Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the ending a hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory


57139 réponses à ce sujet

#16651
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

SnowyKai wrote...

Dwailing wrote...

KujaTheDarkOne2 wrote...

Dwailing wrote...

Why!?  Because he is Prothean?  Having learned about their culture, I am very cautious about following any advice Javik gives me.  He said I couldn't win without sacrificing my honor, but here I am, a very dedicated Paragon, bringing a massive fleet to battle the Reapers.  Or I will be anyway once I reach the battle for Earth. (In the interest of full disclosure, I do occasionally use a Renegade line or interrupt, but I always try to be very Paragon.  The last Renegade thing I did was punching Han'Garrel after the Geth Dreadnought, but I think he deserved it. :))


Just wanted to note real quick that I am almost a pure Paragon... The only two Renegade options I took was to shoot Udina (wasn't willing to chance that he might actually kill the councilor) and then killing Kai Leng. F*** that guy. Knowing Kaiden takes Udina out now, I might possibly not do that Renegade interrupt again... but I will always kill Kai Leng. "For Thane" indeed.


I did shoot Udina, wasn't going to pass that opportunity up. ;)  I also took the interrupt at the end of the dialogue between the Salarian Dalatress, Wrex, and Primarch Victus.  So I have the option to kill or spare Kai Leng?  That will be a tough choice.

Edit: Or is the choice with Leng simply the method of his death?


You can't spare Leng. The only thing that changes between the renegade interrupt and not is that if you do the interrupt, Shep breaks Leng's sword then stabs him. If you don't, he/she moves out of the way, and stabs him. 


I just watched a video of what happens if you take the interrupt.  I am so going to do it.

#16652
Jere85

Jere85
  • Members
  • 1 542 messages
Bunch of trolls on twitter or they are just 12 years or younger.
Last bunch apparantly liked the ending... Have they ever played me1 me2?
No sane person would actually applaud BW for this.

#16653
S Atomeha

S Atomeha
  • Members
  • 847 messages

GamiSB wrote...

ArkkAngel007 wrote...

GamiSB, you realize that TIM's eyes are the result of contact with Reaper technology, right? And for Saren it was the same (this instant with Sovereign), except that BioWare became lazy with Saren's design and had it the same throughout the game, instead of adding the geth/Reaper augmentations after Virmire.

Figured you should know that if you weren't aware.


I was not aware. I take it this happens in the comic?

yep, the comic series evolution. gives him the ability to understand things a lot faster then any other living thing ever.
he learns Asari in a sentence after all.

#16654
KujaTheDarkOne2

KujaTheDarkOne2
  • Members
  • 477 messages

Sefriol wrote...

Dwailing wrote...

Sefriol wrote...

+ Maybe Anderson hided from the Harbinger and didn't get shot because of that? Please - you can get an answer to everything. Even if it seems unlikely it's always as good as yours before BW says otherwise.


Maybe Anderson hid from the Reapers, but doesn't he sprint towards the beam just like Shepard, and does it look like there is a spot for him to hide?


Terrain is not flat and there is 2 tanks in front of the beam which aren't completely decimated. He could have hid somewhere. You cannot deny that even if you so much want to.

+ Who said that game in Mass effect saga has to involve Shepard or even humans? It can be based on time when Protheans lived.

KujaTheDarkOne2 wrote...
It doesn't make much sense for Bioware to spend so many games showing us that synthetics and organics can get along and then say "nope, it can actually never work - forget all that stuff with Legion and EDI".

It makes as much sense as this theory. Talking about thing like this is waste of time

Dwailing wrote...
You saw the only way to enter the room with the panel. It was directly in front of you. There were no other corridors leading to the room. And as you walked through the first corridor, with all the bodies, Anderson described walking through a similar area, meaning you two were probably approximately the same distance from the panel room. Then he says a wall's opening or something and you stop hearing from him and he's suddenly already bent over the panel. It doesn't really make much sense.

