553 réponses à ce sujet

[magnuskn]

dreman9999 wrote...

Complining that the character doesn't live is just fanservice. Just like with Reven in tor. And looking at what they did with Reven in tor with Drew being the head writer of that game....I'm guessing he would done the same to Shepard.

And now on "Empty Catchphrase Theater", Dreman complains that people like different things than he does.

Modifié par magnuskn, 28 février 2012 - 04:02 .

[dreman9999]

Ryzaki wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...
BS, if if it was that, people would be crying about it being poorly written not that Shepard died.

If you bother going into the spoiler group yeah we're pretty much saying both. It's poorly written AND Shep died.

Again, it was badlly written than this topic whouldbe filled with pages about how badly written the ending is. All your arguement in this topic was just about not being given a choice in the matter.

[silentspec111]

AllThatJazz wrote...

Indeed. I like sad endings, dark endings endings, whatever you want to call them. And actually, may well be quite satisfied with the way ME3 ends. But you'd imagine that in SEVEN endings, there would be room for one that isn't sad, dark  or outright grim, to cater for those who want just a little bittersweet, or even *gasp* happy ending in their fictional space opera. Otherwise, why have seven in the first place? Just have one ending, and spend all that cutscene money on more side missions. <_<

well said...exactly how i feel about this whole situation they could have included one bittersweet ending and stopped this s***storm from ever happening in the first place

[dreman9999]

magnuskn wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Complining that the character doesn't live is just fanservice. Just like with Reven in tor. And looking at what they did with Reven in tor with Drew being the head writer of that game....I'm guessing he would done the same to Shepard.

And now on "Empty Catchphrase Theater", Dreman complains that people like different things than he does.

I'm notcomplaining that people like different thing. Just that they should be realistic when looking to the ending of this game....It was never going to be a happy ending.

Modifié par dreman9999, 28 février 2012 - 04:05 .

[magnuskn]

Femlob wrote...
I'm the last person to expect anything from anyone - I do, however, take issue with the idea that the entire game sucks and that Mac Walters should be beheaded just because it's not their kind of ending.

Nobody here would be complaining if people who disliked that other ending were given the option to have a good ending.

Ah, well. It's that fundamental difference again. One group wants more options, the other group wants to forbid them to have options they disagree with. I am glad I belong to the first faction.

[Ryzaki]

dreman9999 wrote...
Again, it was badlly written than this topic whouldbe filled with pages about how badly written the ending is. All your arguement in this topic was just about not being given a choice in the matter.

This isn't the spoiler group where we can clearly say what's wrong with it.

Go to the spoiler version of this thread and see if you have the same complaints.

Most of the bad writing stems from how Shep dies and ends up isolated so of course that's where most of the complaints aim to fix. If that's fixed the writing goes from horrible to decent. (Unless they fix it in a crappy manner).

[Savber100]

I love how sad ending>bad ending> bad writing > Bioware is awful

[The Elder King]

Femlob wrote...

hhh89 wrote...

People like different things. I like both happy ending and bittersweet endings, and I'm fine with screwed-up endings, so I'm fine with what happens in ME3. But you can't expect people that like one type of endings to be satisfied with a type of ending that they hate.

I'm the last person to expect anything from anyone - I do, however, take issue with the idea that the entire game sucks and that Mac Walters should be beheaded just because it's not their kind of ending.

Oh, I agree with this. I don't think that the game will suck, and I don't like much the Walters bashing. He's not the only person who wrote the game.

Modifié par hhh89, 28 février 2012 - 04:07 .

[AlphaJarmel]

THE ENDINGS AREN'T REALISTIC ANYWAY

Jesus.

[magnuskn]

dreman9999 wrote...

magnuskn wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Complining that the character doesn't live is just fanservice. Just like with Reven in tor. And looking at what they did with Reven in tor with Drew being the head writer of that game....I'm guessing he would done the same to Shepard.

And now on "Empty Catchphrase Theater", Dreman complains that people like different things than he does.

I'm notcomplaining that people like different thing. Just that they sould be realistic when looking to the ending of this game....I was never going to be a happy ending.

And that's wrong. Hey, you were sent on a suicide mission in ME2. Not much wiggle room there in the phrasing, eh?

Oh, wait, I brought everybody back, because I put the necessary work into doing so ( arguably there could have been more work involved, though... ).

