271 réponses à ce sujet

[Lookout1390]

The first 98% of it was fine, there were some things that I sort of complained about...but I ignored it because I knew there was no possible way they could mess it up.

Boy, they proved me wrong.

[BrotherFluffy]

Iefho wrote...

Have a little trust in BW, for god's sake! And stop down spiralling this game into such bad reviews. Do you want to just erase that franchise from history?

This is going way too far. 95% of the game is a downright masterpiece!

I DID.  I trusted BioWare that they would produce a quality title with an ending with variety, not galactic doom in three colors.  That trust is GONE.  If they want to rebuild that trust, they need to tell us how they are going to make this right.  God, I hate saying that, but quite frankly, I don't know how  else to put it.  

[Zerohero17]

zanshin16 wrote...

Y'know, I'm pretty sure a lot of the writers, devs, and producers who have poured years and years of their lives into the ME universe feel just as crushed as we do that ME3 did not get the ending it deserved. For me personally, the logical fallacies, recycling of cutscenes, and overall abruptness of the ending aren't so much a closure issue as they simply just don't do the series justice. Lots of people, and not just the fans, invested a lot of their time, creativity, emotions, and resources to see this series through to the end, and to have it fall so flat, without a cohesive dénouement or sense of unity, is really just defeating. I don't NEED Shepard to live - I don't need a hunky-dory ending where everything is rainbows and unicorns, but what I would like to see is the trilogy go out with the bang it deserves.

Amen:ph34r: Nicely well put.

[Sorileus]

Going too far ? I think not, I think I have the right to be mad at the fact that we were ALL hyped into thinking that the last game in the trilogy was ganna be Epic which 99.9% of it was.....Till The Damn END. Then Everything we have worked on since the 1st to the last just felt like it really didn't matter at the end....there are so many different, better ways they could have ended ME3 with...

[New Generation]

I agree that ME3 was awesome until the end and that is what enrages me. The ending of ME3, the most important part of the entire trilogy, was completely botched and invalidated all of the time and emotion I invested in the series. Now knowing what the endings are I lack any motivation to play the game with "any" of my other saves as there is no point in doing so.

[kramerfan86]

Honestly while I have not personally done a bad review or anything I dont think its that uncalled for. If you were watching a film that was amazing then at the very end the main characters just took a dump on screen movie over, you wouldnt call it a good move. Journey is important, but when you are talking about a rich story experience the ending matters quite a bit too.

[Kloborgg711]

The reaction has a powerful magnitude, that's for sure. But it's not because each individual reaction is actually that strong. It's because there are so many damn reactions all over the place.

[cpolisch]

Going too far? Half their fanbase--possibly over half--is offering to give them 15 more bucks for DLC that should have been in the game in the first place.

GOD FORBID.

[BrunoBerg]

BioWare accidentally released the kraken.

[SamFlagg]

KotorEffect3 wrote...

Aedan276 wrote...

KotorEffect3 wrote...

Sentr0 wrote...

Too far? They depressed me to a point where i cant play video games anymore... so no, it just started

Geez stop being so dramatic. 

Why don't you stop provoking people? 

Bottom line is we were told we would get something we didn't receive -- an ending where the fate of characters and civilizations depended on previous decisions, in the way of Mass Effect 2. 

Nothing wrong with reacting against false advertising. 

In case you didn't pay attention the fates of the geth, quarians, and krogan civilizations were decided by the player.  Oh and Earth as well.  Not saying that the endings weren't less than satisfactory but condemning the whole game over them is just downright idiotic. 

Well if you choose synthesis then you combine all organic and synthetic creatures which goes and eliminates the geth quarian divide and overrides anything you did......or go destroy, and no matter what you did with the Geth they'll still all be killed off....or control...where the reapers still get to exist, probably to reap again.

And you blew up all the mass relays.  (doesn't matter which choice) 
(And 99% of the people you helped out on the citadel are dead too, so theres that)

[Pandora]

Iefho wrote...

Have a little trust in BW, for god's sake! And stop down spiralling this game into such bad reviews. Do you want to just erase that franchise from history?

This is going way too far. 95% of the game is a downright masterpiece!

I admit there are people that are going too far. There are dumb***** who are threatening the staff and other mods about the game on other sites. I do have a right to complain. Just like chess, you have a great beginning, middle, and bad ending blows your chances. However because of that ending you still lose.

[LordAsael]

I'll admit that things are getting out of hand. It is in part a byproduct of the emotional investment that people had in their Shepard's. That doesn't excuse some of the more irrational behavior. I suggest ignoring the irrational and encourage constructive conversation and insightful theorycrafting and alternate endings.

[Caz Neerg]

KotorEffect3 wrote...
In case you didn't pay attention the fates of the geth, quarians, and krogan civilizations were decided by the player.  Oh and Earth as well.  Not saying that the endings weren't less than satisfactory but condemning the whole game over them is just downright idiotic. 

