Ce sujet est fermé
kaotician wrote...
spacefiddle wrote...
Yeah, even if this is all what I think it is... your only choice that gives even a hope of survival is choosing to murder the Geth you just helped to saveChrumpek wrote...
Sidenote that prolly was somwhere among the lines of those 500 pages:
God child tells you that if you choose to destroy, it kills every synthethic life, even shepard since he got plenty of synth in him.
I did that and then I see my shepard breathing in the end movie... wha?
ID theory demands that this choice is counter-intuitive: with very, very little to go on, the player must suddenly decide that the game itself is not to be trusted. I think this is a plausible explanation, but a poor design choice. The player is not given enough alternate information to be able to come to this conclusion. It's too rushed and abrupt. If they wanted to go this route it could have been done SO much better.
tl;dr of the ID (Indoctrination) theory (well, one of them) is that, at the end there, none of that is exactly real. You're on the ground, in London, hit by Harby's beam. And what you experience after that is a last-ditch effort by Harby to indoctrinate Shepard. So everything Godboi tells you is BS, and the choice he tries to warn you away from - Destroy the Reapers - is the right one. It's what you came here to do. It won't kill you OR the Geth: Godboi is lying. Is, in fact, Harby.
And it goes further: control the Reapers. Well, we just explained to TIM that this is impossible - but it's in Paragon Blue. Good choice!
Destroy the Reapers is in Renegade Red, and further tied in with slaughtering the Geth, EDI and yourself.
Synthesis is a middle-ground where this falls apart, a little. If it's Harby, not sure why he offers this at all instead of pushing Control more, but that question branches into MORE sub-theories.
Go read the ID theory post, the OP breaks down summaries of "leading theories."
(And I still think Shepard was the Catlyst all along!)
I like most of this theory, the trouble is that it just makes no sense overall since effectively you're saying that Harby, with no reason to do so whatsoever, offers Shepherd a 'pick a card, any card' option, one of which includes his own destruction, and all the other Reapers too. Why would he do that? It's just crazy.
Noo, it's ideas, the destroy option doesn't actually destroy anything ('cause Shep is passed out on earth) It's the IDEA that Shep hasn't lost sight of the true goal, which is to destroy the reapers.
Retour en haut
