out with a staple remover. Whichever offers relief from the pain the loudest.   

[hangmans tree]

Stanley Woo wrote...

People are a diverse collection of different genetics and body types. check out this pictorial (warning: athletes in underwear) featuring the body types of many different athletes. You will see that even among those in the same field of athletics, there is a variety of body shapes and sizes.

Sure, every person has their own stereotypes of what a soldier "should" look like, based on historical depictions of soldiers in media, their own experiences, and what have you. But as the linked pictorial shows, people do come in all shapes and sizes, and perhaps we as a media culture should start accepting that different body shapes can still represent strength.

You are stretching it a bit
Female model is disproportional in hips-waist-shoulders. And IT SHOWS.
I study anatomy most of my life. I know its a toon, and ppl are different in sizes and shapes (as many as they come). Making exaggeration, tweak the truth a bit is ok with me. Striving for something inaccurate in a game is a mistake - whatever the industry standard may be...

[tmp7704]

Liara T wrote...

 

Err, what?

the "pear" shape is otherwise referred to as "spoon" shape. It's second most frequent body type amongst women, by the looks of it.

http://www.freedieti.../body_shape.htm
http://www.independe...ars-516259.html

edit: and some valuable context for that "no shape for a girl" image: http://karisheridanw...s-no-shape.html

Modifié par tmp7704, 28 février 2012 - 10:51 .

[Random citizen]

The Woldan wrote...

makalathbonagin wrote...

Demonique wrote...

Her arms are way too skinny and she has no muscle definition

Something like this would have been much more appropriate

In case it doesn't show, it's a gif of cage-fighter Gina Carano getting ready for a pre-fight weigh-in

no hips
no ass
ugly manish body
huge ******
horseface
BSN: She's perfect!!

no thank you, i prefer my femshep to look like a woman

Are you on drugs? 

Well, if not, there is still some type of problem going on.

Look, I do not get it. while some people are obviously just trolling and joking around about a more muscular femshep looking "manly" I would like to ask those being serious to think about that we are talking about a soldier here. Since that profession requires strength and ability to kick ass, she should look the part.
And there is nothing "manly" about  a athletic woman, unless you think that strength and a physique that bear witness to it is solely in the male domain.

[Arppis]

hangmans tree wrote...

Stanley Woo wrote...

People are a diverse collection of different genetics and body types. check out this pictorial (warning: athletes in underwear) featuring the body types of many different athletes. You will see that even among those in the same field of athletics, there is a variety of body shapes and sizes.

Sure, every person has their own stereotypes of what a soldier "should" look like, based on historical depictions of soldiers in media, their own experiences, and what have you. But as the linked pictorial shows, people do come in all shapes and sizes, and perhaps we as a media culture should start accepting that different body shapes can still represent strength.

You are stretching it a bit
Female model is disproportional in hips-waist-shoulders. And IT SHOWS.
I study anatomy most of my life. I know its a toon, and ppl are different in sizes and shapes (as many as they come). Making exaggeration, tweak the truth a bit is ok with me. Striving for something inaccurate in a game is a mistake - whatever the industry standard may be...

Well for his defense. I guess one could argue that there are women who have body shaped like that.

[Arppis]

tmp7704 wrote...

Err, what?

the "pear" shape is otherwise referred to as "spoon" shape. It's second most frequent body type amongst women, by the looks of it.

http://www.freedieti.../body_shape.htm
http://www.independe...ars-516259.html

edit: and some valuable context for that "no shape for a girl" image: http://karisheridanw...s-no-shape.html

I think that's interesting read, the shapes of the body I mean. Thanks for it. And you have a point, maybe I was bit too harsh judging the lowerbody of hers.

I still the think the arms are pretty poorly designed.

[Hassu]

MsKlaussen wrote...

If you don't mind I'll consider what I've seen in the mirror for 3 decades knowledge enough until such time as I see something like Mick Jagger in there, complete with knee scraping bewbs - at which time I will either race madly to the computer to glean answers from your breathtakingly unilluminating post...or claw my own eyes out with a staple remover. Whichever offers relief from the pain the loudest.   

I shall eagerly await for that day to come.

In the meantime, I'll just have to endure the colossal magnitude of complaints about the most inane topics these forums suffer from. 

[Random citizen]

Arppis wrote...

tmp7704 wrote...

Err, what?

the "pear" shape is otherwise referred to as "spoon" shape. It's second most frequent body type amongst women, by the looks of it.

http://www.freedieti.../body_shape.htm
http://www.independe...ars-516259.html

edit: and some valuable context for that "no shape for a girl" image: http://karisheridanw...s-no-shape.html

I think that's interesting read, the shapes of the body I mean. Thanks for it. And you have a point, maybe I was bit too harsh judging the lowerbody of hers.

I still the think the arms are pretty poorly designed.

Yes, they should be more muscular. That pose is strange, but she is in movement. (her arms should "fall" closer to the body)

[PXXL]

Don't worry BioWare, the straight male approves of FemShep's hips and current thickness of her arms.

[Arppis]

Random citizen wrote...

Arppis wrote...

tmp7704 wrote...

Err, what?

the "pear" shape is otherwise referred to as "spoon" shape. It's second most frequent body type amongst women, by the looks of it.

http://www.freedieti.../body_shape.htm
http://www.independe...ars-516259.html

edit: and some valuable context for that "no shape for a girl" image: http://karisheridanw...s-no-shape.html

I think that's interesting read, the shapes of the body I mean. Thanks for it. And you have a point, maybe I was bit too harsh judging the lowerbody of hers.

I still the think the arms are pretty poorly designed.

Yes, they should be more muscular. That pose is strange, but she is in movement. (her arms should "fall" closer to the body)

I remember someone using Bruce Lee as comparison. But the thing is, because he doesn't have almost any fat, his muscles show pretty much all the time.

But again I am no expert, so might just be that I am mega wrong. *shrug*

[Sporothrix]

PXXL wrote...

Don't worry BioWare, the straight male approves of FemShep's hips and current thickness of her arms.

And who cares about that if those who will actually play the character disapprove? It's just pathetic - she's a soldier and looks like she never carried anything heavier than a purse.

[tmp7704]

Arppis wrote...
I still the think the arms are pretty poorly designed.

The arm thing, i'm of two minds about. On one hand, i wouldn't say they're too thin as far as body proportions go -- shape/geometry-wise they're actually probably better in that regard than it's normal for computer game models and far from 'twigs'. On the other hand though, i can see why people would want the shape to be made thicker, given Shepard's background et all. And the normal map they've used for her doesn't help.

edit: the problem imo isn't as much female Shepard model, but the overly muscular male models -- when she's routinely placed next to multiple such characters, she is bound to appear too frail, relatively.

Modifié par tmp7704, 28 février 2012 - 11:14 .

[Hassu]

misoretu9 wrote...

PXXL wrote...

Don't worry BioWare, the straight male approves of FemShep's hips and current thickness of her arms.

And who cares about that if those who will actually play the character disapprove? It's just pathetic - she's a soldier and looks like she never carried anything heavier than a purse.

She's a woman. Military or not, that's what fit women look like. The military doesn't make you muscular or bulky, it makes you fit. This has been pointed out a thousand times, yet it's obvious no one is paying attention.