138 réponses à ce sujet

[Nighthunteer]

Hey!

So, id like to know - everyone that refuses to belive the indoc theory,
How do you explain Shepard waking up in the concrete rubble?

Imo this is the only sure thing we have, everything else is just grasping at plausable to "prob not" straws. But this, I dont see how else it could be explained. Not even Bioware (Never thought i would say not even infront of BW, geez) would belive that he could make it to earth by falling, after being blown up

Specially after the kid told him he would die anyway!
If they wanted to make it belifeable that he surived the exoplosion, they would have shown him hovering in space, since he already walked in space between the citadel and the crucible - and instead of a breath perhaps a finger twitch.

Lets hear it!

[GnusmasTHX]

He crashed there.

He survived because Prangley erected a barrier when he was crashing to Earth.

Nice one, Prangley!

[Myrmedus]

Some people think he was beamed down after the destruction ending.

Why he'd be under rubble and on death's door compared to being able to walk (and run) I have no idea!

[Phattee Buttz]

It's just some other random person.

[v0rt3x22]

He crashed there.

He survived because Prangley erected a barrier when he was crashing to Earth.

Nice one, Prangley!

It's just some other random person.

And this is why people (like me) who support the indoc. theory - don't take people, who critize people like me for supporting the theory - serious.

They can't come up with a plausible answer.

Modifié par v0rt3x22, 14 mars 2012 - 09:59 .

[Shadewe]

Myrmedus wrote...

Some people think he was beamed down after the destruction ending.

Why he'd be under rubble and on death's door compared to being able to walk (and run) I have no idea!

Lazarrus project.

[DrowNoble]

The shephard breathing is just another of the many plot holes. Obviously he's alive but can't be on the Citadel since it just blew up. Course then, where is he? How did he get there?

That's why some are saying "it was just a dream", which would actually lead to a WORSE ending. If it was a dream, then shep didn't make it to the beam. No Crucible fired, no reapers dead, reapers win. So the Dream Theory is actually making the ending worse.

Remember people: HOLD THE LINE

[AartB]

v0rt3x22 wrote...

He crashed there.

He survived because Prangley erected a barrier when he was crashing to Earth.

Nice one, Prangley!

It's just some other random person.

And this is why people (like me) who support the indoc. theory - don't take people, who critize people like me for supporting the theory - serious.

They can't come up with a plausible answer.

especially because its clearly shepard.. nobody else has the N7 logo on its gear and/or dogtags

[ElectronicPostingInterface]

It's actually just Vega because Bioware didn't think the amount they trolled you was enough.

[111987]

To be fair, Shepard's body did survive re-entry in ME2...

[Arppis]

Hey... if Master Chief could get away with that crap... so can Sheps!

[AdverseShooter]

I just assume that Shepard never actually left earth and that the so called ending(s) is a cheap joke. At least that is what I try telling myself.

[Smiley556]

Phattee Buttz wrote...

It's just some other random person.

So why are the files for this cinematic named 'shepard_alive_male' and 'shepard_alive_female'?

[Walrusninja]

Personally I've always taken the fact that the "pefect ending" video has him waking up back in what appears to be London as pretty solid undeniable proof of some of the theories going around. No arguement can dislodge the fact that the ultimate ending has him waking up back on Earth apparently.

[Nobrandminda]

I agree with Jeremy Jahn's interpretation of it:



"In the end, Commander Shepard dies and all that bull**** happens. Right now people are typing in their keyboards going, "Actually Commander Shepard lives."

No he doesn't, he dies in every ending. By "Commander Shepard living" you mean that one scene where it pans over to someone's chest and he takes half a breath and it cuts to credits. That's not "Shepard living" that's some stupid Easter egg in which they're not committed to the fact that he died.

That's like Magneto moving that little chess piece at the end of X-men 3. Just commit. Either he lives, and he comes out and he's hugging all his friends. He's like "YEAH, WE DID IT!" Or he dies, in which case he's... well now dead. None of this half-assed take half a breath and cut to credits bull****."

Modifié par Nobrandminda, 14 mars 2012 - 10:04 .

[crimsontotem]

111987 wrote...

To be fair, Shepard's body did survive re-entry in ME2...

well other than his helmet intact... he was "meats and tubes"  also how the hell do you survive an explosion? also didn't you notice? he was DEAD during the entry. 

[Sam Anders]

111987 wrote...

To be fair, Shepard's body did survive re-entry in ME2...

But in ME3 he has no armor, the Citadel would have no atmosphere even granting that Shepard survived it exploding, and somehow he ends up in rubble back in London,  not in the Citadel (look at the textures in London compared to the end). And even then, for him to still be alive and take a breath...

I see no real explanation other than indoctrination or more space-magic.

[NoUserNameHere]

Myrmedus wrote...

Some people think he was beamed down after the destruction ending.

Why he'd be under rubble and on death's door compared to being able to walk (and run) I have no idea!

The God-Kid disapears as you fight the powah into that pylon. I'm pretty sure the Catalyst is dead once you blow it up.

With God-Kid dead, there's nobody to beam him down to Earth.

[Smiley556]

111987 wrote...

To be fair, Shepard's body did survive re-entry in ME2...

I think you and I have a very different notion of the word 'survive' then. The re-entry he experienced in ME2 (which was btw a planet more akin to our moon, without an atmosphere like earth)  didnt leave him suffeciently intact to breath unaided.

Modifié par Smiley556, 14 mars 2012 - 10:05 .

[savionen]

111987 wrote...

To be fair, Shepard's body did survive re-entry in ME2...

Yeah, but he was like... a half of a skeleton with a little bit of flesh still hanging on.

[GnusmasTHX]

v0rt3x22 wrote...

He crashed there.

He survived because Prangley erected a barrier when he was crashing to Earth.

Nice one, Prangley!

It's just some other random person.

And this is why people (like me) who support the indoc. theory - don't take people, who critize people like me for supporting the theory - serious.

They can't come up with a plausible answer.

You should feel special now.

[Fredvdp]

The Citadel, a giant mass relay, shoots Shepard to the nearst mass relay (the Conduit). Why? I guess the Catalyst was in a good mood.

The destruction of synthetic life shouldn't kill Shepard because his implants aren't sentient.

[Greed1914]

Still confused why Shepard lives in this option when the Catalyst says that the destroyed technology includes the very implants that brought him back to life. I'm not saying that the other two need to let Shepard live, I'm saying that having that result does not fit with what we were told.

[nitefyre410]

Easter Egg by the Developers to throw people a bone...

Shepard is dead ... no matter what you choose.

[z-r0]

PKchu wrote...

It's actually just Vega because Bioware didn't think the amount they trolled you was enough.

Then how do you explain that the breating body had more breast than Vega. Of course all this in case you gamed FemShep... Sorry, you were obviously trolling:whistle: