Reptilian Rob.txmn1016 wrote...
Oh my god, I must be the only Xbox player here
Add me!
Reptilian Rob.txmn1016 wrote...
Oh my god, I must be the only Xbox player here
Rosery99 wrote...
@Tyrzun
Yes, we are private citzens. But we were acting as a single unified force, our "Movement" had taken on the same aspects of a company, we have different branches, different organizational tiers, in a sense we are moving as a single large machine, thus it makes sense that we would use the same tactics as the company we are urging to change things. But it's a moot point, many people including myself doubted the charity would ever get Bioware to change anything, in fact I didnt want it to MAKE them do anything. All the Charity was meant to do was channel our negativity into something good and help some kids. We did that. We had wanted to raise 100k, we couldn't, it sucks but oh well. Just saying lots of us donated cause it was right and had no delusions of it doing anything to Bioware. I'm pretty sure Snajones kids donation, Im pretty sure Eirilith's food budget donations didn't think they were paying for new endings. Please don't paint everyone with the same brush, if you do you're as bad as Colin at IGN.
Holding The Line,
~R
Modifié par Tyrzun, 23 mars 2012 - 11:16 .
SgtGlory wrote...
As I saw it, the charity drive's intended purpose was a positive outlet to
redirect negative feelings into positive action. Not as a flag wave
for our "motive", although that's what it wound up being construed as, and
may even have turned into.
Regardless, I'll never be sorry I gave my money to Child's Play. Ever.
Stanley Woo wrote...
So that more children could be helped, or so that more attention would be given to the Retake movement and there'd be a greater chance BioWare would listen and do something about it? If you answered the latter, then consider that you may, in fact, have been using the charity for your own cause, and as Tycho wrote, Child's Play is the cause.die-yng wrote...
I didn't want my money back. I wanted the drive to go on and not stop because of some bloody fools.
The "bloody fools" were asking questions and raising concerns that may have put the organization's mission in jeopardy, risking future donations and their ability to do what they were created to do, which is to help sick kids in the hospital feel better with videogames and toys and books and stuff. So they kindly and respectfully asked for the (unsolicited) Retake fund drive to wind down, please and thank you.
Any other "mission" or "cause" or "reason" to support the charity is yours, not theirs.
And I will ask you to keep your name-calling, insults and "sensationalist hyperbole" to yourself when you disagree with someone. Thank you.
Modifié par txmn1016, 23 mars 2012 - 11:29 .
Stanley Woo wrote...
Again, you guys done a good thing for the kids. You will always have that.
Tyrzun wrote...
Abirn wrote...
There is no such thing as selfless charity, Everybody who gives to charity does so for personal gain. It doesn't matter if its to raise awareness for a goal, tax reasons, or just to make you feel better about your self. It's still a selfish thing.
You can believe whatever you want, and believe everyone is like you but they aren't.
People often die for others.
Ask any soldier that's seen real battle. Buddies take bullets for buddies all the time. The "dying" person got nothing out of it because they died instantly.
Stanley Woo wrote...
Again, you guys done a good thing for the kids. You will always have that.
Modifié par die-yng, 23 mars 2012 - 11:44 .
DazenCobalt17 wrote...
Tyrzun wrote...
Abirn wrote...
There is no such thing as selfless charity, Everybody who gives to charity does so for personal gain. It doesn't matter if its to raise awareness for a goal, tax reasons, or just to make you feel better about your self. It's still a selfish thing.
You can believe whatever you want, and believe everyone is like you but they aren't.
People often die for others.
Ask any soldier that's seen real battle. Buddies take bullets for buddies all the time. The "dying" person got nothing out of it because they died instantly.
I kinda have to disagree with you there. In your example natually they didnt want their buddy to get hurt. They would have rather died than see that. they do get something out of it and it comes down to what they want. I guess I am sorta playing devil's advocate here but no harm intended
die-yng wrote...
I honestly don't see why I should feel the need to explain myself, because I wanted to both express my opinion and do something good while doing it.
I was happy that the movement got press, but that wasn't the intention from the start.
It is a pity that it had to end this way and that people actually requested their money back, something like that shouldn't even be possible in my opinion.
I think it is really evil, that some people try to turn this around now and change some good we wanted to do into nothing but base movements.
Yes, there is a personal stake in donating to a charity, there almost always is, even if you just do it to have a clear conscience, but if you do it with the intention of helping someone, than you still do something good.
As for donating without a connection to the movement, I stated before, that I have organizations I already donate to and I prefer to choose those myself.
And I really can't see anything wrong with that. If I had enough money to just spend a 100 Dollars more, I'd probably do it, but since money is almost always tight, I have to choose carefully.
Stanley Woo wrote...
So that more children could be helped, or so that more attention would be given to the Retake movement and there'd be a greater chance BioWare would listen and do something about it? If you answered the latter, then consider that you may, in fact, have been using the charity for your own cause, and as Tycho wrote, Child's Play is the cause.die-yng wrote...
I didn't want my money back. I wanted the drive to go on and not stop because of some bloody fools.
Xavier Hawk wrote...
I for one congratulate all who donated. I feel it was a very mature way to voice a protest whilst doing some good. Many these days rant and rave and cast insults but achieve very little. Those who donated can say whether or not they achieve the goal of getting alternate ending sthey most certainly did raise the profile of the issue and even if they loose there efforts will still have benefitted the charity. Also I'd like to say well done to organiser, you've done a good thing here and I hope it will be long remembered by one and all.
As a final word I'd also ask all sides to be careful how they treat this. Some are upset that the charirty asked for it to be stopped but honestly that's there choice and the people behind it have to ensure they do what is best for the chairty in the long term. Others seek to attach themselves to a new chairty for this cause. Honestly I wouldn't go there the point has been made doing it again would likely meet with negative reactions and finger pointing that it's just hijacking charities for our own cause. Lastly Bioware and EA should also be careful what they say and how they say it as some are getting the impression that you're upset a charity drive was done in the first place and i've even seen rumblings of conspiracy theroys that you put pressure on the charity to shut it down (extremeley unlikely though).
Stanley Woo wrote...
Again, you guys done a good thing for the kids. You will always have that.
Xavier Hawk wrote...
I for one congratulate all who donated. I feel it was a very mature way to voice a protest whilst doing some good. Many these days rant and rave and cast insults but achieve very little. Those who donated can say whether or not they achieve the goal of getting alternate ending sthey most certainly did raise the profile of the issue and even if they loose there efforts will still have benefitted the charity. Also I'd like to say well done to organiser, you've done a good thing here and I hope it will be long remembered by one and all.
As a final word I'd also ask all sides to be careful how they treat this. Some are upset that the charirty asked for it to be stopped but honestly that's there choice and the people behind it have to ensure they do what is best for the chairty in the long term. Others seek to attach themselves to a new chairty for this cause. Honestly I wouldn't go there the point has been made doing it again would likely meet with negative reactions and finger pointing that it's just hijacking charities for our own cause. Lastly Bioware and EA should also be careful what they say and how they say it as some are getting the impression that you're upset a charity drive was done in the first place and i've even seen rumblings of conspiracy theroys that you put pressure on the charity to shut it down (extremeley unlikely though).
Nightfire78 wrote...
Honestly, I have no clue what's going on here at the moment. We found ourselves feeling like crap at the end of ME3, we went to the forums and found like-minded people. We decided that we could make a positive difference given our numbers and the sheer amount of frustrated energy that was waiting to go somewhere....
And we chose to focus this energy on a charity and convert it into money for their cause.
I cannot for the life of me see how this as a bad thing.
In high school, we had a kid commit suicide and people were sad/confused/frustrated. The school started a charity drive for a leukemia charity that involved us all making some trinkets and stuff and/or donating the spare change from our lunch money in a jar in the cafeteria. The charity had nothing to do thematically with the suicide at all, but it gave us something to *do* with our confused energies, and it was very successful and yes, the school got a lot of publicity for it, so did the charity.
