172 réponses à ce sujet

[SilentWolfie]

Some honest feedbacks please, by non zealous bioware fans. I already got the game but I guess I want to brace myself for impact...


So is it because of the bad story? Or gameplay? Or day 1 DLC (seriously, this is the LARGEST crowd disservice possible)? Or the part where it keeps connecting to the EA servers for verification each time you play or some hidden hassle?

I peeked at the numbers of ME3 @ metacritics, and whoa... there were reallllly bad scores. Another question I have is whether ME3 is similar to DA2 in terms of character development, you know pick different choices and everything still come out the same. I really hated DA2, and heavens, I hope there's nothing like that here. If that's the case, I'm going to preordering blindly on any bioware games from now on.

So to bioware, seriously, I want a RPG so I hope your game is a RPG and not FPS, yeah?

[ebevan91]

SilentWolfie wrote...

I peeked at the numbers of ME3 @ metacritics 

There's your problem.

If there's one TINY little thing someone doesn't like about a game, they'll trash the entire game. 

Modifié par ebevan91, 07 mars 2012 - 12:04 .

[Pobatti]

SilentWolfie wrote...

Some honest feedbacks please, by non zealous bioware fans. I already got the game but I guess I want to brace myself for impact...


So is it because of the bad story? Or gameplay? Or day 1 DLC (seriously, this is the LARGEST crowd disservice possible)? Or the part where it keeps connecting to the EA servers for verification each time you play or some hidden hassle?

I peeked at the numbers of ME3 @ metacritics, and whoa... there were reallllly bad scores. Another question I have is whether ME3 is similar to DA2 in terms of character development, you know pick different choices and everything still come out the same. I really hated DA2, and heavens, I hope there's nothing like that here. If that's the case, I'm going to preordering blindly on any bioware games from now on.

So to bioware, seriously, I want a RPG so I hope your game is a RPG and not FPS, yeah?

Only bad reviews I see are at Metacritic... folks going "it's craap! 0%" - just don't listen to them

[LetsGoToMyHouse]

May I direct you here, good sir/madam: (just scroll down a few centimeters)

http://social.biowar...3/index/9658497

Modifié par LetsGoToMyHouse, 07 mars 2012 - 12:06 .

[Wifflebottom]

I haven't gotten my copy yet but you should ignore the user reviews on metacritic because many of those users gave the game zeroes because the game contains homosexual romances. Bioware has stated numerous times in relation to Mass Effect and Dragon Age that gay romances are never forced upon the player nor are heterosexual romances. Also metacritic is scarcely a reliable source of accurate judgement on anything considered popular because of teh trollz (see MW2 metacritic). Hope that answered your question

[Repearized Miranda]

@OP: This game was never an FPS, but it is a TPS! 

In short, let's just say because this game hasn't met the some people who are uncomfortable perceived notion of perfection.

High expectations, that's why!

But yeah, steer clear of overtly negative, but also positive reviews due to the high expectations.

Modifié par Repearized Miranda, 07 mars 2012 - 12:09 .

[Abirn]

I trust user reviews more than I trust "professional" reviewers.

@ Repearized Miranda. The game isn't perfect but if the reviewers are honest then why are some of them giving it a 10/10?

[cipher86]

It plays a lot like ME2 still and I guess that ticks people off. The immersion is much better than ME2, probably because there's an actual constant threat so we're not just dillying about the galaxy on a sidequest bonanza anymore.

Only bad thing about the game so far is that Prothean DLC. It's amazing, but that's the thing. It's so fluently integrated into the game with so much interactivity from the rest of the cast that there's no way it was designed as an afterthought. It was most definitely in production for the main game and stripped to be sold back to us to make a $60 game $70.

Leaves a very sour taste, but is the game amazing? 10 hours in and I say yes.

[Templar_Blademaster]

Wifflebottom wrote...

I haven't gotten my copy yet but you should ignore the user reviews on metacritic because many of those users gave the game zeroes because the game contains homosexual romances. Bioware has stated numerous times in relation to Mass Effect and Dragon Age that gay romances are never forced upon the player nor are heterosexual romances. Also metacritic is scarcely a reliable source of accurate judgement on anything considered popular because of teh trollz (see MW2 metacritic). Hope that answered your question

It isn't just the homosexual romances. It is how much BioWare has taken out compared to previous offerings. Like scenes where there should have been dialogue options but there aren't, the lack of a neutral convo option, the early players who got the space copies that leaked the ending (which didn't sit well with many people).

