Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the ending a hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory


57139 réponses à ce sujet

#9526
hex23

hex23
  • Members
  • 743 messages

BrotherWarth wrote...

Why are so many people suing the fact that the ending is so stupid as a reason for it not being real? When you see a really lousy movie do you assume the filmmakers were just trolling you and are going to release their real masterpiece at a later date?


If you think the ending being stupid is the crux of our indoctrination theory you obviously haven't been paying attention.

The fact that Destroy is the only ending where Shepard lives should be a massive clue that things shouldn't be taken at face value. Alive on Earth might I add, not in space.

Coupled with the vague tweets, and the fact that the game completely stops making sense in the last 10 minutes....I mean, what more do you need? The game's end being 100% valid is a lot more unlikely than Bioware releasing a real end later....if we take the end at face value there is no Citadel, no Reapers, no Mass Relays, millions of aliens stranded on Earth, Shepard is dead....you seriously think Bioware would kill off their #1 franchise at the height of it's popularity?

So no, the end "being stupid" doesn't need to be taken into consideration.

#9527
Terraforming2154

Terraforming2154
  • Members
  • 667 messages

BrotherWarth wrote...

Why are so many people suing the fact that the ending is so stupid as a reason for it not being real? When you see a really lousy movie do you assume the filmmakers were just trolling you and are going to release their real masterpiece at a later date?




Why does it matter if people are hoping for better,seriously, does it bother you a personal level?

There are plenty of threads going on about how horrible the ending is as it isnow, this thread is a good diversion.

Plus, the ending is weird and it feels incredibly off, whether because it was just poorly written and the writers decided to change the entire tone and style of the series within fifteen minutes or because it was intentionally done...The oddness is worth discussing, and this thread is looking at it from a different perspective instead of just saying "EA made Bioware suck" over and over.

Modifié par Terraforming2154, 14 mars 2012 - 12:15 .


#9528
MissMaster_2

MissMaster_2
  • Members
  • 1 010 messages
Wait I have a question. what is the difference between the EMS and TMR?

#9529
Rip504

Rip504
  • Members
  • 3 259 messages

Niemack Saarinen wrote...

Rip504 wrote...

The Pistol does not have infinite Ammo. In the way some of you claim. All guns have infinite Ammo,it's the heat sinks that need to be changed,hence this just happens to be an old model,or a special heat sink. It could simply be the Predator with 49+Shots


"A special Heat sink" thats never been seen before in the trilogy let alone those models carry high damage low magazine.    your argument is invalid.


LMAO,No heatsink just a gun. Your argument is based on thin air.

Shepard is the first organic to ever stand here,Yes in front of the Godchild. That doesn't mean the room. Obviously human writing proves organics were there,or how about the Crucible's design? It is designed to plug into that port SPECIFICALLY,hence someone has seen this room before.


Edit: Maybe whoever designed it,also created your destroy and control consoles. Why do you think TIM KNOWS he can control the Reapers? Through the Prothean archives which has info on this room,Crucible and different options to deal with the Reapers.

Modifié par Rip504, 14 mars 2012 - 12:17 .


#9530
BlackDragonBane

BlackDragonBane
  • Members
  • 285 messages

BlackDragonBane wrote...

If anyone on here wishes to discuss this theory in a more neutral, friendly, and controlled environment, please PM me and I will direct you to where we are slowly moving the discssion.

In all honesty, the thread has been sabatoged by hateful fans and can no longer be the peaceful and thoughtful discussion it had started out as, but myself and several others intend on keep byne's hard work alive and not be soiled by upset ME fans who'd rather inject their own hateful or disappointed opinions into this topic without caring about the whole purpose of this topic.

again, if interested, PM me and I will direct you to where we are migrating to.


bumping for awareness

#9531
blooregard

blooregard
  • Members
  • 1 151 messages

hex23 wrote...

jojimbo wrote...
because as it stands no matter which choice you choose, you die, the gates blow up, happy paradise and the goofy grandpa.