Did you not pay any attention to the ending?  The fate of most of the quarians, if they lived in your play through, is never see their home again, because they were at Earth helping fight the reapers, and the Mass Relays are gone.  So the Rannoch mission was pointless.  The only way for Shepard to survive is to wipe out the Geth.  Earth has been pretty heavily decimated, there aren't likely to be a lot of food stores, so even if human food was digestable by every single stranded species in Sol system, there still wouldn't be nearly enough for all the people who need to be fed.  Wrex will never meet his child.  The list goes on.  It's entirely rational to think the ending ruined the series, because no matter which ending variant you pick, almost every single positive thing you accomplished, if not all of them, is destroyed.

[EmGo]

Well, it is a masterpiece. The whole ME Universe, the trilogy is a masterpiece. Yet it is incredible how the last 15 minutes of a third game could ruined that whole trilogy for me...

[stysiaq]

Farewell, Mass Effect.

Your replay value is now utterly destroyed in mere 10 minutes.

[KatieLovesBioware]

Teddie Sage wrote...

Nope. Shepard wouldn't me to give up without a fight, so that's what I'm doing. I'm fighting for justice to be done.

I agree with this ^ LET'S DO THIS FOR SHEPARD!

[Kloborgg711]

KatieLovesBioware wrote...

Teddie Sage wrote...

Nope. Shepard wouldn't me to give up without a fight, so that's what I'm doing. I'm fighting for justice to be done.

I agree with this ^ LET'S DO THIS FOR SHEPARD!

I simply refuse to believe the game is over. There was no ending. There was some strange mistake or dream Shepard encountered. I'm still waiting for my Shepard's story to conclude. This is all part of the fight.

[MakeMineMako]

Onpoint17 wrote...

Bioware could have lessened this fallout already if they would make some sort of statement. If these endings are part of some master plan, just let us know. If there isn't a plan give us an apology or an explanation of the ending. Something. As it is now, it's looking like this is going to get ugly.

This.

Their silence on the matter is causing more problems. A few vague comments from a handful of Bioware employees isn't enough.

Anyway, if they do act decisively on the matter, it will be a big surprise to me.

Modifié par MakeMineMako, 13 mars 2012 - 01:36 .

[Mev186]

I agree some of it is being taken too far. BUT Bioware isn't helping my keeping silent on the matter. Even a simple "We're listening to your complaints, We'll get back to you later"would be preferable to utter silence....Bioware needs to say something.

[Harbinger of Fun]

I tend to think that saying you don't like something because you don't like it is not 'going too far'.

[Mev186]

Harbinger of Fun wrote...

I tend to think that saying you don't like something because you don't like it is not 'going too far'.

Agreed, but there are reports of Dev's being harassed on Twiter and Facebook for this. It isn't helping....

[TheBandit554]

 SRSLY? Have you no faith? Have you now given up on five years of work only to **** on forums? NO, this is amazing what they have done, look at the community, uniting, theorizing new plots. WE ARE MASS EFFECT. Bioware will have DLC that makes this game even better and it will be from our feedback. The endings now are poetic and mysterious because they were MEANT TO BE. It's for us to think until new content arrives, we'll have closure so stop giving them ****, they are probably in hell right now with this response

[HKR148]

TheBandit554 wrote...

 SRSLY? Have you no faith? Have you now given up on five years of work only to **** on forums? NO, this is amazing what they have done, look at the community, uniting, theorizing new plots. WE ARE MASS EFFECT. Bioware will have DLC that makes this game even better and it will be from our feedback. The endings now are poetic and mysterious because they were MEANT TO BE. It's for us to think until new content arrives, we'll have closure so stop giving them ****, they are probably in hell right now with this response

...If you are trying to convince people, at least be respectful and coherent. Of course there are people on the forum who are stepping over the line, doesn't mean you should.

[crymzenassassin]

ThePrestige10 wrote...

Nothing is going too far. 99,5 % is a masterpiece until the end ruins it all and all the other games too. Bioware just failed awfully. Sry to say.

HOW in the LIVING HELL did it ruin ALL the other games? the hell is that shenanigans...im pretty sure if you go back and play mass effect 1 and 2 they will still be amazing games with amazing stories....and ME3 is still an amazing game regardless of the ending.

after reading around a little i can understand where people are coming from but to say it ruins the other games aswell is just a step too far

Mev186 wrote...

I agree some of it is being taken too far.
BUT Bioware isn't helping my keeping silent on the matter. Even a
simple "We're listening to your complaints, We'll get back to you
later"would be preferable to utter silence....Bioware needs to say
something.

the reason they are probably keeping silent is because they can not win either way....think about it..if they come out and say somthing you will get masses of the same people who are complaining about them not saying anything complaining saying somthing like " IS THAT ALL YOU CAN SAY WTF!??!?!??" 

they get complained at either way, its a lose-lose situation from BW standpoint

Modifié par crymzenassassin, 13 mars 2012 - 01:47 .

[jbajcar]

I don't think this has gone too far. Like geez, people are voicing their opinions and have every right to. Some people maybe go too far (ex. attacking specific employees, etc.) but that's rare enough.