557 réponses à ce sujet

[Sporothrix]

Aaleel wrote...

GirlPower23 wrote...

VinWizzy wrote...

It's funny because I called it. The trolls on meta critic were hungryy and had nothing else to do. I think user reviews should be gone completely. Too many trolls.

I hope this same logic applies with "Professional" reviews as well. Giving ME3 a 10/10 with so many deficiencies is hard to take them serious as well. Both Users and Professionals might be polar opposites on the spectrum but one thing is for sure, neither side is giving a fair review. One is massively sucking up, the other is giving a ridiculously low number to spite BioWare. This game is probably 7/10 at most. There are a lot of serous issues with the game, especially the PC Version.

This^^^^

The game doesn't deserve the user scores it's getting, but the number of 100 reviews from 'professional' reviewers is equally absurd.  The whole system is pretty much worthless now.

I suppose that in following months it will stuck in more appropriate and closer to reality score, about 5. Now people are just really pissed off and that's why it's close to 1.

Modifié par misoretu9, 06 mars 2012 - 11:47 .

[AkiKishi]

Canden_Zain wrote...

Acidrain92 wrote...

I guess all I can really expect from forum goers like you are sarcastic remarks, a condescending attitude, and closed mindedness about a game you havent even played.

Since when does a Bioware 'fan' need to play a game in order to identify everything that is wrong with it?

Zing

[Chrumpek]

Acidrain92 wrote...

Ugh. Just get rid of number scores completely. They really suck and ruin everything =|

Agreed. 

But then... what is the purpose of action mode?! 

[rammsoldat]

cha-cha-cha-cha-ching!

were you to belive reviews you'd think dragon age 2 was a masterpiece, it aint.

[Aaleel]

Acidrain92 wrote...

Ugh. Just get rid of number scores completely. They really suck and ruin everything =|

I agree with this, just write a review and be done with it.  If you want to like a game personally from that start, even if you list a laundry list of flaws, you'll probably still give it a good score.  Saying something like depsite it's flaws blah blah blah.  And if you had already decided you weren't going to like it, the opposite will happen if the game is good.

Just write the review, the pros and cons and be done.

[AkiKishi]

PDesign wrote...

 boards.4chan.org/v/res/131729660

Thanks?.... I've always wanted an oopai stress toy..

Oh I see scroll down

[Sashimi_taco]

I am playing the game right now. I enjoy a lot of things, but there are also a LOT of things I do not enjoy. I feel like my experience is being streamlined, and there are not other paths for me to take.

[GirlPower23]

Wulfram wrote...

If you're only giving out whole numbers, it's legitimate to give a 10/10 for an truly excellent game even if it has flaws. 9.5 is normally rounded to 10

Flaws should be taken into account. From what I've seen this game has a massive amount of flaws. Bad Animations, Poor Writing, Bad Textures, "Wave" Combat (Srsly crap in DAII, Bad in ME3), Neutered Dialog w/companions, difficulty settings not actually "Difficult" but just HP Boost like DAII. This game does not deserve a 9/10.. 10/10.. it deserves a much lower number. It's very typical to see a High Profile game get glowing reviews regardless of it's problems. Games should be critisized for everything.. not just looked at in positive light.

[Fiery Phoenix]

OXM UK gave it a resounding 10. Review here.

[Subject One]

Very good review IMHO:

www.thunderboltgames.com/reviews/article/mass-effect-3-review-for-xbox-360.html

The reviewer talks about a lot of BSN fears (less dialogue options, ending, etc.) without spoil anything, and it seems that the good overweights the bad.

Much better review at least than the ones at IGN and Gamespot.

Modifié par Subject One, 06 mars 2012 - 12:00 .

[Aaleel]

Subject One wrote...

Very good review IMHO:

www.thunderboltgames.com/reviews/article/mass-effect-3-review-for-xbox-360.html

The reviewer talks about a lof of BSN fears (less dialogue options, ending, etc.) without spoil anything, and it seems that the good overweights the bad.

Much better review at least that the ones at IGN and Gamespot.

This may shake a few people.

Mass Effect 3 is an action game with a side-helping of dialogue

[fropas]

Aaleel wrote...

Subject One wrote...

Very good review IMHO:

www.thunderboltgames.com/reviews/article/mass-effect-3-review-for-xbox-360.html

The reviewer talks about a lof of BSN fears (less dialogue options, ending, etc.) without spoil anything, and it seems that the good overweights the bad.

Much better review at least that the ones at IGN and Gamespot.

