553 réponses à ce sujet

[Kanmuru]

Garrus30 wrote...

Wait if someone dies, they just could revive him/her like what Cerberus did with Shepard in ME2, so that could be the scene after the end credits.

Lol dont forget you need a body to do the lazarus project, there are no bodies to revive after what happens at the end...

[magnuskn]

Imperium Alpha wrote...

I WANT EVERYONE TO SUFFER !!!!  (especially since I don't care about the bad ending and i'l be able to watch all of you consume in chaos on those forum and have fun with it. I know i'm a terrible person )

At least you are not pretending like you have a better sense of storytelling than people who prefer better endings. Puts you one on top on those other guys.

[Femlob]

magnuskn wrote...

Imperium Alpha wrote...

I WANT EVERYONE TO SUFFER !!!!  (especially since I don't care about the bad ending and i'l be able to watch all of you consume in chaos on those forum and have fun with it. I know i'm a terrible person )

At least you are not pretending like you have a better sense of storytelling than people who prefer better endings. Puts you one on top on those other guys.

Call me crazy, but some stories just can't end well.

[dreman9999]

Ryzaki wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...
As nice as that would be....It would be a lie....A war like this would not have any happy end for the hero.....And hereing this and happy for it because I alway suppected it.

This is a video game.

Where the protag has had happy endings for the last 2 in the series. Where yes there is some sacrifices but for the most part? He gets back up and walks with his head high.

That not being in ME3 to me makes it not worth playing. Not  until I can find a copy for like 10 bucks.

Plus optional you don't want happy ending for your Shep? Don't take it.

That means nothing. That's like something sould not be impact full because it's a book/movie/cartoon/play /etc. Why even think like that?

It sound like you just want the happy fantasy, which is my issue with everyone up set with the ending.  It would be a joke if it didn't do this.
It's unrealistic to even think this would end happily.

[AkiKishi]

Kanmuru wrote...
The one choice that dosent have the "bad ending" is just :blink::blink::blink::blink::blink::blink:, and will change all life in the galaxy forever (including shep)

I'm 99% sure I know what that ending will be.

[magnuskn]

Femlob wrote...

I've previously stated that I'm not big on dark endings - but a game centered around galactic genocide should not have a "good" ending for the very simple reason that nothing "good" can come from galactic genocide.

Does the term "suspense of disbelief" mean anything to you at all?

Don't the terms "In your opinion" and "Hey, it's fiction, not real life!" mean anything to you?

[Guldhun2]

They could probably make another cool 20 million by selling the "lol happy end" for 19.99



Well played Bioware, well played.

[Texhnolyze101]

BobSmith101 wrote...

101ezylonhxeT wrote...

Gibb_Shepard wrote...

Just out of pure curiosity, do you guys think Red Dead redemption was a "waste of time" and anticlimactic because of it's ending?

No i knew he was going to die that fat a**hole wasn't just gonna let him walk away in fact RDR has one of the best endings for a game i ever seen. it also didn't help the fact that you kept meeting death throughout your journeys anyone with a brain knew that guy in the top hat was death.

You can't really compare a game with a fixed ending to one with multiple endings. By making it 7 flavours of ****sandwich it cheapens the time the player spends in the game.

I agree i just really liked RDR's ending is all

[panamakira]

Imperium Alpha wrote...

panamakira wrote...

*gasps* Does Shep die? I will literally BURN my copy even though it's a big possibility seeing how everything will blow in our faces a la Reaper.

In case you're wondering I'm just guessing yo~

Yes and no. Depends what choice you take.

That's not surprising. DA:O gave us a similar option and I took it in one of my many playthroughs. Hopefully again, we have an option. Unless of course it's like "save your LI and die or let your LI die and live" kind thing. That might be tragically interesting.

[AkiKishi]

Femlob wrote...

Call me crazy, but some stories just can't end well.

True... Like manga stories about humans and ghosts.

Not really the point though. It's not a book it's not a movie, it's a game with different endings. Your actions should mean something significant as a player in that case.

[eye basher]

magnuskn wrote...

Imperium Alpha wrote...

I WANT EVERYONE TO SUFFER !!!!  (especially since I don't care about the bad ending and i'l be able to watch all of you consume in chaos on those forum and have fun with it. I know i'm a terrible person )

At least you are not pretending like you have a better sense of storytelling than people who prefer better endings. Puts you one on top on those other guys.

I like this guy he gets it is no all sunshine and rainbows besides people always wanted reality in ME and now you have it reality were nothing ever works out the way you wanted it to.

[AkiKishi]

Guldhun2 wrote...

They could probably make another cool 20 million by selling the "lol happy end" for 19.99



Well played Bioware, well played.

Your 18 pages late

[kingsims]

panamakira wrote...

Imperium Alpha wrote...

panamakira wrote...

*gasps* Does Shep die? I will literally BURN my copy even though it's a big possibility seeing how everything will blow in our faces a la Reaper.

In case you're wondering I'm just guessing yo~

Yes and no. Depends what choice you take.

That's not surprising. DA:O gave us a similar option and I took it in one of my many playthroughs. Hopefully again, we have an option. Unless of course it's like "save your LI and die or let your LI die and live" kind thing. That might be tragically interesting.

