428 réponses à ce sujet

[UltimateTobi]

FlamingBoy wrote...

so many reviews, so many of them undeserved

Why? Just because of the last 20 minutes of the game? Game reviews aren't just about the story. Game mechanic, sound, graphics, performance, etc. count to that too. And in my opinion, ME3 played very well. The gameplay was good, as was the sound. The graphics are average, but that's Mass Effect.
 
And the story, seens as a whole, is just as epic as it could be. The last 20 minutes are just bad for the hardcore fans (like me). I don't like the ending either, but reviewing the whole game bad for that is not right.

[napushenko]

UltimateTobi wrote...

FlamingBoy wrote...

so many reviews, so many of them undeserved

Why? Just because of the last 20 minutes of the game? Game reviews aren't just about the story. Game mechanic, sound, graphics, performance, etc. count to that too. And in my opinion, ME3 played very well. The gameplay was good, as was the sound. The graphics are average, but that's Mass Effect.
 
And the story, seens as a whole, is just as epic as it could be. The last 20 minutes are just bad for the hardcore fans (like me). I don't like the ending either, but reviewing the whole game bad for that is not right.

this. i would never take seriously any gaming magazine that rates some game 1-5 just because of ending. 

[FlamingBoy]

napushenko wrote...

UltimateTobi wrote...

FlamingBoy wrote...

so many reviews, so many of them undeserved

Why? Just because of the last 20 minutes of the game? Game reviews aren't just about the story. Game mechanic, sound, graphics, performance, etc. count to that too. And in my opinion, ME3 played very well. The gameplay was good, as was the sound. The graphics are average, but that's Mass Effect.
 
And the story, seens as a whole, is just as epic as it could be. The last 20 minutes are just bad for the hardcore fans (like me). I don't like the ending either, but reviewing the whole game bad for that is not right.

this. i would never take seriously any gaming magazine that rates some game 1-5 just because of ending. 

thxs for you opinion:P

[LinksOcarina]

Calians wrote...

Chris Priestly wrote...

•    1UP – A
•    4players (DE) - 75/100
•    9 Lives (BEL) - 90/100
•    Ars Technica – No Score, “Buy It”
•    Atomic Gamer – 10/10
•    Big Pond Game Arena – 10/10
•    CD Action (POL) - 9/10
•    Cheat Code Central – 4.6/5
•    CVG (UK) – 9.4/10
•    Destructoid – 8.5/10
•    Edge - 8/10
•    EGM – 9/10
•    Eurogamer (UK) – 10/10
•    Eurogamer (DE) – 10/10
•    Eurogamer (IT) – 10/10
•    Everyeye (IT) – 9.5/10
•    FZ.SE - 5/5
•    G4TV – 5/5
•    Game Arena (UK) – 9/10
•    Game Informer – 10/10
•    Gamer (NL) - 9.5/10
•    Gamer Limit – 9/10
•    Gamers.at (AUS) - 91/100
•    Gamerzines – 98/100
•    Games Radar – 9/10
•    Gamereactor (SE) – 10/10
•    Gamereactor (NO) – 9/10
•    GameSpot – 9/10
•    GameStar (DE) – 9/10
•    Gameswelt (DE) – 93/100
•    GameTrailers – 95
•    Gaming Trend – 99/100
•    Gaming XP (DE) – 95%
•    Giant Bomb – 4/5
•    Guardian (UK) – 5/5
•    IGN – 9.5/10
•    Inc Gamers – 9/10
•    Joystiq (Single Player Review) - 4.5/5
•    Just Push Start – 9.5/10
•    Kotaku – YES (no score)
•    Machinima – 9.5/10
•    Metro – 9/10
•    MSNBC – 10/10
•    Multiplayer (IT) - 9.5/10
•    Now Gamer (UK) – 9.2/10
•    OXM (UK) – 10/10
•    OXM (US) – 9.5/10
•    PC Gamer (UK) – 93/100
•    PC Powerplay 8/10
•    Pelaaja (FI) - 9/10
•    Pittsburg Post-Gazette – 5/5
•    Planet Xbox – 10/10
•    PlayStation Official Magazine (UK) – 10/10
•    Playstation Lifestyle – 10/10
•    Pressfire (NO) - 6/6
•    Shack News - Epic
•    SpazioGames (IT) - 9.5/10
•    The Escapist – 4.5/5
•    The Verge – 10/10
•    Thunderbolt Games – 9/10
•    USA Today – 4/4
•    VG Nett (NO) - 6/6
•    VG Revolution – 9.7/10
•    Videogamer (UK) – 8/10
•    Video Game Writers - 5/5
•    Xbox Achievements (UK) 96/100

How much money was given to these reviewers? If you want a honest review watch angryjoes review and I think he know quite more than the average ME gamer now-a-days

Joe is not a Reviewer, he is an entertainer first. And I know, I worked with him before. Plus no, he does not know more than the average ME gamer. He just did his homework to make it look he knew. 

And Chris, i'm sad the BT review I wrote is not up there on that list. Then again...the check you promised bounced....

(that was a joke)

That said, the IGN review should not be counted because of Chobots involvement. But, I can say that it's doubtful reviewers were paid off otherwise.