Protesting the Poor Treatment of Thane Krios' Romance
#4676
Posté 03 mai 2012 - 11:47
@gears I was going to try and behave myself but I can't....you do know there is a word they use for people who "romance" themselves?
I did try to keep from saying it but it kept nagging at me.
#4677
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 12:01
I'm sure programming in if Thane is romanced he doesn't die, and if Jacob is romanced, don't have him knock up another woman is not that difficult. Then adding a few e-mails to round everything out.
The solutions above for Thane and Jacob are so simple I'm begginning to think BW shafted femShep on purpose. Especially since ME2 romance barring Garrus and Tali got shafted. Did they really think that people wouldn't notice the lack of choices for femShep, or the forced ending of romances?
#4678
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 12:04
As for Brynn, I was disappointed I couldn't at least b*tch slap her snarky as$. And I didn't even romance Jacob, I just watched it on utube and instantly disliked her. So...dead is good.
~~ridges~~
#4679
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 12:06
utaker1988 wrote...
*snip*
@gears I was going to try and behave myself but I can't....you do know there is a word they use for people who "romance" themselves?
I did try to keep from saying it but it kept nagging at me.
I was going to go with handy...
And utaker...I'm a bit disappointed. I know you can do better than that.
#4680
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 12:11
DineBoo wrote...
As a Garrusmancer who would have went back to ME2 to romance Thane had they not did what they did to him, I'm throwing in my support. Jacob too on a minor scale, because even if I wouldn't romance him, what BW did to him was horrid.
I'm sure programming in if Thane is romanced he doesn't die, and if Jacob is romanced, don't have him knock up another woman is not that difficult. Then adding a few e-mails to round everything out.
The solutions above for Thane and Jacob are so simple I'm begginning to think BW shafted femShep on purpose. Especially since ME2 romance barring Garrus and Tali got shafted. Did they really think that people wouldn't notice the lack of choices for femShep, or the forced ending of romances?
Okay, I admit it. I replayed the one where Kaidan hijacked my GarrusShep. She had a good time. I thought it was well done. I loved the date on the Citadel. Having said that, they could have done a bit more, but at least you guys got something. Well, providing you had the foresight to romance him in ME2. What the hell was bw thinking??
I agree that it probably wouldn't be that difficult. Then again, one would think putting the correct LI in the "ending" flashback wouldn't be to hard either...and we all know how well that worked out. Pretty bad when the fans have to fix the developers mistakes...and actually do a better job.
Again, I have no idea what they were thinking. Maybe the blue doll under their desks was giving them ideas.
And also, welcome DineBoo!!!
#4681
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 12:47
Well, providing you had the foresight to romance him in ME2. What the hell was bw thinking??
One should not be required to have a crystal ball in order to determine if their romance lasts(or gets a satisfying conclusion) in a trilogy series.
If (and it's a big if at this point) I get into another BW series, I'm going to be afraid that who I chose to romance might be cut out of the game or butchered beyond recognition. Who wants that additional stress when I'm just trying to enjoy a game?
LOL. For this reason and favoritism alone, I refuse to romance Liara.Again, I have no idea what they were thinking. Maybe the blue doll under their desks was giving them ideas.
#4682
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 12:51
mnomaha wrote...
utaker1988 wrote...
*snip*
@gears I was going to try and behave myself but I can't....you do know there is a word they use for people who "romance" themselves?
I did try to keep from saying it but it kept nagging at me.
I was going to go with handy...
And utaker...I'm a bit disappointed. I know you can do better than that.
Yes I can do better than that but do we really need to hear what I'm thinking all the time? LOL... My mind decided to pull up roots and go reside in Thane's pants. Did I just say that out loud? :innocent: I struggle with my perversions everytime I come into this forum because what I really want to say will get me banned.
#4683
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 12:54
That's also the reason I refuse Liara each and every time. Besides the fact that they made the entire squad of ME2 obsolete, I refuse all attempts (and there are many) at bw's attempt to shove *their* canon romances in my lap. I do not want the VS or Liara. If I did, I would have romanced them on my own. and let us talk about the word "romance" for a moment...perhaps we should buy the biggest dictionary known to man and mail it to Canada...because I certainly didn't feel much romance in ME3, at least not with my LOVE interest.
#4684
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 12:56
#4685
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 01:07
mnomaha wrote...
@utaker...I love to hear your thoughts, especially the candidly dirty ones. Did you happen to write this story down? Because, although I can pretty much let my imagination go with that, I would love to hear someone else's version. And was it "expulsions" or "explosions"?
