133 réponses à ce sujet

[B.Shep]

I also loved the game, it is pretty good. The problem are the endings that make little sense leaving more questions than answers.

Bioware promise us the ending would close the trilogy, but this wasn't what happened.

Modifié par B.Shep, 11 mars 2012 - 05:32 .

[NoxNoctum]

Gamespot user reviews are more reliable IME.

[MerchantGOL]

the only thing DAII proved when it comes to metacritic is that it cant be tursted

get enough butthurts together and any game looks like ****

ME3 is one of the best games ever made.

[DJBare]

Blah blah blah, meta critic is a joke, it does not agree with my take on the game, blah blah blah.
Sure meta critic is unreliable, but that's not the real reason some of you attack it, if meta critic gives a glowing score then that's ok right?

[Yaroslav1992]

now all look to mass effect 1& 2 user score.
Mass Effect 3 is one of the best game that i've played, but the ending, just ruins all, if they'll fix it, the user review will be better, im sure.

Modifié par Yaroslav1992, 11 mars 2012 - 05:50 .

[MerchantGOL]

Yaroslav1992 wrote...

now all look to mass effect 1& 2 user score.
Mass Effect 3 is one of the best game that i've played, but the ending, just ruins all, if they'll fix it, the user review will be better, im sure.

your kidding write?

[GrandpaPorridge]

ME3 as a game is easily a 9.5/10, but many people are angry about the ending and EA's hawkish and unethical marketing tactics. But mostly the ending.

[aimlessgun]

The only reviews that matter are ones from people you know and trust, and that share your taste in games.

Regardless, the game is better than the rating. But this game is really, really hard to stick a number on, because of how fast it dropped off a cliff in the final minutes.

[Il Divo]

aimlessgun wrote...

The only reviews that matter are ones from people you know and trust, and that share your taste in games.

Agreed.

[william.munden]

people just hate EA with good reason and know they hate bioware because they are in bed with EA the game is all-right its just a shooter with some really nice cut scenes it not an RPG.

[LetMeW1n]

DJBare wrote...

Blah blah blah, meta critic is a joke, it does not agree with my take on the game, blah blah blah.
Sure meta critic is unreliable, but that's not the real reason some of you attack it, if meta critic gives a glowing score then that's ok right?

Lol. Day 1 DLC, leaked ending spoilers and other crap. I read those myself, maybe a little late, and couldn't cancel my pre-order. But getting over that, the bulk of game was the ME i loved. ..Maybe a little less because of the auto-dialogue, but there were pretty cool improvements in other areas, and I'm not talking about weapon modding(not again)

But the 1st couple missions were made even more unbearable by all the spoilers. If they want me getting used to the new dialogue system at least throw in some more realistic and fancier plot and environmental distractions. **** felt just a little contrived at first(demo intro and mars)

Modifié par LetMeW1n, 11 mars 2012 - 11:48 .

[LetMeW1n]

In hindsight, the auto-dialogue system isn't even that bad. You still get to pick shep's tone at every turn in a conversation, and it feels more natural. Even if there's the rare occurrence where he/she says something that you did not intend for. Immersion is great, otherwise.

[kalle90]

Mass Effect 3 is nowhere near as bad as Dragon Age 2. Mass Effect 3 is atleast quite enjoyable most of the time even though dialogue choices are cut, ending is bad etc.

Playing through Dragon age 2 was agony on the other hand. The only things it had were Varrick and the final choice with who I side on, which was actually really difficult and multiple people gave their opinions what I should do. I can't understand how anyone can give it an 8.

But you can tell that difference by actually reading the reviews. In DA2 user reviews people go to great lengths complaining about the recycled areas, dull combat of waves, disconnected story, less rpg etc. With ME3 half of the bad scores are because of "day1dlcday1dlc" or "bad ending"

[alex13abc]

I just started ME3 and am loving it so far, however a few things don't sit well with me:

- Day 1 DLC which obviously was part of the game and was removed to make more money: inacceptable. I paid 50 euros to get a complete game, I will not pay 1 cent more and all who care about not being conned out of their money by greedy developers should do the same. I bought all DLC for ME2 and would have gladly paid twice the price for lair of the shadow broker considering how good it was, however these DLC were clearly added later to give the game more depth and were not part of the game during development.

- I can't judge the ending and have not read any specifics since I don't want it spoiled but the internet is buzzing about how horrible it is. I strongly hope it's not as bad as I hear everyone say.