If you play the part you see that there is a change that Anderson is ahead of you, but you can't see him. even if that is not right it might be a design flaw. I don't need to give you better explanation. The ending might be the last thing they done and this is the result.


Does anyone have a picture of the hill you run down?  I really don't recall it having much in the way of plausible cover. And again, you're pointing to a change in Anderson's characterization that seems implausible. He would not duck off the side to hide while everyone else charges.

It really doesn't make as much sense as this theory, actually.

And your final argument is basically "Bioware designed it badly", which really isn't much of an argument at all.

#16655
SnowyKai

SnowyKai
  • Members
  • 37 messages

Dwailing wrote...

SnowyKai wrote...

Dwailing wrote...

KujaTheDarkOne2 wrote...

Dwailing wrote...

Why!?  Because he is Prothean?  Having learned about their culture, I am very cautious about following any advice Javik gives me.  He said I couldn't win without sacrificing my honor, but here I am, a very dedicated Paragon, bringing a massive fleet to battle the Reapers.  Or I will be anyway once I reach the battle for Earth. (In the interest of full disclosure, I do occasionally use a Renegade line or interrupt, but I always try to be very Paragon.  The last Renegade thing I did was punching Han'Garrel after the Geth Dreadnought, but I think he deserved it. :))


Just wanted to note real quick that I am almost a pure Paragon... The only two Renegade options I took was to shoot Udina (wasn't willing to chance that he might actually kill the councilor) and then killing Kai Leng. F*** that guy. Knowing Kaiden takes Udina out now, I might possibly not do that Renegade interrupt again... but I will always kill Kai Leng. "For Thane" indeed.


I did shoot Udina, wasn't going to pass that opportunity up. ;)  I also took the interrupt at the end of the dialogue between the Salarian Dalatress, Wrex, and Primarch Victus.  So I have the option to kill or spare Kai Leng?  That will be a tough choice.

Edit: Or is the choice with Leng simply the method of his death?


You can't spare Leng. The only thing that changes between the renegade interrupt and not is that if you do the interrupt, Shep breaks Leng's sword then stabs him. If you don't, he/she moves out of the way, and stabs him. 


I just watched a video of what happens if you take the interrupt.  I am so going to do it.


Yeah, it is pretty f-ing badass. :D 

#16656
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

KujaTheDarkOne2 wrote...

Sefriol wrote...

Dwailing wrote...

Sefriol wrote...

+ Maybe Anderson hided from the Harbinger and didn't get shot because of that? Please - you can get an answer to everything. Even if it seems unlikely it's always as good as yours before BW says otherwise.


Maybe Anderson hid from the Reapers, but doesn't he sprint towards the beam just like Shepard, and does it look like there is a spot for him to hide?


Terrain is not flat and there is 2 tanks in front of the beam which aren't completely decimated. He could have hid somewhere. You cannot deny that even if you so much want to.

+ Who said that game in Mass effect saga has to involve Shepard or even humans? It can be based on time when Protheans lived.

KujaTheDarkOne2 wrote...
It doesn't make much sense for Bioware to spend so many games showing us that synthetics and organics can get along and then say "nope, it can actually never work - forget all that stuff with Legion and EDI".

It makes as much sense as this theory. Talking about thing like this is waste of time

Dwailing wrote...
You saw the only way to enter the room with the panel. It was directly in front of you. There were no other corridors leading to the room. And as you walked through the first corridor, with all the bodies, Anderson described walking through a similar area, meaning you two were probably approximately the same distance from the panel room. Then he says a wall's opening or something and you stop hearing from him and he's suddenly already bent over the panel. It doesn't really make much sense.

If you play the part you see that there is a change that Anderson is ahead of you, but you can't see him. even if that is not right it might be a design flaw. I don't need to give you better explanation. The ending might be the last thing they done and this is the result.