Same with Dragon Age 2, it wasn't just the homosexual romances. It was just the general handling of the game that didn't sit well with people.

And besides, you shouldn't ignore metacritic. What you should do is research before you purchase, and when you use metacritic just cross check the scores between journalist reviews and player reviews. Even better, wait a month when the review scores even out and then check. If the scores are close, then you can judge the game based off that score. If the scores vary by over 3 points, then there is something to look into.

[Moonshadow_Dark]

Really? Because I've seen a ton of reviews from PROFESSIONALS that indicate otherwise. IGN, Game Informer, G4 etc. All of them gave it a great score. Not to mention, the greatest and most reputable reviewer I know gave it a seal of approval: My own personal tastes. And that guy? He always knows what I like 100% of the time.

[TheItalianSnip3r]

If your talking about the user reviwes on metacritic it's because there are tons of haters, one guy didn't even buy it. He said "charge us for DLC on day one, don't bother buying this money grabber" another said "there are no choices in this game" I ignore them and pay attention to the so called "pro" reviews which are actually better (It's currentley a 93 on PC and PS3, 94 on Xbox)

[Arcadian Legend]

Protip-Don't bother with Metacritic.

[MakeMineMako]

The big game industry folks tend to give big name, highly anticipated titles rave reviews at the start.

[Pobatti]

Abirn wrote...

I trust user reviews more than I trust "professional" reviewers.

@ Repearized Miranda. The game isn't perfect but if the reviewers are honest then why are some of them giving it a 10/10?

Chicken and Egg

If no game ever got a 10/10 because of the belief that it's impossible to get a 10 since that would be perfect, instead you'd just see all these games get a 9/9 everywhere instead. So basically all you'd be doing is altering the scale so that instead of 10 distinct ranks there would be only 9.

Therefore you ignore that 'impossible to get 10' rule. Games can be improved, but that rule makes no sense.

If the 10th rank can never be attained, then games will only be rated within the confines of the 9 which can. Then someone decides to be smart and says that 9/9 = perfection, and so people start rating games 8/8.

[Jestina]

So far far the only bad I can think of is the animations(poopy pants running), and my character looks pear shaped. The story seems to be dragging a lot in the beginning too. Not much freedom to do anything so far and i've been playing a couple hours.

[Abirn]

MakeMineMako wrote...

The big game industry folks tend to give big name, highly anticipated titles rave reviews at the start.

and I wonder why that is.  It couldn't possibly because people have gotten fired for negative reviews or publishers threatening future blacklistings  (See DNF)

[Steffin]

Pobatti wrote...

SilentWolfie wrote...

Some honest feedbacks please, by non zealous bioware fans. I already got the game but I guess I want to brace myself for impact...


So is it because of the bad story? Or gameplay? Or day 1 DLC (seriously, this is the LARGEST crowd disservice possible)? Or the part where it keeps connecting to the EA servers for verification each time you play or some hidden hassle?

I peeked at the numbers of ME3 @ metacritics, and whoa... there were reallllly bad scores. Another question I have is whether ME3 is similar to DA2 in terms of character development, you know pick different choices and everything still come out the same. I really hated DA2, and heavens, I hope there's nothing like that here. If that's the case, I'm going to preordering blindly on any bioware games from now on.

So to bioware, seriously, I want a RPG so I hope your game is a RPG and not FPS, yeah?

Only bad reviews I see are at Metacritic... folks going "it's craap! 0%" - just don't listen to them

So we only listen to the pople that say is a 10/10 and agree with your position?

OP, play the demo, witness first hand the console graphics, the clunky movements, the inability to holster your weapon, the bad lip sync, the horrible spam bloom lighting, the healvily compressed textures. Make your own choice, instead of reading reviews from ad revenue driven sites. 

Oh, almost forgot, don't forget the $70 pricetag for the console garbage. Enjoy!

[Pobatti]

Jestina wrote...