False. Why do people keep parroting wrong info that was disproven literally 250+ pages ago? I'm not trying to be rude but read the thread before you post. We've had to explain the "Shepard lives" ending what seems like 200 times.



the only part of the ending that doesn't really make any sense is why shep is called "the shepard" but I assume the kid is too young to be in school or not in the grade they'd teach you about the war with the reapers thus the kid wouldn't know who commander shepard really is. Kinda like how your parents may tell you stories about george washington chopping down a cherry tree but you don't actually learn about the revolutionary war until like high school

#9532
LenabotSE

LenabotSE
  • Members
  • 97 messages
Look, guys, I very much believe in the theory, but it's not a good thing to get really defensive if someone take a more pessimistic stance about the endings. They are not obligated to write a whole thesis with evidence and extensive counter-arguments. Again, I believe the theory, but it's good to not get your hopes up for this.

Taking the endings at face value is a very rational approach to the situation, as something like the indoc. theory has - as far as I can recall - never really been done before, and especially not in a blockbuster title. It makes a lot of sense, but even in the best of circumstances, there's only a small chance of this being true. Significantly less chance of there being DLC/extra content in the near future, though the missing disc data does have me curious.

Just don't treat the theory as an IV that's keeping you alive. Be kind, no growling. :P

#9533
Don Ravan

Don Ravan
  • Members
  • 26 messages
Man, i didnt even get to finish the game. On opening day, i got 5 hours in and my computer decided to break. Maybe a good thing though, because ive seen all of the endings and agree that they sucked.

Maybe by the time my comp is fixed, they will have released new endings.

Crossing my fingers,

#9534
Guest_BrotherWarth_*

Guest_BrotherWarth_*
  • Guests

savionen wrote...

BrotherWarth wrote...

Why are so many people suing the fact that the ending is so stupid as a reason for it not being real? When you see a really lousy movie do you assume the filmmakers were just trolling you and are going to release their real masterpiece at a later date?


Because the other 99.9% of the trilogy was high quality. It seems fair to give Bioware the benefit of the doubt, at least for now.


Reaper baby. ME2 had a stupid ending as well.

#9535
Little Lummo

Little Lummo
  • Members
  • 66 messages
Received message from Talik2000 who can't post yet, he wanted me to pass this on.

"I cant post yet, but has any1 checked what happends if you switch date on you computers clock to past like the 15th? there are lots of hidden files on the disc. A clock might release all the content please quote me and post this. Thanks."

#9536
blooregard

blooregard
  • Members
  • 1 151 messages

BrotherWarth wrote...

savionen wrote...

BrotherWarth wrote...

Why are so many people suing the fact that the ending is so stupid as a reason for it not being real? When you see a really lousy movie do you assume the filmmakers were just trolling you and are going to release their real masterpiece at a later date?


Because the other 99.9% of the trilogy was high quality. It seems fair to give Bioware the benefit of the doubt, at least for now.


Reaper baby. ME2 had a stupid ending as well.




ME3 DLC confirmed: final battle will take place TTGL style with shepard destroying the reaper's universe and bringing about infinite peace

#9537
Gryphonrampant

Gryphonrampant
  • Members
  • 2 messages
Perhaps a new ending would feed off the information gained at sanctuary, the last mission before the final save point. They were studying indoctrination; perhaps there will be an indoctrination countermeasure introduced in a DLC.

#9538
Debi-Tage

Debi-Tage
  • Members
  • 525 messages

Terraforming2154 wrote...

BrotherWarth wrote...

Why are so many people suing the fact that the ending is so stupid as a reason for it not being real? When you see a really lousy movie do you assume the filmmakers were just trolling you and are going to release their real masterpiece at a later date?




Why does it matter if people are hoping for better,seriously, does it bother you a personal level?

There are plenty of threads going on about how horrible the ending is as it isnow, this thread is a good diversion.

Plus, the ending is weird and it feels incredibly off, whether because it was just poorly written and the writers decided to change the entire tone and style of the series within fifteen minutes or because it was intentionally done...The oddness is worth discussing, and this thread is looking at it from a different perspective instead of just saying "EA made Bioware suck" over and over.





Exactly. Say what you will about Bioware - but they DO listen to their fans, as is evidenced throughout the series - look to Lair of the Shadow Broker for a specific example. Also, for writers soooo concerned about tying up all the loose ends they did in ME3 - do you seriously think that is the best they could do!? Really, the game mechanics are pretty much there from ME2...just polished - they had 2 years to come up with the finale for ME3 - and they are better than those endings. And the Mass Effect series is not a movie or a book - it is shaped by player interaction over three games. There is a fundamental difference in the comparisons of this series to any other form of media out there. Moot point.