Does anyone have a picture of the hill you run down?  I really don't recall it having much in the way of plausible cover. And again, you're pointing to a change in Anderson's characterization that seems implausible. He would not duck off the side to hide while everyone else charges.

It really doesn't make as much sense as this theory, actually.

And your final argument is basically "Bioware designed it badly", which really isn't much of an argument at all.


Huh, I must have written that last part a while back, I don't remember it.  And I agree.  Saying that Bioware designed something badly is like saying that the next Call of Duty is going to be the most innovative game ever.  "This doesn't seem physically possible!" to quote Private Jimmy.

#16657
S Atomeha

S Atomeha
  • Members
  • 847 messages
whoever posted the pic of anderson as he says "They're controlling you" i just double checked, he never looks at TIM as he says it, either in shepards direction or the camera

#16658
mutermath

mutermath
  • Members
  • 191 messages
so is it every time you choose the destroy option that sheps wakes up?
i just completed a play and chose that but no scene of him waking up.

#16659
jackncoke28

jackncoke28
  • Members
  • 220 messages
Is it me, or doesn't synthesis seem like some sort of space magic eugenics. It's why that ending never sat well with me. It's like saying the only way to cure racism and bigotry is to genetically modify everyone to be exactly the same, when the whole reason you'd want to get rid of racism and bigotry is because you respect differences in people. Anyways it all adds to destroy being the obvious choice for me, the only ending that asserts free will.

#16660
FalconRising

FalconRising
  • Members
  • 11 messages

GamiSB wrote...

-Choosing IndoctrinationI hope I don't mind**** anyone, including myself. Here goes. I find it kind of hard to believe that if the events on the Citadel are Shepard's mind's interpretation of Indoctrination, then the path that equates to resisting indoctrination is the path you've been working towards all along. I'll elaborate; if indoctrination is the type of control you have to choose to accept, on whatever level, it makes more sense to disguise that acceptance as something the subject is known to be receptive to. Reaper files on Shepard must be extensive, they know s/he's working to destroy them. In other words, if all of that is a hallucination intended to indoctrinate Shepard, then to me Destruction seems the most likely to lead to indoctrination, as Shepard's mind has accepted the fantasy - after all, it came to Shepard disguised as the goal Shepard's been working towards all along. In fact, if this the case, then it's likely that choosing any of Destruction, Control or Synthesis within the confines of the hallucination leads to Shepard's indoctrination, and the only way out would be to shoot the god-child/AI, shoot yourself, or something else that reflects exertion of your will over that of Sovereign's. This is all, of course, assuming our understanding of indoctrination is accurate.

My thought on this is that not all of Shepard is taken at that point. A part of him is still controlling his mind and able give him a way out that he will recognize. It is after all still his mind so he must have some say in controlling how his imagination works. The kid is not necessarily evil or an agent of the Reaper’s he is a piece of Shepard (symbolized by both male and female voices being played alongside the kids) that is being corrupted to try and sway him to an outcome they want. 


What I'm trying to say is that if Shepard's mind is fighting the indoctrination and trying to give him/her a way out of it, that way out isn't going to be through the fantasy playing out to one of its three conclusions; those can only lead to indoctrination.  If there is a way out, it has to be though somehow rejecting the choices presented by the hallucination. 

Given that we saw the walls shifting when walking over to the console, I'm willing to push the "I believe" button on there being a hidden door that concealed TIM so he could appear when he did. 

The radio chatter was referenced in one of the youtube vids I watched summarizing all of this.

I don't think ID Theory can be written off, but I do think it could be much harder to grasp and accept, if the points I've raised go unanswered and given the colossal amount of coincedentally bad writing that went into the ending.

#16661
Raze4573

Raze4573
  • Members
  • 123 messages
It has always been that Shep=The Player.
So if Anderson in that pic isnt looking at TIM but towards Shepard and in that angle its clear that its directed to us.

