In addition to the pointed out inconsistencies/dissapointments (Why/How was the Normandy travelling in a Mass Relay, how could squadmates [they all are] on Earth be on the Normandy, and the cop out ending), there's one thing many people forgot:
Throughout the entire game series and in the Codex, it states that
a Mass Relay exploding will render all habitable planets inhabitable in the system it explodes in.
This means that not only could Shepard have been on the ruined Earth (as per the "Shepard Lives" ending), but all life on Earth would have died seconds after the relay exploded and incinerated everything in the system (including all allied vessels and persons on them).
In addition, this means that you have inadvertantly killed millions in the few systems the Reapers had not yet been to (but had a relay), killed anyone still fighting the Reapers in any system they were in, killed everyone on the fleet, and killed virtually anyone anywhere near a relay (read: nearly every civilization met in the game, including races without spaceflight such as the Yahg). The only people I could have seen making it through would be the civilization that was cut off, as alluded to in the Cerberus Daily News stories in Mass Effect 2, in addition to a couple of such scattered colonies and hereto unknown species.
To further add, the probability of the Normandy dropping out of the middle of a relay jump onto any planet, let alone a hospitable one, or indeed inside any given solar system, are astronomical.
I loved the game the entire way through, but the ending was atrocious, and I have created my own ending in my mind and supplanted the given endings.
Modifié par Shock n Awe, 13 mars 2012 - 06:06 .