Modifié par Debi-Tage, 14 mars 2012 - 12:21 .


#9539
Deltateam Elcor

Deltateam Elcor
  • Members
  • 783 messages

Little Lummo wrote...

Received message from Talik2000 who can't post yet, he wanted me to pass this on.

"I cant post yet, but has any1 checked what happends if you switch date on you computers clock to past like the 15th? there are lots of hidden files on the disc. A clock might release all the content please quote me and post this. Thanks."


Doubt it.

#9540
balance5050

balance5050
  • Members
  • 5 245 messages

LenabotSE wrote...

Look, guys, I very much believe in the theory, but it's not a good thing to get really defensive if someone take a more pessimistic stance about the endings. They are not obligated to write a whole thesis with evidence and extensive counter-arguments. Again, I believe the theory, but it's good to not get your hopes up for this.

Taking the endings at face value is a very rational approach to the situation, as something like the indoc. theory has - as far as I can recall - never really been done before, and especially not in a blockbuster title. It makes a lot of sense, but even in the best of circumstances, there's only a small chance of this being true. Significantly less chance of there being DLC/extra content in the near future, though the missing disc data does have me curious.

Just don't treat the theory as an IV that's keeping you alive. Be kind, no growling. :P


"They are not obligated to write a whole thesis with evidence and extensive counter-arguments." They should if they want to be taken seriously, otherwise they are just trying to spread the pessimism to us.

Sorry, but I won't give the indoctrinated an inch.

#9541
Lili_oups

Lili_oups
  • Members
  • 161 messages

manjikengo wrote...

netarchy wrote...

manjikengo wrote...

Lili_oups wrote...

And i bet the "breath" scene is right after shepard took harbinger beams...not after the citadel explosion

That makes absolutely no sense. The BREATH ending he or she is covered in rubble too. I don't remember pushing pieces of concrete off myself before the conduit walk.


... It makes perfect sense the indoctrination theory in that the whole citadel bit *never actually happened* at all.


10/10.  Either way, the indoctrination STARTS when shepard is knocked out by harbingers laserblast. It ENDS once you see the normandy crew leaving the ship. the breath ending takes place after the normandy crew walks onto the island in lost.

Why did they removed this pic ?

#9542
DOYOURLABS

DOYOURLABS
  • Members
  • 1 731 messages
Doesn't Garrus's speech about "cold calculus" or something seem to fit here too? He mentions sacrificing a billion to save a trillion, or something to that effect. Sacrificing the geth would be the billions, and the rest of the galaxy would be the trillions.

Also, if this is true, I owe BioWare a huge apology. This is brilliant writing, if true.

Modifié par DOYOURLABS, 14 mars 2012 - 12:23 .


#9543
Don Ravan

Don Ravan
  • Members
  • 26 messages

BrotherWarth wrote...

savionen wrote...

BrotherWarth wrote...

Why are so many people suing the fact that the ending is so stupid as a reason for it not being real? When you see a really lousy movie do you assume the filmmakers were just trolling you and are going to release their real masterpiece at a later date?


Because the other 99.9% of the trilogy was high quality. It seems fair to give Bioware the benefit of the doubt, at least for now.


Reaper baby. ME2 had a stupid ending as well.


Dude, id understand it being a stupid ending if, when you found the human reaper, Shep decided to adopt it. Then, the rest of the series is you rushing around trying to find reaper food and diapers.

Otherwise, it was a good ending.

#9544
eoinnx03

eoinnx03
  • Members
  • 1 028 messages
YES!

http://robotgeek.co....making-history/

Read this people! I'm happy to be part of this community again.

#9545
Rip504

Rip504
  • Members
  • 3 259 messages
You suggest,but prove nothing.

#9546
FryinHard

FryinHard
  • Members
  • 81 messages

balance5050 wrote...

Niemack Saarinen wrote...

Rip504 wrote...