LOL...no but I imagine I can recreate it with words. I can relive every dirty thought I've ever had regarding Thane with perfect clarity.
It was more like an explosion, the story had him not, hmmmm....let's say releasing himself since Irikah. He probably could have taken out a whole Reaper Fleet.
And the dams have now burst......
#4686
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 01:08
.Apparently I have an entirely different opinion on what is satisfying. This was not it.
If I didn't consider Thane dying a nice conclusion in my non romance but loyal playthough, I especially wouldn't consider it if I romanced him. And the fact Miranda could be saved made it worse.
So true. I really didn't like I had to go out of my way not to romance Kaidan when I was trying to lock in Garrus. I especailly didn't like it when I had a harem of women come up to my cabin when I was mourning Thane all by myself. Seriously BW? You couldn't put in a one mission buffer between Thane dying and the harem coming up to the cabin?I refuse all attempts (and there are many) at bw's attempt to shove *their* canon romances in my lap.
It's not that I didn't like Sam, I sort of wish she had content like Cortez, but jeez. Also shows another area femShep got shafted, but that's another topic.
#4687
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 01:18
DineBoo wrote...
.Apparently I have an entirely different opinion on what is satisfying. This was not it.
If I didn't consider Thane dying a nice conclusion in my non romance but loyal playthough, I especially wouldn't consider it if I romanced him. And the fact Miranda could be saved made it worse.So true. I really didn't like I had to go out of my way not to romance Kaidan when I was trying to lock in Garrus. I especailly didn't like it when I had a harem of women come up to my cabin when I was mourning Thane all by myself. Seriously BW? You couldn't put in a one mission buffer between Thane dying and the harem coming up to the cabin?I refuse all attempts (and there are many) at bw's attempt to shove *their* canon romances in my lap.
It's not that I didn't like Sam, I sort of wish she had content like Cortez, but jeez. Also shows another area femShep got shafted, but that's another topic.
This is why I avoided my Cabin, I didn't go up there unless they forced me too...like during the nightmare scenes. Instead I opted for this approach....

I spent my time in Life Support, to take a break, think about what I was going to do next...but mostly cry.
#4688
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 01:21
I'm pissed enough that Thane and Jacob got such poor treatment, but jeez. That, to me, felt like Bioware was saying "They're not romances anymore, sorry."
#4689
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 01:22
So I woke up unblanketed, in my military grade undies, alone and unsatisfied because the Drell that I LOVED was murdered via poor writing.
I'm on a roll today!
@utaker...it does definitely sound like the dams have burst. Poor Thane. I would help you with that...
#4690
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 01:34
With Sam, she gets a few convos before you get a male fantasy lesbian sex scene. And for what I hear, you get more dialog with her character if you didn't do the scene. BW couldn't take the time to show Sam buying chess board, or worrying about family similar to Cortez?
Everyone, even unpopular romances, should have gotten a Liara quality romance. Period. No LI should be taken away, none should die. And if they "have" to, it needs to be across the board. If femShep has lovers taken away, so should maleShep.
#4691
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 01:46
There have been many things that have caused my face to twist into the horrified WTF face but none ever got a bigger reaction from me than the time I read that someone actually wanted Kolyat on the table as an LI. This of course was mentioned in this context, "With Thane and Jacob being taken away from FemShep, how about Vega, Joker, or even Kolyat." Oh yes..that's EXACTLY what ALL my FemShep's would do...nail Kolyat after banging his father. Really? I think even Mali would have an issue with that. "Oh Kolyat, yes I loved your Father, I still do but he'd want me to move on. Take your clothes off please." NO NO NO!!!!
#4692
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 01:57
@Utaker, umm do your like write erotic stuff for a living/hobby? Also you totally said something about there being a term for romancing ones self, Then a few posts later you go into great suggestive detail about Thane romancing himself.
@mnomaha the shapes and sizes of the human body, art, in game Drell are all male, and the only Asari are female.
And this line right here
"Again, I have no idea what they were thinking. Maybe the blue doll under their desks was giving them ideas." Umm hahaha I'm sorry but It's great, ya know how many Liara fans would tell me
"I'm just a dumb@ss for ever thinking of romancing anyone but Liara",
or that "if I was a true a fan of Samara I should totally be happy with the content I got of her in ME3 because it was more than she deserved."
Or what they tell anyone who's not a Liara fan ohh there just butthurt because they think they deserved more time with a LI that shouldn't have ever been a LI to begin with.
