145 réponses à ce sujet

[G3rman]

The obvious reason is so they can have ME4 located on this backwater world. PERFECT PLOT DEVICE EVAR!!!!!11

[albertalad]

Nathan Redgrave wrote...

Why, for the love of God, does "inbreeding" always come up...?

Well if you strand the NOrmandy crew on some deserted world how else can they act? Just sit there and die quietly? That's just nature to breed for any species and the crew would be no different - in this particlar case after the first lot of kids there would have to be inbreeding of so small a numbers as the Normandy crew. Or as in ME2 someone exerts total control - its not the fan base fault blame BW for this idiocy!

[Unit-Alpha]

Yes +1

Good lord, this isn't too much to ask.

[Bigdoser]

Yup if bioware just made the normandy crash land on earth i think all the rage will be mitigated.

[BellPeppers&Beef023]

albertalad wrote...

Nathan Redgrave wrote...

Why, for the love of God, does "inbreeding" always come up...?

Well if you strand the NOrmandy crew on some deserted world how else can they act? Just sit there and die quietly? That's just nature to breed for any species and the crew would be no different - in this particlar case after the first lot of kids there would have to be inbreeding of so small a numbers as the Normandy crew. Or as in ME2 someone exerts total control - its not the fan base fault blame BW for this idiocy!

also, didn't 1 of the leaked videos show an adult and a deformed child starring at a distant planet??

[Dasher1010]

Bigdoser wrote...

Yup if bioware just made the normandy crash land on earth i think all the rage will be mitigated.

Truth

[Legendaryred]

Yes I agree, it adds nothing to the story and contributes nothing to the player but anger. I mean wtf? it makes no sense at all and it takes away the possibility of any future DLC since everything is ****, unless UNLESS they want to sell in the future a DLC where you get the good ending. In that case, **** ***!

[ncknck]

Zyrious wrote...

Not only are there not enough people on the normandy to actually start a colony, but there arent even half as many females needed to pair off even half the crew.

But we dont know that. Not even seeable in me1/2 where lesser crewmembers were basically just placeholders. Operators, with zero servicemen. Thats not possible. Normandy must have alot more people. So a new colony is very possible, and starting it on Earth, really now that would be a pointless loop indeed, as we humans already did that. Basically it would make for some crappy movie where X came, destroyed civiliziation, and we start anew with all the junk left behind, space travel not even needed.

[Zyrious]

ncknck wrote...

Zyrious wrote...

Not only are there not enough people on the normandy to actually start a colony, but there arent even half as many females needed to pair off even half the crew.

But we dont know that. Not even seeable in me1/2 where lesser crewmembers were basically just placeholders. Operators, with zero servicemen. Thats not possible. Normandy must have alot more people. So a new colony is very possible, and starting it on Earth, really now that would be a pointless loop indeed, as we humans already did that. Basically it would make for some crappy movie where X came, destroyed civiliziation, and we start anew with all the junk left behind, space travel not even needed.

The concept of a phoenix rising out of the ashes is a poetic one, rebuilding rather than just being stranded out in the middle of nowhere building a random colony with less than 50 people where a single disastor would wipe out the colony. There's already dozens of human colonies that will be doing that. Besides, like i said, the most poetic of endings would be to see the normandy on Earth, watching the tattered remains of human, asari, turian, and everyone else on Earth working together to find survivors and begin rebuilding anew after all the chaos. A Missed opportunity indeed.

And in the end it only has to be one of many endings, rather than having all endings be - normandy screwed, shepard dead or wishing he was.

Modifié par Zyrious, 01 mars 2012 - 07:51 .

[Pr3ying M4nt15 360]

Yeah I agree, such a small change would have sweetened the destroy ending for people who are happy to not worry about the AI related problems in the future. Which tbh I think most people would opt for.

[BellPeppers&Beef023]

Zyrious wrote...

ncknck wrote...

Zyrious wrote...

Not only are there not enough people on the normandy to actually start a colony, but there arent even half as many females needed to pair off even half the crew.

But we dont know that. Not even seeable in me1/2 where lesser crewmembers were basically just placeholders. Operators, with zero servicemen. Thats not possible. Normandy must have alot more people. So a new colony is very possible, and starting it on Earth, really now that would be a pointless loop indeed, as we humans already did that. Basically it would make for some crappy movie where X came, destroyed civiliziation, and we start anew with all the junk left behind, space travel not even needed.

The concept of a phoenix rising out of the ashes is a poetic one, learning from your mistakes and rebuilding rather than just being stranded out in the middle of nowhere building a random colony with less than 50 people where a single disastor would wipe out the colony. There's already dozens of human colonies that will be doing that. Besides, like i said, the most poetic of endings would be to see the normandy on Earth, watching the tattered remains of human, asari, turian, and everyone else on Earth working together to find survivors and begin rebuilding anew after all the chaos. A Missed opportunity indeed.

And in the end it only has to be one of many endings, rather than having all endings be - normandy screwed, shepard dead or wishing he was.

In the end, people just want closure over these characters that they have invested so much time and emotions in.

[Blablabla79]

MouseNo4 wrote...

I have to seriously ask... WHAT THE HELL IS THE POINT of stranding the Normandy and crew? What POSSIBLE PLOT SERVICE DOES IT PROVIDE??

End rant.

What bioware does here reminds me of Joss Whedons attitude towards characters the fans like. It is exactly the same cheap, ****ty way to add "drama". 

[Stokie Stallion]

Better ending would to be trapped with all my crew mates and LI on a planet with at least a colony, whom recongise me for my achievements and begin anew

[Zyrious]

ithurtz wrote...

