Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the ending a hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory


57139 réponses à ce sujet

#17101
Raze4573

Raze4573
  • Members
  • 123 messages
After that when I got to the dream sequence and heard Mordin, Thane, Legion...
I was ready to grab a bucket of ice cream and cry all day.

#17102
Legion109

Legion109
  • Members
  • 144 messages
I know it's been mentioned before but was anyone else unnerved by the "oily shadows" in sheps dreams. I was like oh sh*t Rachni queen talked about oily shadow.

Indoception

#17103
arkhine

arkhine
  • Members
  • 122 messages

Vandicus wrote...
The part about them removing tons of used games from the market still stands though. I like to think it was Bioware/EA's cunning plan to vastly increase the number of new copy sales over used copy sales. 


That is just evil. If they pull it off, I can see other companies or EA doing that for their future games. Imagine Assassin's Creed 3 without a closure ending (although I stopped playing halfway through Brotherhood, need to go finish that) and then Ubisoft asking for payment later on. Ugh.
 

#17104
Raze4573

Raze4573
  • Members
  • 123 messages
I wonder if it was Shep being slowly indoctrinated at that moment or perhaps all the prothean data in his brain etc made him somehow predict the future in a way.
AHEM Prince of Persia: Epilogue. Nuff said.

Modifié par Raze4573, 18 mars 2012 - 06:36 .


#17105
arkhine

arkhine
  • Members
  • 122 messages

Raze4573 wrote...

After that when I got to the dream sequence and heard Mordin, Thane, Legion...
I was ready to grab a bucket of ice cream and cry all day.


I was about to burst into tears at Ashley and Garrus's 'goodbye' dialogue. Then I heard the 'Leaving Earth' theme at the end of the credits. After that I heard the cut Anderson dialogue about Shepard being a good dad. 

This game makes me feel like :crying: all the time.

#17106
Raze4573

Raze4573
  • Members
  • 123 messages
But then the Starchild appears and knee kicks you in the quad.

#17107
balance5050

balance5050
  • Members
  • 5 245 messages
Here's one that I don't know if any one caught: The mass relay beam at the end DOESN'T start in the sol system. At first I thought it was the viper system (The Arrival) but the layout and angle actually makes it seem as if it's coming from Hades Nexus.

http://i39.tinypic.com/1zzm03l.png

http://fc07.devianta...art-d3a34qx.png

Modifié par balance5050, 18 mars 2012 - 06:41 .


#17108
balance5050

balance5050
  • Members
  • 5 245 messages
 Posted ImagefPosted Image

#17109
Martukis

Martukis
  • Members
  • 325 messages
Looks more like the Viper Nebula to me

#17110
kyg_20X6

kyg_20X6
  • Members
  • 854 messages
twitter.com/#!/JessicaMerizan/status/181251582812364802

EDIT: My question.

Modifié par kyg_20X6, 18 mars 2012 - 06:44 .


#17111
Raze4573

Raze4573
  • Members
  • 123 messages
Not sure if youre correct about Hades Nexus but yeah...it doesnt seem like its originating in the Sol system.

#17112
Vandicus

Vandicus
  • Members
  • 2 426 messages

arkhine wrote...

Vandicus wrote...
The part about them removing tons of used games from the market still stands though. I like to think it was Bioware/EA's cunning plan to vastly increase the number of new copy sales over used copy sales. 


That is just evil. If they pull it off, I can see other companies or EA doing that for their future games. Imagine Assassin's Creed 3 without a closure ending (although I stopped playing halfway through Brotherhood, need to go finish that) and then Ubisoft asking for payment later on. Ugh.
 


I'm wavering on whether or not that strategy is evil in this particular case, because I think the indoctrination angle is actually the most brilliant plot twist I've ever seen. Ever. Its not really possible to do for most of the gamers(who try to optimize their endings) unless Bioware pulls a move like this. It just so happens that it'll also grossly manipulate the markets in their favor. And the sad/slightly funny thing about it, is that regardless of the necessity of such a manevuer to deliver a more impactful ending(as in the case of indoc theory) the market manipulation part works under pretty much any circumstance. Gamers will hold onto their copies in the future in case this happens again, decreasing # of used copies, and people who usually only want to wait a week or 2 for a $10+ discount will go ahead and buy it new since it might mean a wait of a month or more.

#17113
Legion109

Legion109
  • Members
  • 144 messages

Raze4573 wrote...
I wonder if it was Shep being slowly indoctrinated at that moment or perhaps all the prothean data in his brain etc made him somehow predict the future in a way.AHEM Prince of Persia: Epilogue. Nuff said.

Theory - I wonder if Shep has subtle hints of Indoctrination not enough to take control just enough to present the whisperings in Sheps head, however it's being held back by Sheps will which is slowly being eroded in Mass Effect 3 (Mordin, Thane/Kirrahe, Legion deaths) Loss on Thessia, then the final erosion "Am I really just a VI of myself" so when Harby's laser knocks him unconscious he becomes much easier prey to indoctrination.
Sidenotes: 1) When have the Reapers ever actual called themselves reapers their arrogance demands they present themselves almost as gods... 2) What's Harby's real name we know Soveriegn is Nazara... 3) When did Harby get the name Harbringer as I remember nobody ever actually calls it that so did Shep just give it that name.... 4) Isn't it funny that you get a VI of yourself in ME2 then in ME3 Shep thinks he may just be a VI.(forgive the spelling I'm on a smartphone)
Indoception

#17114
arkhine

arkhine
  • Members
  • 122 messages

Raze4573 wrote...