I wanted to **** slap Jacob when he told me "I'm gonna be a daddy, I knocked up this random chick here It's cool." I wanted to **** slap him and say "Yeah and in thousands of other realities you just cheated on a FemShep"
Good lord almighty you people in here are such vile thinkers your corrupting my mind.
#4693
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 02:02
I had no interest in Sam and certainly wasn't going down with "A varren looks better" Allers. Sorry, Anya is very much into man meat.
And I also agree about the inequality between the Sheps. DerpShep had women and men all around him. FemShep got shortchanged big time.
@utaker...BitterShep (formerly Anya) would have jumped Vega, but Javik's teeth freaked both of us out. I don't mind a little nibbling but those chompers could break bone.
and I love Kolyat, but uh, I don't want to love him. They are NOT interchangeable.
#4694
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 02:14
gearseffect wrote...
I saw the Garrus scene on Youtube, and I was like Aw what the hell man are you kidding Me? Femshep should have woken up with a naked Garrus (or ya know so far as the game shows) propped up on the other pillow smoking a pipe, and he looks over at her after she wakes up and says "Rough night? You want to to engage in some Turian per-mission exercises? I also got another pipe if you'd like to smoke after we're done honey"
@Utaker, umm do your like write erotic stuff for a living/hobby? Also you totally said something about there being a term for romancing ones self, Then a few posts later you go into great suggestive detail about Thane romancing himself.
@mnomaha the shapes and sizes of the human body, art, in game Drell are all male, and the only Asari are female.
And this line right here
"Again, I have no idea what they were thinking. Maybe the blue doll under their desks was giving them ideas." Umm hahaha I'm sorry but It's great, ya know how many Liara fans would tell me
"I'm just a dumb@ss for ever thinking of romancing anyone but Liara",
or that "if I was a true a fan of Samara I should totally be happy with the content I got of her in ME3 because it was more than she deserved."
Or what they tell anyone who's not a Liara fan ohh there just butthurt because they think they deserved more time with a LI that shouldn't have ever been a LI to begin with.
I wanted to **** slap Jacob when he told me "I'm gonna be a daddy, I knocked up this random chick here It's cool." I wanted to **** slap him and say "Yeah and in thousands of other realities you just cheated on a FemShep"
Good lord almighty you people in here are such vile thinkers your corrupting my mind.
LOL I was actually referring to the human species in real life at that point. As for the game, I personally didn't mind the all male models. I tend to prefer them, although I do appreciate beauty equally between the sexes. Not necessarily into shagging the women, but I do appreciate a good pair.
As for Thane "romancing" himself... ... ... sorry, my mind went someplace for a minute there... anyways, I would totally watch that.
Garrus smoking a pipe...I actually can visualise a hooka instead of a pipe. "old Turian tradition"
Liara fans are Liara fans. I can't begrudge anyone their LI, but I do get all forms of pissed off when the "canon" fanbase gets snarky (and downright vicious) when we discuss ours. Especially the ones the only ever romanced the blue bewbness.
#4695
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 02:16
gearseffect wrote...
I saw the Garrus scene on Youtube, and I was like Aw what the hell man are you kidding Me? Femshep should have woken up with a naked Garrus (or ya know so far as the game shows) propped up on the other pillow smoking a pipe, and he looks over at her after she wakes up and says "Rough night? You want to to engage in some Turian per-mission exercises? I also got another pipe if you'd like to smoke after we're done honey"
@Utaker, umm do your like write erotic stuff for a living/hobby? Also you totally said something about there being a term for romancing ones self, Then a few posts later you go into great suggestive detail about Thane romancing himself.
@mnomaha the shapes and sizes of the human body, art, in game Drell are all male, and the only Asari are female.
And this line right here
"Again, I have no idea what they were thinking. Maybe the blue doll under their desks was giving them ideas." Umm hahaha I'm sorry but It's great, ya know how many Liara fans would tell me
"I'm just a dumb@ss for ever thinking of romancing anyone but Liara",
or that "if I was a true a fan of Samara I should totally be happy with the content I got of her in ME3 because it was more than she deserved."
Or what they tell anyone who's not a Liara fan ohh there just butthurt because they think they deserved more time with a LI that shouldn't have ever been a LI to begin with.
I wanted to **** slap Jacob when he told me "I'm gonna be a daddy, I knocked up this random chick here It's cool." I wanted to **** slap him and say "Yeah and in thousands of other realities you just cheated on a FemShep"
Good lord almighty you people in here are such vile thinkers your corrupting my mind.