#16662
AdmiralsJack

AdmiralsJack
  • Members
  • 161 messages

mutermath wrote...

so is it every time you choose the destroy option that sheps wakes up?
i just completed a play and chose that but no scene of him waking up.


only if you have enough war assets

#16663
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

mutermath wrote...

so is it every time you choose the destroy option that sheps wakes up?
i just completed a play and chose that but no scene of him waking up.


The scene with Shepard waking up only occurs if you choose Destroy with an effective military strength of 4,000 or above, 5,000 or above if you don't stop TIM from executing Anderson.

#16664
SnowyKai

SnowyKai
  • Members
  • 37 messages

mutermath wrote...

so is it every time you choose the destroy option that sheps wakes up?
i just completed a play and chose that but no scene of him waking up.

You have to have over 4,000 EMS to get that scene. 

#16665
Yakko77

Yakko77
  • Members
  • 2 794 messages

Jere85 wrote...

Shot Udina and took revenge on Kai Leng, nobody messes with my crew and gets away with it... oh wait.


Yeah, my paragon Sheps did that too but the only renegade option we have right now is boycott I'm afraid.

#16666
GunMoth

GunMoth
  • Members
  • 731 messages
 Okay I'm back. Kind of backtracking on "What is indoctrination?" "How could TIM control us?" "Thorian creeper vs. reaper indoctrination". I found the quotes from the wiki and the codex that shed light on the differences between the two. If TIM WAS controlling Shepard (assuming you don't believe in the indoctrination theory) it wasn't couldnt have been through the power of indoctrination, but had to have been by other means. There are NO examples / text of someone losing control of their "actions" before "believing" in the reaper's cause. The reaper will erode your thought processes FIRST then take control of your body. The thorian creeper is the opposite. It takes control of your mind by using pain to condition your body to do something it wants. 

If you believe the indoctrination theory begins at the elevator, then this is evidence that TIM had used his implants to begin indoctrinating Shepard. If you believe the indoctrination process is carried on throughout the game and that Shepard starts his/her dream during the laser, then TIM is simply a figment of your imagination. 

According to the wiki the amount of time it takes the reaper signal to erode someone's mental ability / willpower is anywhere from a couple days to a full week. However, its not uncommon for people to start having issues within the first contact. The farmers on Eden Prime complained about a "jamming signal" and how you "couldnt hear yourself think". This is within the first few moments of Saren's landing on the colony. So far (that we can be 100% certain on) is that indoctrination is caused by 2 things: A reaper and a reaper artifact. There COULD be other variables, but these are examples we've seen in the game/novels. 

"The more control Sovereign has over a person, the less capable they become. Saren realized that to keep his mind free of Sovereign's control, he had to make himself an invaluable resource."

"As ExoGeni watched, it took less than a month for 80% of Zhu's Hope's inhabitants to become infected and begin performing tasks for the Thorian. The ExoGeni VI reports that via these spores, the Thorian issues mental commands to its thralls;"

"Only people with immense mental strength are able to resist indoctrination, and even then, only for a short time."

"To keep Saren loyal, Sovereign put cybernetic implants in Saren's body and used those implants to influence and control the former Spectre."

"The control the 
Thorian exerts using spores is similar to indoctrination, though the initial conditioning is different. While Reaper indoctrination erodes the psyche until an individual just stops thinking for themselves, the spores allow the Thorian to control its thralls using pain as reinforcement and punishment. If a victim refuses the Thorian's orders, the result is pain so severe that it soon conditions the individual against even considering rebellion; the removal of the pain when they comply serves as further reinforcement. This conditioning allows the Thorian almost complete control of those it enslaves, so that they will even die to protect it.""However, this means that a disciplined mind can resist Thorian enslavement more easily than Reaper indoctrination. Fai Dan and Ian Newstead, for example, are both known to have been able to resist Thorian enslavement to some degree. However, unlike the Reapers, the Thorian is careful not to deliberately injure its thralls; also, Thorian enslavement ceased immediately when the Thorian died, whereas Reaper slaves were left in a permanently indoctrinated state once the Reapers had left."