This may shake a few people.

Mass Effect 3 is an action game with a side-helping of dialogue

Why because it's true?

[Chrumpek]

Just saying that reviewers approached this game as an cover-based shooter action game, not an RPG and in those regards its a 8,5-9/10 game agreed here.

But as an RPG or the mass effect legacy... I dunno

[Walldorf]

User-Score at Metacritic is devestating, I never saw a game that got so much hate.

[Eternal Phoenix]

PDesign wrote...

metacritic.com/game/pc/mass-effect-3 user score

That face killed it!

 

Awesome!

---

But those user scores are far fetched. Zeros and ones? I highly doubt these people have played the game or much of the game. I have my doubts about the game and the RPG elements but I'm sure it's still enjoyable gameplay wise and thus shouldn't be given a zero or a one.

Modifié par Elton John is dead, 06 mars 2012 - 12:00 .

[stysiaq]

Walldorf wrote...

User-Score at Metacritic is devestating, I never saw a game that got so much hate.

Lets hope its not hate as deserved as the DA2 hate.


also: the face codes.

Modifié par stysiaq, 06 mars 2012 - 12:04 .

[Catsith]

Walldorf wrote...

User-Score at Metacritic is devestating, I never saw a game that got so much hate.

You have not been on the internet for very long, then.

[AkiKishi]

Aaleel wrote...

Subject One wrote...

Very good review IMHO:

www.thunderboltgames.com/reviews/article/mass-effect-3-review-for-xbox-360.html

The reviewer talks about a lof of BSN fears (less dialogue options, ending, etc.) without spoil anything, and it seems that the good overweights the bad.

Much better review at least that the ones at IGN and Gamespot.

This may shake a few people.

Mass Effect 3 is an action game with a side-helping of dialogue

Already knew that from the demo. It's the people who were delluding themselves that the game would somehow be different who are having a hard time with it now.

stysiaq wrote...

Walldorf wrote...

User-Score at Metacritic is devestating, I never saw a game that got so much hate.

Lets hope its not hate as deserved as the DA2 hate.

It's not. But the expectation was so much higher that it evens out.

Modifié par BobSmith101, 06 mars 2012 - 12:04 .

[Subject One]

Aaleel wrote...

Subject One wrote...

Very good review IMHO:

www.thunderboltgames.com/reviews/article/mass-effect-3-review-for-xbox-360.html

The reviewer talks about a lof of BSN fears (less dialogue options, ending, etc.) without spoil anything, and it seems that the good overweights the bad.

Much better review at least that the ones at IGN and Gamespot.

This may shake a few people.

Mass Effect 3 is an action game with a side-helping of dialogue

Yes, the reviewer call the things by its name. And even listing the good and bad changes done to ME3 he thinks its a very good game and it sounds honest to me.

[stoicsentry2]

OK, but didn't Dragon Age 2 get "great" reviews as well? I'm not saying they *PAID* for these positive reviews but let's be honest... it's most likely.

[Sargerus]

Walldorf wrote...

User-Score at Metacritic is devestating, I never saw a game that got so much hate.

*cough* Modern Warfare 3 *cough*

http://www.metacriti...odern-warfare-3 

[fropas]

Sargerus wrote...

Walldorf wrote...

User-Score at Metacritic is devestating, I never saw a game that got so much hate.

*cough* Modern Warfare 3 *cough*

http://www.metacriti...odern-warfare-3 

fifteen-hundered negative reviews. That's freaking insane!

[Acidrain92]

Subject One wrote...

Aaleel wrote...

Subject One wrote...

Very good review IMHO:

www.thunderboltgames.com/reviews/article/mass-effect-3-review-for-xbox-360.html

The reviewer talks about a lof of BSN fears (less dialogue options, ending, etc.) without spoil anything, and it seems that the good overweights the bad.

Much better review at least that the ones at IGN and Gamespot.

This may shake a few people.

Mass Effect 3 is an action game with a side-helping of dialogue

Yes, the reviewer call the things by its name. And even listing the good and bad changes done to ME3 he thinks its a very good game and it sounds honest to me.

agreed, and you know I do really feel for the people who were expecting the ME series to go in a different direction than it has. Hell even I didnt see this coming, but from what I have seen I actually enjoy where the mass effect series is. I just hope that after I am done playing the game, I leave with a very satisfied, yet heartfelt feeling, rather than a "I cant believe this. I seriously cant believe this. Im so depressed." feeling.

ME3 as a game is actually starting to scare me >.> I hope I make the right decisions.