Yes, I am a vile thinker. I embraced it a long time ago. I will write down my dirty thoughts if I find that I can no longer contain them. I use to write fanfic all the time but stopped for a long time. I ignored what my thoughts were asked to do for a long time yes...then.... sexy green drell drops from the vent....mind starts to flood with dirty thoughts... fingers start to twitch... microsoft word opens.... thoughts turn into filthy stories....
It took a long time for me to start again, as I use to only do it under the influence of alcohol and a lot of it. Now, I just don't care. My ex husband had issues with my dirty mind. My current one, well he doesn't care as long as I'm happy. Not many men will willingly watch you walk out the door, get into a car, and take off for lord knows how many days to go to an event called "The Gathering of the Juggalos." Then smile when you walk in the door with face paint on and throw your Faygo, mud, and grass stained clothes on the floor and proclaim they have missed you. Besides, when he does decide to say something about my porn stories about Thane, I walk over to the closet, throw a PlayBoy at him and tell him to go busy himself.
#4696
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 02:32
mnomaha wrote...
As for Thane "romancing" himself... ... ... sorry, my mind went someplace for a minute there... anyways, I would totally watch that.
I had one with Hope and Thane on a beach about a year after the Reapers were defeated....Hope was totally watching him...of course he was watching her too...I am a complete pig and I'll just say it now so I don't have to later. With Hope and Thane everything is on the table except extra people being involved. Mali would but I haven't written anything for her only thought about it. I should just start separating these things and put them up somewhere. Right now they are all mushed together in one very long Word document because I really wrote them so that I could get the thoughts out of my head and move along to other dirty thoughts. Hope made Thane dress up in her undies before and that was an interesting little story. He's standing there and says to her, "it puts the lotion on it's skin." Like I said, there isn't a place I haven't gone.
#4697
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 02:47
But I don't think you, and others, would be saying deal with it when it comes to dealing with people who have valid complaints. I know Garrus isn't for everyone, and he has points in the fact he can be killed off. Not plot armored Liara.@DineBoo...not to mention her blue bewbs got bigger and she was *fully* nude. W.T.F.???? Now I do not want to hate on Liara fans at all, but it really pisses me off when they complain that they didn't get enough content, etc. Seriously? You're "chick" was in all three games and had a FULL romance and you're not satisfied? GTFO...really? Then again, I think I'd be the same way with Thane.
Regarding the romance scene, I said in another thread that there is a lot that can be done clothed. Garrus wasn't in armor. Why they didn't do this, or at least change the scene around to tailor to Garrus and Tali's strengths, I'll never know.
Liara has enough fluff. I'm irritated enough as it is when she shows up after Shep's bad dream instead of Garrus, who told me to get some sleep. Or her popping up in my cabin period when I couldn't get Garrus to come up, or have Tali come up more and chat.
All romances got shortchanged in someway as compared to Liara's. Two were butchered (Thane/Jacob), others shortchanged with content (Miranda/Jack/Ashley), and others didn't get consideration in the romance scene (Tali/Garrus).
Liara needs no more content. Everyone else does, with some more than others.
Thanks for let me chat, Thanemancers. You have my support and I feel your pain.
Modifié par DineBoo, 04 mai 2012 - 02:48 .
#4698
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 02:56
Thanks for the support DineBoo and you are always welcome to come chat with us, we don't consider it hijacking.
#4699
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 03:40
Funny that you mention romance scenes, as I was thinking about that today. I do a lot of video editing and in-game cinematography in both ME1/ME2. Filming what already exists (from different angles/FOV), in order to give a new take on things is one of my favorite pass times.
They could have easily done romance scenes for Tali and Garrus, it just takes tasteful creativity. Having the 'underwear' is completely unnecessary if you know how to play camera angles. For some reason they did it with Liara, but not with anyone else (gee, I wonder why).
This kind of technique would be nice for Garrus/Tali. Showing a hand on a shoulder, or just vague semi-unfocused shots that still convey a feeling of closeness. For Tali, I may have even shown quick glimpses of her shedding the suit, culminating into the reveal of her face.
I think what they forgot is love scenes don't necessarily have to be about full-blown sex, but intimacy. Implied things, hurried glimpses, subtle physical contact, etc. can be just as beautiful and arousing in it's own right.
As I see it, a lot of potential wasted. What do I know, though? I only did something similar with stuff they already created...
with Thane.
<_<
Modifié par Aislinn Trista, 04 mai 2012 - 03:53 .
#4700
Posté 04 mai 2012 - 03:46





Retour en haut