Am I supposed to feel guilty for having invested effort into that donation drive just because it was also about making me and everyone else feel a bit better? We donated in the name of the boy who died, I don't know if he would have been in any way interested in the charity. Perhaps we should feel bad about doing that too?
I feel like a bunch of unrelated crap is being mixed together.
Apparently there are people who want their money back. The few (and I say few because It's been maybe 3 people) I have seen say anything to this effect here have said that they want to give it to another charity instead because they are not convinced that CP has the kids best interest at heart. Ok, well, what are you gonna do? It's a free country.
This, however, has NOTHING to do with why the donation drive was started or stopped or whether or not Bioware does jack sh**.
There is nothing wrong with, nor has there ever been, somebody deciding to turn a negative into a positive by giving to those less fortunate and it boggles my mind how this thread is turning into some kind of diatribe on how our motives weren't "pure enough" or something to donate.
Quite frankly, I don't think the kids who benefit from our donations (be it to CP or to KNR or to whatever others that will be organized or suggested) give a rat's behind about how pure the motivations were of the people the money came from to make their life better. And frankly, I don't see how the motivation can be any purer than "we want to know something good has come out of this, no matter what we personally get or do not get".
If there are people who for some bizarre reason thought that they were "buying an ending" than that's too bad, but I don't see how it means the charity drive was bad or evil because some <removed the word I was going to use> people can't be bothered to read the text directly next to the "donate" button that tells you what you're doing... namely donating to a charity that helps hospitalized kids. We might as well stop all charities flat out if we have to guard the poor people who just do sh** without knowing what they're doing.
And for those making a big deal about how there was a counter for the donations and we could have all donated seperately...
1. half of us didn't even know CP existed, so they would have never ever gotten anything from us because no one can donate to something they don't know is there
2. it is a well-known, not at all mysterious, totally normal psychological phenomenon/fact that people will feel more like they make a difference if they see a big total.
None of us could have afforded donating 80k, and we all know that we donated small amounts, but 90% of people have problems seeing their donations as effective because "it's only 10 bucks, what's that gonna do?"; it's very different if you donate your 10 bucks and see that it, in combination with people you have encouraged to donate or who you hang out with etc., turns into such a huge sum. We all, theoretically, know that that would happen also without the counter, but people tend to be visual. It's different when you see it. When you see it, it's real. Why do you think telethons have that big-arse counter in your face the whole time? They know it motivates people. You tend to give more if you see a big effect, even if you know you're just a small part of it.
I'm sorry for the long post, but the turn this thread seems to be taking at the moment just baffles me.
Frankly, I think discouraging people from wanting to do good out of a bad situation and putting them down for donating to a charity in a group is almost as bad as taking your money back, though at least those people (at least all the 3 I saw) plan to re-donate, the ones putting people down for donating are actively making people not want to care or donate further.
For crying out loud people, just stop and take a breath. A charity got a lot of money, we know good has come out of this movement no matter what happens regarding the game. The confused people who didn't bother reading are, quite frankly, not our responsibility and it does no good for people to come in here and berate us for them because I can assure you that no one who is and has been in this thread was unaware of CP being a charity. The people who want to reassign their money to another charity because they no longer trust the CP organization apparently exist, but are clearly not hanging out here anymore and were very few in here to begin with, so yelling at us for something we have no control over and are not personally doing also has very little point or effect.
CP has not taken any damage form this, as a matter of fact they've gained a lot of money (even if somebody or other takes some back). I know it's generally frowned upon on internet forums to look at the good rather than the bad, but I would very much appreciate it if this thread could get back to doing just that.
The bottom line is, win or lose on the ending issue, we have made sure the CP kids win. That's important, the rest is just there for better or worse.
now back to your regularly scheduled posting.
Be positive and hold the line!