178 réponses à ce sujet

[Edrick1976]

WOW this would have been way better ending if this was true.....

[Stygian1]

GOOD GOD WHY WASN'T THIS THE ENDING WE GOT?!?!

[Exolyps]

Still pretty much the same ****. Shepard can survive and less plot holes with no star child.

But still, the frigging relays destroyed and you still get magic button to kill reapers. So no big difference.

[Echo_V]

i want to believe this is true, but i just can't :*(

wierd how so many random people can write endings which make so much more sense than the actual one...

[Icophesis]

I remember reading this on Gamefaqs shortly after I finished the game the sunday night after release. Lord knows if this is true or not, but it definitely seems fitting. More time talking to Reapers, which was always one of the more interesting conversations in previous games.

[2484Stryker]

So who else finds it hilarious that Bioware didn't simply run out of time & thus wrote a bad ending? They basically had a pretty good ending, but decided to make it bad. That's like...I don't know...failing twice as hard?

[Quietness]

Exolyps wrote...

Still pretty much the same ****. Shepard can survive and less plot holes with no star child.

But still, the frigging relays destroyed and you still get magic button to kill reapers. So no big difference.

personally i hated the starchild more than any other thing, magic button like that we can call science i guess /shrug. Honestly its better than some random stuck on text box and starchild, teleporting team-mates,normandy randomly running away, where the normandy landed.

[Iyerbeth]

I would do almost anything to get this ending in the game. It's not perfect but damn would I have finished one happy gamer.

[Duckin50s]

i'd take it

[Stygian1]

Quietness wrote...

Exolyps wrote...

Still pretty much the same ****. Shepard can survive and less plot holes with no star child.

But still, the frigging relays destroyed and you still get magic button to kill reapers. So no big difference.

personally i hated the starchild more than any other thing, magic button like that we can call science i guess /shrug. Honestly its better than some random stuck on text box and starchild, teleporting team-mates,normandy randomly running away, where the normandy landed.

Yeah way better, still  has problems, but not enough to ruin the series. 

[Galiredon]

This is very interesting. I like the sound of this so much better than the endings we got. I would have been very satisfied with these options and probably had chosen the destroy ending.

[GB-Kakuzu]

This would still just be 4 endings with little choice involved.

[Auriel]

I would have been satisfied with this ending, even if it's not entirely perfect. I really hope Bioware would do something similar.

[CHRISTsideJOKER]

omg! this would have been 100% better than what we got now, bioware please fix it

[GB-Kakuzu]

While I agree this is better than what we have, Bioware has already messed it up and fans should demand more than this.

Hold the Line.

[k8ee]

Once again I am reminded how we never got to talk to Harby. WTF BW?

[Si777]

not perfect ending but still pretty good. and it makes sence

[DocDoomII]

GB-Kakuzu wrote...

While I agree this is better than what we have, Bioware has already messed it up and fans should demand more than this.

Hold the Line.

I'm with you. But I'm cowering in fear of what they might give us.

[Emberwake]

The thing that kills me about this is that while there is absolutely no reason to believe its true, fan endings like this seem so plausible because it is diffcult to believe that just about any random fan can write a better ending than the one we got. Bioware, you should be fhrious with your writers right now.

Hold the line.

[wagsnout]

[quote]coldlogic82 wrote...

Yeah, I keep seeing this, but I don't buy it. Why on earth would they change the endings from that to what they have. Anyone who understands even only the most fundamental concepts of story and plot structure could see that was better. Anyone who understands even only the most fundamental concepts of story and plot structure can see the endings as they are equate to total trash. I can't believe ANYONE could be that stupid. At least if the endings as they are is intended, it's only one mistake. If this is true, then they made the mistake of changing the ending, the mistake of the ending itself, and the mistake of having no understanding of how fiction works.[/quote]
In a perfect world you are totally right. Yet we live in a world where Bioware gave us the currect Mass Effect 3 endings. All rules are off.

[/quote]

This might be a case of to many 90 hour weeks and to much coffee. We know that Bioware were scrambling to get the endings finished. They'd already pushed back the release date from Xmas to march. I can imagine the writing team being told that they have to shorten the ending and locking themselves away for the 10th all-nighter in a row to cut the ending down from twenty pages of dialogue to only ten. By the time they were done they may have been to exhausted and compressed to realise the damage they'd done.

[Yttrian]

Unlikely: Synthesisis the "best" ending according to the writers, undermining the entire argument.

[Iyerbeth]

Even if this isn't actually the real original ending, I can say I'm never going to get upset about a game delay again. If it takes another 6 months to not suck, do it!

[Keatstwo]

Could live with this and can't see it being too difficult to add in. Wouldn't upset people who like the current endings either as it just fleshes out what there is and removes the ridiculous parts (vent boy + gilligan's planet).

[SetUpUsTheBomb]

These sound more like the endings we were promised. Bitter Sweet, sacrifice required no matter what, but still YOU choose what is sacrificed and the ultimate outcome. Whether it's true or not, this should be the ending of Mass Effect 3 (barring a return to the Dark Energy storyline, which would be the best possible ending I think)

[Vigil_N7]

These are better than the ones we have at the moment, but not by much. I like the idea of more interaction with Harbinger, but that's pretty much the only saving grace of these endings. The reaper's motivation for survival are incredibly weak, and their motives don't make sense. Sure, the protheans became vast but the reapers have been harvesting organics for millions, if not billions of years. I'd rather the purpose of the reapers left unexplained.

I'd still choose to destroy the reapers, nothing else is satisfying in comparison.