101103 réponses à ce sujet

[nightcobra]

Little Miss Angel wrote...

nightcobra8928 wrote...

-snip-

i had to close the video after a while, listening to stephen johnson's reasons of why he "liked" the ending(s) was getting my already bottled emotions start to boil. better to close it and cool off, might have needed another laptop otherwise.

What did he say? I couldn't get past the first two minutes

the gist of it is that he loved the ending as he felt it wrapped up everything from me1 and 2 nicely as well the main theme of "organics vs synthetics" and the "created rebelling against the creator".

i sat there thinking....did we play the same trilogy?



ps:just one more day....just one more day...

Modifié par nightcobra8928, 05 avril 2012 - 08:58 .

[IxSITHxI]

Atrocity wrote...

IxSITHxI wrote...
why didnt i get + 10 internets when i posted this?

Because you are a sith and people tend not to give them any internets since they just take internets anyhow?

Good point. I give MYSELF UNLIMTED INTERNETS!! AHAHAHAHAHA!!

[firstarioch]

Reply to Nightcobra8928 :

Who is that guy ?

[nightcobra]

firstarioch wrote...

Reply to Nightcobra8928 :

Who is that guy ?

the old guy in the g4 feedback video i was linked to.

should be around the middle of the video. 

Modifié par nightcobra8928, 05 avril 2012 - 09:03 .

[Atrocity]

nightcobra8928 wrote...


the gist of it is that he loved the ending as he felt it wrapped up everything from me1 and 2 nicely as well the main theme of "organics vs synthetics" and the "created rebelling against the creator".

i sat there thinking....did we play the same trilogy?

How the hell ending wrapped anything up? From those mentioned perspectives it falls flatter on its' face than ever. Created rebelling against the creator? Umm, no one did. It turns out even the geth didn't. I suppose the first stage of EDI, the rogue VI kind of did, but it was more a case of confusion than anything else.

Organics vs synthetics? Seem to be getting along just fine, judgind by the peace I made between geth and quarian. And EDI seems to be happy among organics.

So, umm *insert yo dawg picture here*

[nightcobra]

Atrocity wrote...

nightcobra8928 wrote...


the gist of it is that he loved the ending as he felt it wrapped up everything from me1 and 2 nicely as well the main theme of "organics vs synthetics" and the "created rebelling against the creator".

i sat there thinking....did we play the same trilogy?

How the hell ending wrapped anything up? From those mentioned perspectives it falls flatter on its' face than ever. Created rebelling against the creator? Umm, no one did. It turns out even the geth didn't. I suppose the first stage of EDI, the rogue VI kind of did, but it was more a case of confusion than anything else.

Organics vs synthetics? Seem to be getting along just fine, judgind by the peace I made between geth and quarian. And EDI seems to be happy among organics.

So, umm *insert yo dawg picture here*

those were some of the reasons why my blood was starting to boil. a little more and my inner krogan would have popped out, and he wants to play:devil:


tomorrow can't come soon enough.

Modifié par nightcobra8928, 05 avril 2012 - 09:06 .

[Jawsomebob]

less than 48 hours till we will know!

[NeverQuiteAwake]

nightcobra8928 wrote...

the gist of it is that he loved the ending as he felt it wrapped up everything from me1 and 2 nicely as well the main theme of "organics vs synthetics" and the "created rebelling against the creator".

i sat there thinking....did we play the same trilogy?

ps:just one more day....just one more day...

GAH!! Good thing I stopped too, my blood would've been boiling. Those "main themes" were completely turned on theirs heads when we united the Geth and the Quarians. Hell, no matter the outcome of Rannoch, I'm not sure those themes are relavent anyway. If you side with the Geth and kill the Quarians, don't the Geth become loyal to you? And if you destroy the Geth, well, it doesn't matter much then.

edit: oh yeah, that's right, the Geth never really rebelled against their creators anyway.

And what about EDI? She learned to love, for God's sake.

/end rant

One more day

Modifié par Little Miss Angel, 05 avril 2012 - 09:11 .

[firstarioch]

Reply to nightcobra8928:

Tomorrow 4 30 edt.
Now where will be live broadcast of it?

[toffeetrooper]

firstarioch wrote...