I hope the LI can live and find happiness after shepard death like a true paragon .

Modifié par kingsims, 28 février 2012 - 03:24 .

[Femlob]

magnuskn wrote...

Femlob wrote...

I've previously stated that I'm not big on dark endings - but a game centered around galactic genocide should not have a "good" ending for the very simple reason that nothing "good" can come from galactic genocide.

Does the term "suspense of disbelief" mean anything to you at all?

Don't the terms "In your opinion" and "Hey, it's fiction, not real life!" mean anything to you?

They do. Neither applies to my previous statement.

Yes, you read that right.

Realistic fiction has to be more believable than reality.

Modifié par Femlob, 28 février 2012 - 03:26 .

[Mims]

The problem isn't just that the ending isn't 'happy', its that the endings don't really seem all that different. Except for the obvious wtf ending.

[magnuskn]

Femlob wrote...

magnuskn wrote...

Imperium Alpha wrote...

I WANT EVERYONE TO SUFFER !!!!  (especially since I don't care about the bad ending and i'l be able to watch all of you consume in chaos on those forum and have fun with it. I know i'm a terrible person )

At least you are not pretending like you have a better sense of storytelling than people who prefer better endings. Puts you one on top on those other guys.

Call me crazy, but some stories just can't end well.

Mass Effect wasn't really that kind of story, from what I played in the first two games.

Again, it's not my story. But it's my money I spend on it, now and ( as I planned originally ) in the future. I am exercising my option to let BioWare know that they cannot rely on me alimenting their future anymore, if they choose to screw the part of the fanbase over to which I belong to.

[ARTHURIUSS]

Ignore the naysayers, the endings are fantastic. If anything appreciate Bioware for having the guts to pull off something like that. Add to that, anyone who's played the game has been nothing but complimentary about the endings. Just because you don't get a happily ever after doesn't mean it's a bad ending.

[Femlob]

ARTHURIUSS wrote...

Ignore the naysayers, the endings are fantastic. If anything appreciate Bioware for having the guts to pull off something like that. Add to that, anyone who's played the game has been nothing but complimentary about the endings. Just because you don't get a happily ever after doesn't mean it's a bad ending.

That's more or less the vibe I'm getting.

But hey, I've got SW:KotOR2:TSL to tide me over. *Goes back to playing*

[magnuskn]

Femlob wrote...

magnuskn wrote...

Femlob wrote...

I've previously stated that I'm not big on dark endings - but a game centered around galactic genocide should not have a "good" ending for the very simple reason that nothing "good" can come from galactic genocide.

Does the term "suspense of disbelief" mean anything to you at all?

Don't the terms "In your opinion" and "Hey, it's fiction, not real life!" mean anything to you?

They do. Neither applies to my previous statement.

Yes, you read that right.

Fiction has to be more believable than reality.

No. It has to be more satisfying. Which means different things to different people. As a multiple options game, Mass Effect 3 should have catered to the different groups, not just one sub-set.

[Texhnolyze101]

ARTHURIUSS wrote...

Ignore the naysayers, the endings are fantastic. If anything appreciate Bioware for having the guts to pull off something like that. Add to that, anyone who's played the game has been nothing but complimentary about the endings. Just because you don't get a happily ever after doesn't mean it's a bad ending.

^

[Femlob]

101ezylonhxeT wrote...

ARTHURIUSS wrote...

Ignore the naysayers, the endings are fantastic. If anything appreciate Bioware for having the guts to pull off something like that. Add to that, anyone who's played the game has been nothing but complimentary about the endings. Just because you don't get a happily ever after doesn't mean it's a bad ending.

^

Petulant little kid.

[Han Shot First]

Darth Malice113 wrote...

noxpanda wrote...

Were talking about how messed up the me3 endings are, they come in terrible, more terrible or just plain old WTF?! variations

Yeah, it's pretty much along the lines of " Would you rather be burned to death, stabbed to death, or stoned to death?"

 What I gather it's basically varying levels of heartbreak.

Varying levels of heartbreak?

Awesome. A fairytale ending full of sunshine, rainbows and buttlerflies should not be possible in the final chapter. This is the most destructive conflict in the collective histories of all the existing spacefaring civilizations combined, and the Reapers are by far the most dangerous enemy any of them has faced. Shepard and his team should not be able to escape unscathed. As much as I loved ME2 one of the great flaws with the Suicide Mission was that it was possible to get everyone through unscathed. That should not be used as a template for the end run of ME3.

If Bioware ignored fan demand from those who cannot accept a little tragedy with their victory, I salute them. Storytelling > fan service

Modifié par Han Shot First, 28 février 2012 - 03:30 .

[AkiKishi]

Well the only review has been complementory about the ending that much is true. Bit of a mixed bag otherwise.

[panamakira]

BobSmith101 wrote...

Femlob wrote...

Call me crazy, but some stories just can't end well.

True... Like manga stories about humans and ghosts.

Not really the point though. It's not a book it's not a movie, it's a game with different endings. Your actions should mean something significant as a player in that case.

I agree with you. If they're giving us a choice with multiple endings in the game at least one has to end in a much positive note than the others, (for me). Otherwise, they should've just had one ending if that was the only possible outcome they could think for the ME story.

IMPENDING DOOM FOR ALL!!!!