7 réponses à ce sujet

[Madanial]

There is a crazy guy(user name "123") claim that Elf was Kemonomimi...(wtf?)

I know you may unable to read Thai language, but my point is.

How do you think about his idea?Is Elf really a part of Kemonomimi?

(Jeez,J.R.R. Tolkien must cry when he heard that guy said)

[Haasth]

No. It's definitely not. Honestly the whole anime (Which is what I think a 'kemonomimisomething' is from, right?) culture should stay away from the, I'll go ahead and call it Western, fantasy world! J.R.R Tolkien would turn around in his grave.

[Madanial]

Yeah, i think so.



This guys just keep claiming that he was right and others was wrong.So crazy,isn't it?

[Twitchmonkey]

Pretty sure elves are an ~10th century pagan symbol. Not much anime or manga going on then.

[Morthrax Kildara]

What a load of BS...

Elves are not thought op by the Japanese. Who is this guy?

[Madanial]

He's one of the lamest person in comic and game industry in Thailand.Even got himself recorded in Uncyclopedia.

[kraidy1117]

Elves are depicted from Pagen symbols and Nor mythology, not ****ty anime. J.R.R Tolkien must be very disappointed.

Modifié par kraidy1117, 25 novembre 2009 - 04:12 .

[Mordaedil]

I wouldn't say it's completely wrong, but it's definitely not derivative of that phenomenon.



In actuality, it is reverse; Elves, or rather elven lore and folktales inspired Kemonomimi as well as other anthropomorphic character types.



If he wishes to to claim it's the same regardless, ask him what animal it is derived from. I'd be curious on his answer.