ME2 > ME3 >> ME
For me it is close between 2 and 3, but characters and places of ME2 took over.
Rate ME games from best to worst
Débuté par
mindw0rk
, mars 14 2012 10:13
Retour en haut
#2
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:14
Nykara
-
- Members
- 1 929 messages
Impossible. I love them all as I am sure I will love any Mass Effect games that follow.
#3
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:16
Jealous Beauty
-
- Members
- 344 messages
If not for the ending, ME3 would be my favorite by far.
#4
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:16
FrenziedRabbit
-
- Members
- 66 messages
ME3>ME1>ME2. But it's so close it's astounding.
Btw, 20,000th thread on the forum, grats.
Btw, 20,000th thread on the forum, grats.
#5
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:17
AlienSpaceBats
-
- Members
- 1 819 messages
From best to worst, in order of appearance I guess. Depending on how future DLC pans out, ME3 might just top ME2. I've so much nostalgia and so many memories of the first Mass Effect that not much can top that.
#6
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:17
Norskebanan
-
- Members
- 204 messages
ME > ME2 >>> ME3
I prefer story and lore over fluid gameplay and shooter-hybrid mechanics.
I prefer story and lore over fluid gameplay and shooter-hybrid mechanics.
#7
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:18
XRelakX
-
- Members
- 529 messages
If i didnt like any of those i would be paying for more would i? I think theyre all good overall.
#9
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:19
instantdeath999
-
- Members
- 264 messages
As a whole...
ME2>>>>ME3>>>>>ME
ME2 is my favorite because character development was the focus of the game. However, I am also including all of the DLC... with all of that, ME2 just feels like a complete game. I have gripes, though. No party banter or interaction among the crew, for instance, and lack of RPG elements.
What ME2 lacks, ME3 makes up for. Love how alive the ship feels. Overall, the game itself is simply unforgettable. Hopefully DLC (endingpatchendingpatchendingpatch) will really flesh it out.
ME is a fantastic game, and probably the most "complete" of the series. I don't like the story or voice acting as much, but it is still a great experience. ME has the "biggest" story, mainly because it's the introduction, but I don' think the dialogue is as tightly written as the sequels.
ME2>>>>ME3>>>>>ME
ME2 is my favorite because character development was the focus of the game. However, I am also including all of the DLC... with all of that, ME2 just feels like a complete game. I have gripes, though. No party banter or interaction among the crew, for instance, and lack of RPG elements.
What ME2 lacks, ME3 makes up for. Love how alive the ship feels. Overall, the game itself is simply unforgettable. Hopefully DLC (endingpatchendingpatchendingpatch) will really flesh it out.
ME is a fantastic game, and probably the most "complete" of the series. I don't like the story or voice acting as much, but it is still a great experience. ME has the "biggest" story, mainly because it's the introduction, but I don' think the dialogue is as tightly written as the sequels.
Modifié par instantdeath999, 14 mars 2012 - 10:20 .
#11
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:20
Arppis
-
- Members
- 12 750 messages
I actualy like ME3 the most. Even with the ending. But I'd still say they are all equaly good, each with it's flaws and pros.
#12
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:21
ATWFA
-
- Members
- 95 messages
Mass Effect 2
Over.
Mass Effect 1.
Over.
Mass Effect 3.
The ending ruined almost the whole story for me, couple that with a disappointing photoshop of my beloved Tali's face, and ME3 deserves to be last on this list IMO
Over.
Mass Effect 1.
Over.
Mass Effect 3.
The ending ruined almost the whole story for me, couple that with a disappointing photoshop of my beloved Tali's face, and ME3 deserves to be last on this list IMO
#13
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:22
AgitatedLemon
-
- Members
- 6 294 messages
ME2 at #1.
ME1 at #2.
ME3 at #3.
I can safely say that ME3 is the only game I've ever played to be ruined by a 45 second cutscene, with the ending choice. The first 95% of the game was good though.
ME1 at #2.
ME3 at #3.
I can safely say that ME3 is the only game I've ever played to be ruined by a 45 second cutscene, with the ending choice. The first 95% of the game was good though.
#14
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:22
VinWizzy
-
- Members
- 359 messages
Even if the ending was better:
ME > ME3 > ME2
Even though ME had a lot of frustrating moments, the nostalgia got to me. Besides the story was great.
ME > ME3 > ME2
Even though ME had a lot of frustrating moments, the nostalgia got to me. Besides the story was great.