The Pistol does not have infinite Ammo. In the way some of you claim. All guns have infinite Ammo,it's the heat sinks that need to be changed,hence this just happens to be an old model,or a special heat sink. It could simply be the Predator with 49+Shots


"A special Heat sink" thats never been seen before in the trilogy let alone those models carry high damage low magazine.    your argument is invalid.


Yeah, why would one of the old models just be lying there when you have seen one in years.


LOL about the gun… what bugs me is that a lot of you are up in arms about the gun having infinite ammo in the end(you can still reload though)… But think about that for a second.

Especially if you have low war resources and only have one option in the end… which is shooting the exploding
pipe/node/destruction. Anyways, one thing being said is
 
“I didn’t have a pistol equipped”.

Well there are plenty of bodies to pick from on the ground, and if your weapons got blasted off you… you’re going to need one cause guns solve problems. Either way, now you have this “MAGIC GUN”(lol) and it’s like that for a lot of
reasons.

What if you were an absolute terrible shot. Those 3 husks would be a serious problem. Not to mention that Turian Reaper at the end. He takes at least 2 shots, if you aim well. So that’s 5 bullets needed, right there.

Next it is said that the gun isn’t in your hands after being beamed up… So what? Shep fell down and picked it up again. He knows it, too, since as soon as he is able he is looking for it. Oh, but this one also has infinite ammo. Again… So what?

Let’s say it’s the same gun and has already had 5 rounds through it from when you picked it up. I think it would make the next scene really hard to pull off if you spent the rest of your ammo shooting the Keepers on the walk up, heh i did. Imagine when TIM made a move to shoot at you and you were like “oh no TIM not today”…

click. click.
Bam, he shoots you dead. Would have been nice to have that “Magic gun” there.

Anyways, let’s say you talk TIM into suicide and save 1 bullet…
You still need 1 to shoot Anderson. So that is 6 shots so far. Let’s say Shepard picks up a Carnifex that only has 9 shots in the mag. Which would make the final decision scene really difficult.

Figure you go through the talks and pick “destroy”. You sashay on up to the area and are required to shoot the pipe to
destroy it. You have 3 shots left.
OH but it takes 4 shots to go boom.


You lose before you even get the ending where you lose. Not good. So in my opinion the gun with infinite ammo is a plot device to move the story along. Since if you didn’t have it, you could run out of ammo only to be stranded in the end with no way to end the game, or inevitably get killed by TIM when you can’t Renegade option shoot him. See what I’m saying.



Not trying to disprove anything, just some things get way too much focus and blown out of proportion.     And since I am finally getting around to posting let's add some more things...


In fact I whole heartedly subscribe to the possibility of the end being a near death experience, which determines Shepards resolve and is very important for the internal war that is raging inside Shepard’s mind.

Another thing that happened to me that I’m surprised didn’t get more press by some here, was when you spoke with Joker immediately after the Legion Virtual Reality he make a really interesting comment. Says something along the lines of
“well if you were convinced that was real how do you know
everything you are experiencing outside of it is real. How do you know that all
of this is not just some simulation and you are still hooked up in the Geth
ship?”

This was a really awesome point for him to bring up and made me think about it from then on… Hell there was also plenty of Reaper viruses hanging around in there, too. You never know.


I think that the first time you see the kid, playing outside(with a Normandy shuttle no less….mmmmmm foreshadowing), that is the only real time he is alive and there. The idea had to come from somewhere for the Reapers to use in their suggestions.  I don’t believe it’s an indoctrination thing, it seems to be more important to be a free will thing. Like the Reapers need Shepard to put everything he believes behind his decision and are working the whole time to suggest and plant their own agenda in him. They even said it, when the collective consciousness of the Reapers mentioned they couldn’t use TIM since he was basically under their control. Hell if that was the case they could have just lifted TIM right on up there and told him to jump into the pretty green light.


I think it’s funny that some of you guys are calling the kid "GOD KID". Since the Reapers, ie god kid, basically represent what could arguably be PURE EVIL. Who is also acting in a way that they are a collective consciousness trying to persuade you, good guy, or use suggestion to bend you to their will. They need something from you. The KID outright says that, says ‘We need each other’. He needs you to make the choice yourself, which would end you and preserve them. All the while, if you don’t give into their fancy trickery and lies and stick to your resolve, ignoring all that makes you second guess your main goal…you live and they die. The whole game they are trying to get you on their side.
Not really by pure indoctrination, since they say that they can’t use TIM for that very reason, but by you using free will and choice to extend their lifespan by giving up yours. Ultimately getting their goals accomplished. It’s
kind of an interesting thought especially if you subscribe to it possibly being a NEAR DEATH EXPERIENCE. Since you can’t hallucinate while knocked the fack out. It could be a dream but… NDE is more plausible, imo.