But then the Starchild appears and knee kicks you in the quad.


Not really too bothered yet. I have this amazing thread and the people here to thank. Then there is the fact that Broken Steel happened and money grubbing video game companies won't pass up the chance to milk us.

#17115
Deteramot

Deteramot
  • Members
  • 13 messages
Y'know, basically from the very first dream sequence, my first thought was "Indoctrination." The theory really just seems to fit too well for it just to be a coincidence.

That said, I find myself increasingly disillusioned with Bioware's lack of response and careful deflection of the questions. It doesn't make a whole lot of sense from a business standpoint to have 89% of your fans say that they hated the ending to your game, and then never address their concerns. I just have to shake my head at that.

#17116
Raze4573

Raze4573
  • Members
  • 123 messages
Harbingers name could be on the datapad Shepard got from Joker at the end of ME2.

#17117
DenmaDev

DenmaDev
  • Members
  • 5 messages
Hi there. Been following this thread for about a week now. I haven't been able to read every single page and post, so this might have been mentioned before. I don't know. Regardless, I'm throwing it out:

Just finished up a new playthrough. During the Anderson/Shepard/Illusive Man confrontation, I decided to go Renegade as opposed to Paragon. I wanted the pleasure of taking TIM's life. Usually I just stick to choosing the red dialogue for TIM's very last line so I can shoot him, but this time I did it for each response. The first red dialogue has Shepard asking TIM something along the lines of, "If you can control the Reapers, why are you bothering with us?" (Not word for word. I didn't pay full attention to the line.)

What stuck out to me, and what I made sure to remember, was TIM's response to this question, which, after reading this theory and wishing it to be true, set off an alarm in my head. He responds, "Because I need you to believe."

Why on Earth would that be his response? Villainous gloating, maybe? The Reapers gloating through him? Or, as the theory would state, is he the voice of indoctrination saying that Shepard needs to believe that the Reapers don't need to be destroyed.

Just felt I'd throw that one in.

#17118
balance5050

balance5050
  • Members
  • 5 245 messages

Martukis wrote...

Looks more like the Viper Nebula to me


I thought that to, but viper nebula doesn't connect to an adjacent relay like it shows in the ending scene.

Modifié par balance5050, 18 mars 2012 - 07:04 .


#17119
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 813 messages

balance5050 wrote...

Martukis wrote...

Looks more like the Viper Nebula to me


I thought that to, but viper nebula doesn't connect to an adjacent relay like it shows in the ending scene.


If the Alpha Relay was still there it would have connected to every other Relay in the galaxy. That was what was special about it, and why we couldnt let the Reapers get it.

The fact that the Relay isnt there, yet it is clearly where the chain reaction starts makes absolutely no sense.

#17120
Raze4573

Raze4573
  • Members
  • 123 messages
The point is that it doesnt start in the Sol system, how could a random relay send the Crucibles space magic without being connected to it?
And DenmaDev, interesting find.

#17121
Iconoclaste

Iconoclaste
  • Members
  • 1 469 messages

DenmaDev wrote...

What stuck out to me, and what I made sure to remember, was TIM's response to this question, which, after reading this theory and wishing it to be true, set off an alarm in my head. He responds, "Because I need you to believe."

Why on Earth would that be his response? Villainous gloating, maybe? The Reapers gloating through him? Or, as the theory would state, is he the voice of indoctrination saying that Shepard needs to believe that the Reapers don't need to be destroyed.

Maybe the possibility that the Reapers trying to control Shepard through TIM (since when?) had a hard time to achieve it...

#17122
Rob Psyence

Rob Psyence
  • Members
  • 229 messages

Raze4573 wrote...

Harbingers name could be on the datapad Shepard got from Joker at the end of ME2.


I always thought it was because he says "I am the Harbinger of your destruction."

#17123
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 813 messages

DenmaDev wrote...

Hi there. Been following this thread for about a week now. I haven't been able to read every single page and post, so this might have been mentioned before. I don't know. Regardless, I'm throwing it out:

Just finished up a new playthrough. During the Anderson/Shepard/Illusive Man confrontation, I decided to go Renegade as opposed to Paragon. I wanted the pleasure of taking TIM's life. Usually I just stick to choosing the red dialogue for TIM's very last line so I can shoot him, but this time I did it for each response. The first red dialogue has Shepard asking TIM something along the lines of, "If you can control the Reapers, why are you bothering with us?" (Not word for word. I didn't pay full attention to the line.)

What stuck out to me, and what I made sure to remember, was TIM's response to this question, which, after reading this theory and wishing it to be true, set off an alarm in my head. He responds, "Because I need you to believe."

Why on Earth would that be his response? Villainous gloating, maybe? The Reapers gloating through him? Or, as the theory would state, is he the voice of indoctrination saying that Shepard needs to believe that the Reapers don't need to be destroyed.

Just felt I'd throw that one in.


I actually pointed that out a couple days ago. I too found it fairly odd.

#17124
Crusina

Crusina
  • Members
  • 241 messages
So I've heard that the kid in the dream sequences screams come back here if you start moving in the opposite direction?

Any videos or evidence supporting that? I don't have a save near it so...

#17125
nighthawk132651

nighthawk132651
  • Members
  • 29 messages
Any good news on endings like from twitter or annoucments?