Morning brethren! !!
Back to holding the line !!! As always since 13th of March.
how are we holding up today?
Anything new apart from this good artilce I found and exposing hypocrisy of Penny Arcade.

http://www.cinemable...ct-3-41139.html

good article.......but what a hate filled person snagglepuss(last post) is he need to see a shrink

edit:spelling

Modifié par toffeetrooper, 05 avril 2012 - 09:11 .

[Tyion133]

Atrocity wrote...

nightcobra8928 wrote...


the gist of it is that he loved the ending as he felt it wrapped up everything from me1 and 2 nicely as well the main theme of "organics vs synthetics" and the "created rebelling against the creator".

i sat there thinking....did we play the same trilogy?

How the hell ending wrapped anything up? From those mentioned perspectives it falls flatter on its' face than ever. Created rebelling against the creator? Umm, no one did. It turns out even the geth didn't. I suppose the first stage of EDI, the rogue VI kind of did, but it was more a case of confusion than anything else.

Organics vs synthetics? Seem to be getting along just fine, judgind by the peace I made between geth and quarian. And EDI seems to be happy among organics.

So, umm *insert yo dawg picture here*

Actually the rogue VI/AI was only trying to defend itself from being shut down

[firstarioch]

Reply to toffeeytrooper :
As everyone who thinks that ending has anything to do with thus game and gives proper closure.

[Phoenix NL]

Tyion133 wrote...

Atrocity wrote...

nightcobra8928 wrote...


the gist of it is that he loved the ending as he felt it wrapped up everything from me1 and 2 nicely as well the main theme of "organics vs synthetics" and the "created rebelling against the creator".

i sat there thinking....did we play the same trilogy?

How the hell ending wrapped anything up? From those mentioned perspectives it falls flatter on its' face than ever. Created rebelling against the creator? Umm, no one did. It turns out even the geth didn't. I suppose the first stage of EDI, the rogue VI kind of did, but it was more a case of confusion than anything else.

Organics vs synthetics? Seem to be getting along just fine, judgind by the peace I made between geth and quarian. And EDI seems to be happy among organics.

So, umm *insert yo dawg picture here*

Actually the rogue VI/AI was only trying to defend itself from being shut down

"Green is the color of money." more dlc for everyone!

[toffeetrooper]

firstarioch wrote...

Reply to toffeeytrooper :
As everyone who thinks that ending has anything to do with thus game and gives proper closure.

i wouldnt say everyone, but there is a lot of hate out there.
the gameing industry wants to be taken seriosley yet they call there own customers names! It might just be me but i cant see how that helps their cause. 

edit: spelling is terrible, having a dead head day

Modifié par toffeetrooper, 05 avril 2012 - 09:19 .

[SkaldFish]

nightcobra8928 wrote...

Stamina Rose wrote...

Mbednar wrote...

Hey check it out if ya haven't already.  I know its G4 but we've got someone in the biz on our side.<3

She does a pretty good job defending our point.  I facepalm at a few moments but hey, she's helping

www.g4tv.com/videos/58021/feedback-mass-effect-3-ending-controversy/#video-57918


Again, sorry if its been posted already.  Its just nice to know that not everyone hates us

That was a great video, at least someone has the exact same thoughts as the fans have.

i had to close the video after a while, listening to stephen johnson's reasons of why he "liked" the ending(s) was getting my already bottled emotions starting to boil. better to close it and cool off, might have needed another laptop otherwise.

I agree. I kept thinking "were we playing the same game? Is this man brain damaged? Am I brain damaged?" Too many steps into Bizarro World for me.

Modifié par SkaldFish, 05 avril 2012 - 09:19 .

[chmarr]

IxSITHxI wrote...

IxSITHxI wrote...

This  100,000,000 times over and then another 100,000,000 times over again, and then for good measure another 42 times over. 

 P.S.

(be warned it is 39 min long but its sooooo damned interesting. it almost feels like a vid one of my english professor would show in class (in a good way))

P.P.S

it talks about how they broke genre, character focus, central conflict and the Narrative Coherence of the game; all in the last few moments of the game

chmarr wrote...


THIS is WELL worth the watch

+10 internets for you

why didnt i get + 10 internets when i posted this?

+10 internets and a cupcake

Modifié par chmarr, 05 avril 2012 - 09:22 .

[NeverQuiteAwake]

Tyion133 wrote...