But seriously, Joker even said it. How do we know anything we are experiencing is real, after being in the virtual reality. He is planting the idea right there. Your subconscious also warns you in the dreams, especially the last one. Where it is basically saying, don't go with the kid or you will burn.

I am replaying the game cause of this thread and lots of the additions made to it by you guys to look out for things.

ALSO the 1M1 thing is interesting, as if you look on all of the doors on the Normandy there is 8M8. just sayin

Modifié par FryinHard, 14 mars 2012 - 12:40 .


#9547
Niemack Saarinen

Niemack Saarinen
  • Members
  • 465 messages

Rip504 wrote...

Niemack Saarinen wrote...

Rip504 wrote...

The Pistol does not have infinite Ammo. In the way some of you claim. All guns have infinite Ammo,it's the heat sinks that need to be changed,hence this just happens to be an old model,or a special heat sink. It could simply be the Predator with 49+Shots


"A special Heat sink" thats never been seen before in the trilogy let alone those models carry high damage low magazine.    your argument is invalid.


LMAO,No heatsink just a gun. Your argument is based on thin air.




I'm using your words. you stated a "Special heat sink"  or a "predator that carries 49+ shots" if these models were so ruthlessly efficient with their shot count then why arent we ever introduced to it throughout the trilogy?  why "Perfect" this "Old model" with a model that fires fewer shots? Your argument is invalid.


I sure as hell would like to have had this magical 49+ Old model of a predator that dwarfs its newer renditions completely in every regard to efficiency.

#9548
Djodrake

Djodrake
  • Members
  • 1 messages
 Came to think of the child you met on earth, and died when taking off in the shuttle, its the same child in your nightmares (obviously) and the same "child" when your at the ending, how does this "God" know about this specific child that Shepard met and the same child Shepard saw in his dreams? I would certainly believe that its some reaper messing with his mind or him dreaming about it all, because why would this "God" show up in the form of a small child and specifically the one you saw die on earth and in your dreams? 

#9549
Pyewacket

Pyewacket
  • Members
  • 134 messages

balance5050 wrote...

LenabotSE wrote...

Look, guys, I very much believe in the theory, but it's not a good thing to get really defensive if someone take a more pessimistic stance about the endings. They are not obligated to write a whole thesis with evidence and extensive counter-arguments. Again, I believe the theory, but it's good to not get your hopes up for this.

Taking the endings at face value is a very rational approach to the situation, as something like the indoc. theory has - as far as I can recall - never really been done before, and especially not in a blockbuster title. It makes a lot of sense, but even in the best of circumstances, there's only a small chance of this being true. Significantly less chance of there being DLC/extra content in the near future, though the missing disc data does have me curious.

Just don't treat the theory as an IV that's keeping you alive. Be kind, no growling. :P


"They are not obligated to write a whole thesis with evidence and extensive counter-arguments." They should if they want to be taken seriously, otherwise they are just trying to spread the pessimism to us.

Sorry, but I won't give the indoctrinated an inch.


Agreed.  We're (for the most part) offering up reasonable evidence to support this and they're just scrunching up their faces and going, " Un uh!  Bioware's just dumb."  It's so frustrating.

#9550
Sl4sh3r

Sl4sh3r
  • Members
  • 256 messages

Rip504 wrote...

The Pistol does not have infinite Ammo. In the way some of you claim. All guns have infinite Ammo,it's the heat sinks that need to be changed,hence this just happens to be an old model,or a special heat sink. It could simply be the Predator with 49+Shots


Hm?



Just uploaded that for ya.

Enjoy

Edit: And just to clarify... Your theory is that some magic pistol with 49+ rounds appeared our of no where for you to use? And THAT'S more believable than our theory?

Modifié par Sl4sh3r, 14 mars 2012 - 12:26 .