Modifié par GunMoth, 17 mars 2012 - 10:22 .


#16667
JTP117

JTP117
  • Members
  • 286 messages
I love this thread. The logic is simply undeniable.

#16668
Raze4573

Raze4573
  • Members
  • 123 messages
Shepard was wounded, feeling guilty after being unable to save the child, after losing Ashley/Kaidan/Thane/Mordin/anyone else that died during ME2.
So honestly, you can copy paste as much as you want but Shepard was in such state that his mind was vulnerable enough to get probed and manipulated.

#16669
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

Yakko77 wrote...

Jere85 wrote...

Shot Udina and took revenge on Kai Leng, nobody messes with my crew and gets away with it... oh wait.


Yeah, my paragon Sheps did that too but the only renegade option we have right now is boycott I'm afraid.


What, you mean we can't go the the Bioware offices and start punching random members of the team to get what we want? jk, jk

#16670
GunMoth

GunMoth
  • Members
  • 731 messages

Raze4573 wrote...

Shepard was wounded, feeling guilty after being unable to save the child, after losing Ashley/Kaidan/Thane/Mordin/anyone else that died during ME2.
So honestly, you can copy paste as much as you want but Shepard was in such state that his mind was vulnerable enough to get probed and manipulated.


I don't think you understand where I'm coming from. I believe in the indoctrination theory. o_o;; 
I was saying that TIM taking control of shep's body but not his / her mind makes no sense in comparison to him simply being a hallucination (makes more sense imo) 

Him taking control of the body but not the mind is what thorians* do.

Modifié par GunMoth, 17 mars 2012 - 10:28 .


#16671
mutermath

mutermath
  • Members
  • 191 messages

Dwailing wrote...

mutermath wrote...

so is it every time you choose the destroy option that sheps wakes up?
i just completed a play and chose that but no scene of him waking up.


The scene with Shepard waking up only occurs if you choose Destroy with an effective military strength of 4,000 or above, 5,000 or above if you don't stop TIM from executing Anderson.

what about making TIM shooting himself i got full rep but still didn't get bthe option

#16672
S Atomeha

S Atomeha
  • Members
  • 847 messages

Raze4573 wrote...

It has always been that Shep=The Player.
So if Anderson in that pic isnt looking at TIM but towards Shepard and in that angle its clear that its directed to us.

Yep, it's hard to catch if your not looking carefully at it. but it looks like he is addressing you, and not TIM

#16673
Raze4573

Raze4573
  • Members
  • 123 messages
Sorry, its 11pm, i'm sleep deprived and I think St Patty celebration is making my judgement shift from Paragon to Renegade.
I actually saw you trying to take the indoctrination theory down...while you were saying it has more sense than TIM taking control...
Good Starchild God I have been indoctrinated by alcohol!

#16674
SirLugash

SirLugash
  • Members
  • 388 messages
@FalconRising : When you consider TIM as the part of Sheps mind already indoctrinated and Anderson the part still fighting, the indoced one would offer you the ways which will result in complete indoctrination (control, synthesis) and the free one will give you the alternative (destroy).

Modifié par SirLugash, 17 mars 2012 - 10:30 .


#16675
ba0987

ba0987
  • Members
  • 22 messages

GamiSB wrote...

ArkkAngel007 wrote...

GamiSB, you realize that TIM's eyes are the result of contact with Reaper technology, right? And for Saren it was the same (this instant with Sovereign), except that BioWare became lazy with Saren's design and had it the same throughout the game, instead of adding the geth/Reaper augmentations after Virmire.

Figured you should know that if you weren't aware.


I was not aware. I take it this happens in the comic?


Yup in Evolution don't want to spoil it too much but TIM finds out about Reapers long before Shep does and gets synthetic eyes etc.

Its why he is so ready to believe you in me2.

Modifié par ba0987, 17 mars 2012 - 10:39 .