Zyrious wrote...

ncknck wrote...

Zyrious wrote...

Not only are there not enough people on the normandy to actually start a colony, but there arent even half as many females needed to pair off even half the crew.

But we dont know that. Not even seeable in me1/2 where lesser crewmembers were basically just placeholders. Operators, with zero servicemen. Thats not possible. Normandy must have alot more people. So a new colony is very possible, and starting it on Earth, really now that would be a pointless loop indeed, as we humans already did that. Basically it would make for some crappy movie where X came, destroyed civiliziation, and we start anew with all the junk left behind, space travel not even needed.

The concept of a phoenix rising out of the ashes is a poetic one, learning from your mistakes and rebuilding rather than just being stranded out in the middle of nowhere building a random colony with less than 50 people where a single disastor would wipe out the colony. There's already dozens of human colonies that will be doing that. Besides, like i said, the most poetic of endings would be to see the normandy on Earth, watching the tattered remains of human, asari, turian, and everyone else on Earth working together to find survivors and begin rebuilding anew after all the chaos. A Missed opportunity indeed.

And in the end it only has to be one of many endings, rather than having all endings be - normandy screwed, shepard dead or wishing he was.

In the end, people just want closure over these characters that they have invested so much time and emotions in.

That's the thing, the endings DO have closure. Just really bad closure (imo). It'd be one thing if thes endings were just one of many, but they are not. They have variations but that's it. Normandy crashes, crew is dead or alive, Shepard is pretty much screwed wether he lives or not so that part doesnt really matter unless there's some ingame cutscenes with him we're unaware of.

[J-Reyno]

I have to agree. I think they could have done a little better than "everything sucks no matter what".

Say perhaps if your Shepard lives, you have to somehow either choose to be with the normandy crew or your LI. Of course most would probably pick LI ,but say you chose the LI the two of you are stranded in a place that cannot sustain life for any substantial period of time. Shep and LI will die together shortly after the epilogue. If you choose the crew, both you and the LI are safe and can continue to live a normal life expectancy. However you are separated permanently due to the destruction of the relays.

That's the kind of bittersweet ending I may have expected.

Right now it's DEAD OR FOREVER ALONE.

Maybe when you actually play the game, however, the endings don't seem that bad. In a few days, we'll see.

Modifié par Reyno411, 01 mars 2012 - 07:55 .

[Stokie Stallion]

Dasher1010 wrote...

Bigdoser wrote...

Yup if bioware just made the normandy crash land on earth i think all the rage will be mitigated.

Truth

I do agree, back to jolly ol' England with me crew

[The Makatak]

Lucy_Glitter wrote...

MouseNo4 wrote...

I have to seriously ask... WHAT THE HELL IS THE POINT of stranding the Normandy and crew? What POSSIBLE PLOT SERVICE DOES IT PROVIDE??

End rant.

Manipulation of emotions to make people feel things so they think it's a good game.

I feel like that's all Bioware's done with ME3 so far. Every trailer, even in the demo, they're like, "CHILDREN WILL DIE. THIS IS SAD."

The line "you can't help me" isn't even that captivating. But kick out Jack Wall for some melancholy piano. Suddenly: "DRAMA! ACTING! MARK MEER LEARNS [talent]!"

It's like the writers went from taking notes from Star Wars/Trek/Gate to formulating their plots in the vein of Stephanie Meyer.

[MelfinaofOutlawStar]

ncknck wrote...

crashing on Earth? Is boring. Its like.. boring. Thats like Columbus making a new colony.. in Italy. Let them start anew, new beginning.

Hell, it's not even viable for them to create a new colony from the few on the Normandy.

[J-Reyno]

The Makatak wrote...

Lucy_Glitter wrote...

MouseNo4 wrote...

I have to seriously ask... WHAT THE HELL IS THE POINT of stranding the Normandy and crew? What POSSIBLE PLOT SERVICE DOES IT PROVIDE??

End rant.

Manipulation of emotions to make people feel things so they think it's a good game.

I feel like that's all Bioware's done with ME3 so far. Every trailer, even in the demo, they're like, "CHILDREN WILL DIE. THIS IS SAD."

The line "you can't help me" isn't even that captivating. But kick out Jack Wall for some melancholy piano. Suddenly: "DRAMA! ACTING! MARK MEER LEARNS [talent]!"

It's like the writers went from taking notes from Star Wars/Trek/Gate to formulating their plots in the vein of Stephanie Meyer.

Or perhaps "CHILDREN WILL DIE.  THIS HURTS YOU."

[DifferentD17]

You have my support, Though I would prefer Shep to be alive on earth as well...

DD17 Fleet
+100 War Assets

[Vergil5]

I agree with this completely.

[Mr.House]

Agree 100%

[xtorma]

they have your money.....they don't care

HAHAHAHAHA

[Natsunomiko21]

DifferentD17 wrote...

You have my support, Though I would prefer Shep to be alive on earth as well...

DD17 Fleet
+100 War Assets

Yeah supposedly thats the good destroy ending, where shepard lives and he's back on earth (dunno how tho lol)
Just missing his LI and the normandy crew  

[ZDPhoenix]

Natsunomiko21 wrote...

MouseNo4 wrote...

I have to seriously ask... WHAT THE HELL IS THE POINT of stranding the Normandy and crew? What POSSIBLE PLOT SERVICE DOES IT PROVIDE??

End rant.

Cheap drama.

It's not cheap drama when it's the conclusion.

If they used it to sell an extra DLC that would be ano...

Oh jeez, I better not give them ideas.