133 réponses à ce sujet

[Farbautisonn]

Jedi Sentinel Arian wrote...

It deserves 4 ~ 9 based on your attitude and your focus. If you focus on Graphic and Gameplay on a game that is called RPG you can give it 9 or more, but you betray the genre in this process.
If you focus on RPG aspect of ME3 this game hardly gets a 8. plus ending, milking, inconsistency, bugs and errors it's around 7 ~ 7.5.

-This.

[kbct]

Solmanian wrote...

haven't finished the game yet, but so far its the best game I played this year, hands down.

Heh, if I had a nickel for every one of these responses...

I felt the same way.

[Mole267]

kbct wrote...

Most people liked the game. Most people didn't like the ending. You can see it in the reviews on this site and every other site.

I actually didn't even read any reviews about Mass Effect 3. I pre-ordered it based on BioWare's track record. I'm sure a lot of you guys did too. However, for the first time in ten years (or maybe even fifteen years) I will change my behavior for the next game.

By the way, what is the best site for user reviews? Because people here and on MetaCritic don't like the ending.

I rather like www.giantbomb.com I think their reviews are pretty good and honest. They gave ME3 4 stars out of 5.

The site was started by a former editor at Gamespot, who got fired after giving Kane and Lynch a mediocre review. Prior to that, Eidos had obviously given Gamespot a ****ton of money for advertising, they even had the whole website Kane and Lynch themed. They wouldn't reveal why this editor was fired, but everyone knew. Gamespot even took down his review and replaced it with a more favorable one.

[PhazeDelta1]

if i based my game purchases off of metacritic reviews, the hdd i have my games on would be empty.

[Wishpig]

rkp1 wrote...

 I gave it a ZERO on Metacritic.

Don't ship a broken game.

You shouldn't be allowed to review games if you gave ME3 a zero. If you think ME3 is a zero, you have never played a bad game. This may not be a great game. Hell, you might not even consider it a GOOD game. But to think it's lower than medicore shows a poor understanding of games in general.

It's because of people like you I now trust user scores even less than critic scores.

Modifié par Wishpig, 11 mars 2012 - 09:38 .

[Farbautisonn]

Wishpig wrote...
You shouldn't be allowed to review games if you gave ME3 a zero. If you think ME3 is a zero, you have never played a bad game. This may not be a great game. Hell, you might not even consider it a GOOD game. But to think it's lower than medicore shows a poor understanding of games in general.

It's because of people like you I now trust user scores even less than critic scores.

If his game has but a few of the problems of the kind mentioned in tech support... Why not? 

[Kakita Tatsumaru]

Well, I think all those zero comes from the tens.
Actually seeing all those ten makes me wants to give it a zero just the balance things out (but I don't in the end) considering the game is FAR (how can the series lost so many good things in one game?) from being the kind of game which will become a flagship of quality for videogames, so I understand that people with less self restrain give it zero.

[PaulSX]

do not even compare DA2 with the greatness of ME3. These two games are not in the same level.