Actually the rogue VI/AI was only trying to defend itself from being shut down

I'm beginning to wonder if Organics vs. Synthetics was ever really a "main theme". It almost seems to be more of a question about what it means to be alive, and who has a right to live. The Geth did not rebel, they wanted to live. EDI did not fight us, she was one of us.

The last message the rogue VI trasmits in binary is "HELP" not "I'M GOING TO DESTROY YOU ALL". I mean, there are the Reapers, but their killing organics ultimately wasn't about Organics vs. Synthetics, they were trying to "save us".

[Phoenix NL]

Little Miss Angel wrote...

Tyion133 wrote...

Actually the rogue VI/AI was only trying to defend itself from being shut down

I'm beginning to wonder if Organics vs. Synthetics was ever really a "main theme". It almost seems to be more of a question about what it means to be alive, and who has a right to live. The Geth did not rebel, they wanted to live. EDI did not fight us, she was one of us.

The last message the rogue VI trasmits in binary is "HELP" not "I'M GOING TO DESTROY YOU ALL". I mean, there are the Reapers, but their killing organics ultimately wasn't about Organics vs. Synthetics, they were trying to "save us".

Spot on Angel! Just finished watching that video, my head hurts now.......

[firstarioch]

Reply to toffeetrooper :

Don't worry about spelling. I'm writing from mobile. Sometimes I don't even know how it comes out. With regards to charity closure that was LOW even for penny arcade that gave us lots of hearts and. Minds everywhere. But they just closed it with bulll**** excuses.
Find it abhorrent.

[nightcobra]

Little Miss Angel wrote...

Tyion133 wrote...

Actually the rogue VI/AI was only trying to defend itself from being shut down

I'm beginning to wonder if Organics vs. Synthetics was ever really a "main theme". It almost seems to be more of a question about what it means to be alive, and who has a right to live. The Geth did not rebel, they wanted to live. EDI did not fight us, she was one of us.

The last message the rogue VI trasmits in binary is "HELP" not "I'M GOING TO DESTROY YOU ALL". I mean, there are the Reapers, but their killing organics ultimately wasn't about Organics vs. Synthetics, they were trying to "save us".

for me the main theme was stopping a cycle of destruction by an insurmountable force and defeat it despite the odds. with our choices saying how well/badly we stopped it with a full spectrum of bright/white, neutral/bittersweet/gray, and dark/black/sad set of outcomes.

Modifié par nightcobra8928, 05 avril 2012 - 09:31 .

[WarBaby2]

Good I already moved on...

http://www.escapistm...m_campaign=news

[julian08]

Deschi wrote...

chmarr wrote...

Little Miss Angel wrote...

If anyone wants to watch a Tasteful, Understated Nerdrage video about EA and Bioware:

Apologies if it's been shared already, only just watched it now.

THIS is WELL worth the watch

+10 internets for you

Go people WATCH that video and spread the word that it is out! It still kind of a subjective view on the things but at last one that goes to a bit deeper than many others...

Oh my god, he's playing Aerie's romance theme over the last minutes.
*sniff* excuse me for a moment. . .

[Nharia1]

WarBaby2 wrote...

Good I already moved on...

http://www.escapistm...m_campaign=news

They could still be in the writing phase for all we know... Doesn't mean that they're not going to do anything, cause they most certainaly had some SP DLC planned before this whole thing came up.

[Phoenix NL]

WarBaby2 wrote...

Good I already moved on...

http://www.escapistm...m_campaign=news

I kind of wish it wasn't the end of Shepard's story but I could accept it if it didn't end this way. I will live in denial with Jennifer Hale

[WarBaby2]

Nharia1 wrote...
They could still be in the writing phase for all we know... Doesn't mean that they're not going to do anything, cause they most certainaly had some SP DLC planned before this whole thing came up.

Yea... pre ending DLC like Omega... and people will buy it, no matter what.

The whole retake affort was a nice idea... but the sad thruth is, in this day and age, companies like EA have no need for a loyal fanbase anymore. They have the brainless masses that will simply buy anything... and they know it and calculate with it... and they ALWAYS get their moneys worth.

EDIT: In the future, I am more inclined to support indie companies like Almost Human (Legend of Grimlock)... atleast to them we are still humans with a voice, not just money cows.

Modifié par WarBaby2, 05 avril 2012 - 09:46 .