18 réponses à ce sujet

[A Challenger]

I know there are quite a bit of threads on this already, but none of them answer specifically what needs to be done. Miranda just died in my playthrough and I am a little bit disgruntled. She was loyal, I did not romance her or anyone but Liara, I did not give her Alliance resources (Though I did not even think that mattered, as some people seem to have saved her without them too, and the conversation is virtually the same regardless of what you do), and I saw her all three times, including warning her about Kai Leng.

So what gives? Right after ramming her father out a window, she simply drops. Did Alliance resources really matter that much despite her "back up plan" with or without resources? Or does this game just coin flip her surviving.

[jtav]

Yes, it matters.

[Nero Narmeril]

Wasn't the warning in the resources?

[A Challenger]

Nero Narmeril wrote...

Wasn't the warning in the resources?

Well, the scene didn't change at all regardless of what I did. She still had her little shifty plan and what not, but if it really is the resources that make or break her survival, I guess I am going back and replaying it. I could have sworn though some people saved her with or without resources though.

[sasasasue]

Oops. I didn't know Miranda could even survive! I thought I did everything too, met up with her, gave her resources, persuaded her dad not to kill people. What went wrong? (Not that it matters in the big picture in the end anyway :|)

[jtav]

As best I can tell:

1.Miranda must be loyal
2. Accept all meeting requests
3. Give her the data
4. If romanced, do not break up with her

[SierraGHOSTN7]

What you have to do to save her? She needs to know about Kai Leng earlier. You have to warn her.
If you don't do this, she'll die.
When in the conversation with her father, I tried only 2 options, the paragon and renegade option on the left of the conversation-wheel. In both she survived.
So I dunno, maybe you should choose only between paragon/renegade - blue/red to save her.

[A Challenger]

Astaiir wrote...

What you have to do to save her? She needs to know about Kai Leng earlier. You have to warn her.
If you don't do this, she'll die.
When in the conversation with her father, I tried only 2 options, the paragon and renegade option on the left of the conversation-wheel. In both she survived.
So I dunno, maybe you should choose only between paragon/renegade - blue/red to save her.

That is what I did. I did literally everything but give her the resources, and I looked everywhere to be sure, nothing says (so far) that those are a neccesitiy to saving her. Going through an old save to find out now.

Just glad I enjoyed Thessia, otherwise this'd feel like a grind.

Modifié par A Challenger, 12 mars 2012 - 03:53 .

[jlb524]

jtav wrote...
4. If romanced, do not break up with her

Really?  That kinda sucks.

[jtav]

jlb524 wrote...

jtav wrote...
4. If romanced, do not break up with her

Really?  That kinda sucks.

I've had multiple reports of her not contacting Shep again after that. I'm not sure if it leads to the trooper or Leng death.

[jlb524]

jtav wrote...

jlb524 wrote...

jtav wrote...
4. If romanced, do not break up with her

Really?  That kinda sucks.

I've had multiple reports of her not contacting Shep again after that. I'm not sure if it leads to the trooper or Leng death.

I guess not contacting Shepard makes sense...it all just seems convenient though (for the Miranda dumping player).

[dr garlic]

 romanced her in me2
loyal in me3
dumped her in favor of ashley, but gave her the resources
she lives

i was really worried after reading this that it wouldnt work - but it did

[Rattlesnark]

dr garlic wrote...

 romanced her in me2
loyal in me3
dumped her in favor of ashley, but gave her the resources
she lives

i was really worried after reading this that it wouldnt work - but it did

At which point of the game did you break things off with her?

[Peranor]

I can't get Miranda to live. Must be because I broke up with her in ME3. Im playing with an imported character from ME1 and 2. And in ME2 i completed her loyalty mission and romanced her. In ME3 I broke up with her the first time I met her in the Citadel to continue my romance with Ash. But i did warn her about Kai Leng and I also gave her alliance support when she asked for it. But she still dies. It's not her father that shoots her. She dies from wounds inflicted before I get in to the room. So the only factor I can find is the fact that I broke up with her. Too bad the game has such ****ty endings I can't be bothered to play through it again to find out....

[The Enforcer OS]

She died in my first playthrough, but I missed the Presidium meetup.
2nd time she lived, but I didn't see anything about giving her resources...

[Guglio08]

I gave her the resources and met her twice on the Citadel but she died anyways. Very confused.

[Rattlesnark]

anorling wrote...

I can't get Miranda to live. Must be because I broke up with her in ME3. Im playing with an imported character from ME1 and 2. And in ME2 i completed her loyalty mission and romanced her. In ME3 I broke up with her the first time I met her in the Citadel to continue my romance with Ash. But i did warn her about Kai Leng and I also gave her alliance support when she asked for it. But she still dies. It's not her father that shoots her. She dies from wounds inflicted before I get in to the room. So the only factor I can find is the fact that I broke up with her. Too bad the game has such ****ty endings I can't be bothered to play through it again to find out....

Same predicament. Broke up with her at the docks as well - ended up leaving instead of telling me about her sister. This is pretty damn crappy, dying when she shouldn't have. I might overlook the ending and give this game another go, at least the rest of the game of worth going though.

Guglio08 wrote...

I gave her the resources and met her twice on the Citadel but she died anyways. Very confused.

 
Same here, did you break up with her on the first meeting (citadel docks)?

Modifié par Rattlesnark, 14 mars 2012 - 04:09 .

[j78]

After the citadel gets attacked you have warn her about kai leng in the specters office .she’ll say something about taking extra precisions or something .