How exactly would I expect ME3 to be a fundamentally different story? Sorry, but I am left supposing that a hopeless scenario is just what you want to see there ( hence condemning every other view as "fanservice" ).

Modifié par magnuskn, 28 février 2012 - 04:08 .

[panamakira]

Oh wow~ It seems we are complaining about options in a game that takes pride in giving options to the players when it comes to the storyline.

Maybe there's a bittersweet ending somewhere in there, I don't know. I don't want a "happy" ending exactly but maybe I wouldn't want Shep to get screwed over completely but I guess that is just what happens to him/her. That choice seems to be out of our hands.

[Ryzaki]

Savber100 wrote...

I love how sad ending>bad ending> bad writing > Bioware is awful

Oh so it makes sense for someone across the area from a Mass Relay (the mass Relay is several planets away from their area) to get sucked into it and plopped into a uncharted world and only a ship crew of people (mixed with some aliens) somehow land on a Eden and start a viable colony? During a space battle and ONLY this ship gets thrown here and all the other ships just keep fighting?!? Oh and the two people with Shepard somehow teleport back to the ship (instead of waiting on Earth for Shepard) and end up on the Eden planet too? 

That makes sense? 

THAT'S GOOD WRITING?!?

Modifié par Ryzaki, 28 février 2012 - 04:10 .

[Kanmuru]

I hope the ****storm will big bigger after the game is out, the same 10 people arguiing each other for 20 pages is not that fun...

[The Elder King]

Ryzaki wrote...

hhh89 wrote...

But they're in part organics. Does this mean that all those melted organics were moron?

Yup.

Oh well, I already had. doubts after meeting Harbinger.

[Yumi50]

magnuskn wrote...

In ME2, you were given the choice of how good your ending would be. If you wanted a real happy ending, you could get it. If you wanted it to be more tragic, you could get that, too. In little variations down to "total devastation".

In ME3, you can get "totally screwed over", "absolutely screwed over", "really, really screwed over" and "no, we weren't kidding, you are screwed over! Haha, thanks for giving us your money. LOSERS!".

I really want to laugh. But I can't. I'm crying. 

[AkiKishi]

dreman9999 wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...
BS, if if it was that, people would be crying about it being poorly written not that Shepard died.

If you bother going into the spoiler group yeah we're pretty much saying both. It's poorly written AND Shep died.

Again, it was badlly written than this topic whouldbe filled with pages about how badly written the ending is. All your arguement in this topic was just about not being given a choice in the matter.

Expect that after release.

Right now people are not equipped to comment on the writing as much as they are to comment on the lack of variety in the endings.

[Total Biscuit]

Ok, for everyone claiming Bioware put realism and storytelling above happy ess and player satisfaction; the endings are wholly unrealistic, totally bollocks, make no real sense, have no explanation for how it works, particularly the so called perfect ending, and you defeat the reapers with the flick of a switch no matter what ending you choose.

The entire thing ends appallingly, not just because it gives fans of the last two games the finger, but because it's flat out badly written nonsense.

The Reapers are defeated no matter what you do, and Shepard does more damage than they get a chamce to do.

[ratzerman]

So after four years and hundreds of dollars, I'm left with nothing but emptiness.

Lesson learned.

[AkiKishi]

Ryzaki wrote...

Savber100 wrote...

I love how sad ending>bad ending> bad writing > Bioware is awful

Oh so it makes sense for someone across the area from a Mass Relay (the mass Relay is several planets away from their area) to get sucked into it and plopped into a uncharted world and only a ship crew of people (mixed with some aliens) somehow land on a Eden and start a viable colony? During a space battle and ONLY this ship gets thrown here and all the other ships just keep fighting?!? Oh and the two people with Shepard somehow teleport back to the ship (instead of waiting on Earth for Shepard) and end up on the Eden planet too? 

That makes sense? 

THAT'S GOOD WRITING?!?

Why does that sound so familiar......

Damm you thats going to bug me now until I figure it out.

[CerberusSoldier]

morrie23 wrote...

The endings will greatly annoy, maybe even upset, a lot of people. BSN is going to burn next week.

  


It has already started 

[MJF JD]

Priestly is at work...

[Illusive]

Aren't there supposed to be 6 different endings? I find it hard to believe they are all completely horrible ...