- Reduced dialogue options compared to the last 2 games. This is not a big problem considering how good the game and story are so far but Shepard often speaks when the player should be deciding what he says (and yes, I'm playing full decisions). Also, the summary of what he's going to say on the wheel are sometimes quite deceiving which I don't remember from the last games.

- Not a biggy but I don't like not being able to holster my weapon.

Modifié par alex13abc, 11 mars 2012 - 12:03 .

[Mhgasa]

Its an absolutely AWESOME game with an ending/epilogue that is extremely vague an unforfilling for me as a long time fan.

[Dave Exclamation Mark Yognaut]

This game is much better than Dragon Age 2. Most people dislike the ending, though.

[Foxhound2020]

MerchantGOL wrote...

the only thing DAII proved when it comes to metacritic is that it cant be tursted

get enough butthurts together and any game looks like ****

ME3 is one of the best games ever made.

I don't like how butchered the dialogue is, that gives it a large mark down in ratings from me. Plus the imports were completely broken, and the ending was nonexistant.

Those dialogue scenes are extremely important to me because that is what makes the game cinematic. For some reason, the old Mass Effect 2 team just could not do it.

All they needed to do was make the game like Mass Effect 2. They couldn't pull that off, so yes they get a low metacritic rating from me.

You can call us trolls on metacritic all you want, but it doesn't change the fact that we outnumber you. Otherwise, the positive reviews would be higher than the negative ones.

Also, just because our standard for rating a game is different than yours, does not make us trolls on metacritic. For example, I never played Halo single player. Never. I only played the mutliplayer, and I couldn't care less how the game ended, how the story was, or how the dialogue was. My standards for rating that game would be entirely different to someone who did play singleplayer. That doesn't make them a troll on metacritic or make their rating illegitimate.

Just because you don't care how low the dialogue options are and don't care how the game ended does not mean we can't rate the game. Just keep telling yourself our ratings don't matter.

Modifié par Foxhound2020, 11 mars 2012 - 12:34 .

[AkiKishi]

DanEzra633 wrote...

Professional Reviews: 92/100
User reviews: 3.2/10

I bought Dragon Age 2 based on how much I enjoyed the previous game, its DLCs, and strong reviews. After the disappointment of that game, I lost faith in 'professional' game reviews.

I'm looking forward to this game, but based on the above scores it looks like there's a real danger of repeating disappointment, inflated reviews, and cut corners. Is this the case with ME3?

Well DA2 did a lot of little things wrong that added together made it a very bad game. ME3 tends to just do a few things wrong but to a more extreme degree than DA2.

[Krogort]

I was also very disapointed by DA2, and hopefully ME3 isn't at all as bad.
Without spoiling since it's making a lot of fuss on the web, only the ending is problematic everything else is good.
Gameplay, story telling, story, basicaly everything is improved from ME2.

[Massefeckt]

GrandpaPorridge wrote...

ME3 as a game is easily a 9.5/10, but many people are angry about the ending and EA's hawkish and unethical marketing tactics. But mostly the ending.

No it is not a 9.5 to 10 game too many bugs and issues, a game scoring that highly has to be something out of this world, originality, genre breaking, technically perfect(no bugs) a huge step forward in gameing. ME3 isn't any of those.

That said it's a great game but has a lot of little issues and bugs that stop it from being anywhere near perfect, which is what you need for the kind of score you are talking about.

It cannot be compared to DA2 though, ME3 is still a ME game and very enjoyable, DA2 was a completley different game to DA:O and really should have been a spin off rather than a direct sequel.

As for metcritic? It's called a protest. The wall street protestors didn't represent everyone but they had a point to make, same with metacritic it's as much about business practices as it is the game itself.

Modifié par Massefeckt, 11 mars 2012 - 12:46 .

[Kakita Tatsumaru]

ME3 is an epic shooter with bad endings, so if you don't really care about the RPG part of the series and don't think bad endings are enough to scrap your interest for a game then this game is for you, if not then you are welcomed to the disappointed fans club.

[Arppis]

33 hours in, just recruited Quarians.

I am having fun with the game and so far it has been good if not great experience. I know a lot of people complain about endings, but I don't care as long as I can destroy the Reapers and make sure life continues in galaxy.

But as I said, I like the game. Download the demo and try it out.

[Farbautisonn]

XxTaLoNxX wrote...

LoL WUT?

Unless I played a different demo, the demo doesn't contain the content that people are pissed about.........

Bad suggestion is bad.

-Reading comprehension FTW.

The demo is crap and has plotholes up the kazoo. So does the ending. Im pissed about both. And the plethora of bugs you keep running into, minor and major, during sidequests.