So far far the only bad I can think of is the animations(poopy pants running), and my character looks pear shaped. The story seems to be dragging a lot in the beginning too. Not much freedom to do anything so far and i've been playing a couple hours.

I'm keeping my ME3 demo installed even after I get the full game. I couldn't bear to lose the hilarity that is the over the top and immensely funny Anderson sprinting animation

[Arch1eviathan]

Hear we go again...

[ttchip]

Pobatti wrote...

I'm keeping my ME3 demo installed even after I get the full game. I couldn't bear to lose the hilarity that is the over the top and immensely funny Anderson sprinting animation

It's the same in the full game.

[Moonshadow_Dark]

Steffin wrote...

Pobatti wrote...

SilentWolfie wrote...

Some honest feedbacks please, by non zealous bioware fans. I already got the game but I guess I want to brace myself for impact...


So is it because of the bad story? Or gameplay? Or day 1 DLC (seriously, this is the LARGEST crowd disservice possible)? Or the part where it keeps connecting to the EA servers for verification each time you play or some hidden hassle?

I peeked at the numbers of ME3 @ metacritics, and whoa... there were reallllly bad scores. Another question I have is whether ME3 is similar to DA2 in terms of character development, you know pick different choices and everything still come out the same. I really hated DA2, and heavens, I hope there's nothing like that here. If that's the case, I'm going to preordering blindly on any bioware games from now on.

So to bioware, seriously, I want a RPG so I hope your game is a RPG and not FPS, yeah?

Only bad reviews I see are at Metacritic... folks going "it's craap! 0%" - just don't listen to them

So we only listen to the pople that say is a 10/10 and agree with your position?

OP, play the demo, witness first hand the console graphics, the clunky movements, the inability to holster your weapon, the bad lip sync, the horrible spam bloom lighting, the healvily compressed textures. Make your own choice, instead of reading reviews from ad revenue driven sites. 

Oh, almost forgot, don't forget the $70 pricetag for the console garbage. Enjoy!

Says make your own choice

Give the guy a list of complaints beforehand

[SilentWolfie]

I actually thought metacritics got DA2 right... it was more of an "adventure" game than a RPG to me. Phew, still has bad memories from it (and I have never completed the game, just played through 30% of it and couldn't be bothered to finish it, waste of $$).

I also doubt the part on homosexual content affecting the scores, because bioware has always been big on that area, a good thing imo. Uhh. Didn't like DA Anders, though.

Edit: I do agree the graphics is lacking though.

Modifié par SilentWolfie, 07 mars 2012 - 12:24 .

[Pobatti]

Steffin wrote...

Pobatti wrote...

SilentWolfie wrote...

Some honest feedbacks please, by non zealous bioware fans. I already got the game but I guess I want to brace myself for impact...


So is it because of the bad story? Or gameplay? Or day 1 DLC (seriously, this is the LARGEST crowd disservice possible)? Or the part where it keeps connecting to the EA servers for verification each time you play or some hidden hassle?

I peeked at the numbers of ME3 @ metacritics, and whoa... there were reallllly bad scores. Another question I have is whether ME3 is similar to DA2 in terms of character development, you know pick different choices and everything still come out the same. I really hated DA2, and heavens, I hope there's nothing like that here. If that's the case, I'm going to preordering blindly on any bioware games from now on.

So to bioware, seriously, I want a RPG so I hope your game is a RPG and not FPS, yeah?

Only bad reviews I see are at Metacritic... folks going "it's craap! 0%" - just don't listen to them

So we only listen to the pople that say is a 10/10 and agree with your position?

Nope, we just ignore those idiotic reviews that do nothing but give either a 0 or a 10, basing their opinion on no actual facts based on actually playing the game, post reviews that contain nothing but spam, attacks on the Bioware staff, continual repetition of some of the internet memes that have sprung up without any of the facts...

[Jestina]

Pobatti wrote...
I'm keeping my ME3 demo installed even after I get the full game. I couldn't bear to lose the hilarity that is the over the top and immensely funny Anderson sprinting animation

They still kind of move that way but at least the graphics are a little cleaner. Also there is this weird thing after a cutscene where my femshep tucks her elbows back...really strange looking, and she walks funny.