Modifié par VinWizzy, 14 mars 2012 - 10:24 .
#15
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:22
loungeshep
-
- Members
- 1 864 messages
over all ME 3>ME 2>ME 1
Storywise, 3>1>2
Graphics and game play 3>2>1
VA'ing tie.
Storywise, 3>1>2
Graphics and game play 3>2>1
VA'ing tie.
#16
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:22
E-Type XR
-
- Members
- 414 messages
ME3 (99% of the game) > ME2 > ME > Being Killed >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ME3 ending
(slight hyperbole, but not much)
(slight hyperbole, but not much)
#17
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:22
OneMore1968
-
- Members
- 793 messages
Wow its a toughie they all stand out in their own way.
1. ME3 - played it on normal first but next time want to try narrative mode
2. ME1 - had strong narrative fole and less combat (I enjoyed building relationships)
3. ME2 - Mepersonally, I enjoyed it but felt that they missed opertunities in several places to develop the character a lot further
1. ME3 - played it on normal first but next time want to try narrative mode
2. ME1 - had strong narrative fole and less combat (I enjoyed building relationships)
3. ME2 - Mepersonally, I enjoyed it but felt that they missed opertunities in several places to develop the character a lot further
#18
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:23
sylinmino
-
- Members
- 8 messages
ME2>ME
I found everything just made a ton better in ME2 from ME, though I love both so much.
I'm not putting ME3 on this list until I know if the ending will change. So far, that game is the best of both of them except for the ending. The ending, which screws everything over, cannot be forgiven until it is completely changed.
I found everything just made a ton better in ME2 from ME, though I love both so much.
I'm not putting ME3 on this list until I know if the ending will change. So far, that game is the best of both of them except for the ending. The ending, which screws everything over, cannot be forgiven until it is completely changed.
#19
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:24
OneMore1968
-
- Members
- 793 messages
Wow its a toughie they all stand out in their own way.
1. ME3 - played it on normal first but next time want to try narrative mode
2. ME1 - had strong narrative fole and less combat (I enjoyed building relationships)
3. ME2 - Mepersonally, I enjoyed it but felt that they missed opertunities in several places to develop the character a lot further
1. ME3 - played it on normal first but next time want to try narrative mode
2. ME1 - had strong narrative fole and less combat (I enjoyed building relationships)
3. ME2 - Mepersonally, I enjoyed it but felt that they missed opertunities in several places to develop the character a lot further
#21
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:29
BradPoker
-
- Members
- 6 messages
1. ME 2
2. ME 1
3. ME 3 - Simply becasue everything the first two and a half games created was crushed and set on fire by this remarkably stupid ending.
2. ME 1
3. ME 3 - Simply becasue everything the first two and a half games created was crushed and set on fire by this remarkably stupid ending.
#22
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:30
Kanon777
-
- Members
- 1 625 messages
Gameplay ME3>ME2>ME1
Story ME3>ME1>ME2
Story ME3>ME1>ME2
#23
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:32
Arl Raylen
-
- Members
- 535 messages
1. ME2
2. ME3
3. ME
The combat in ME2 was so much better than it was in 1, and the character stories were done so well. ME3 would be number 1 if I wasn't so depressed about the ending. ME had a great main story and awesome party members but the secondary quests, combat, and planet exploration killed it for me in comparison to the other two.
2. ME3
3. ME
The combat in ME2 was so much better than it was in 1, and the character stories were done so well. ME3 would be number 1 if I wasn't so depressed about the ending. ME had a great main story and awesome party members but the secondary quests, combat, and planet exploration killed it for me in comparison to the other two.
#24
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:33
Aaleel
-
- Members
- 4 427 messages
ME - Liked the characters the most, Saren probably the best written character in series. Liked the squad, liked the story, Virmire my favorite mission out of all the game.
ME3 - Old gang back together almost, just needed Wrex. Some of the missions were very well done. Even if the ending wasn't terrible, it would still be second.
ME2 - Least favorite group of squadmates. The story got lost, and was poorly paced. The collectors and Harbinger very underdeveloped. I play for story, and it had the worst story development by far.
ME3 - Old gang back together almost, just needed Wrex. Some of the missions were very well done. Even if the ending wasn't terrible, it would still be second.
ME2 - Least favorite group of squadmates. The story got lost, and was poorly paced. The collectors and Harbinger very underdeveloped. I play for story, and it had the worst story development by far.
#25
Posté 14 mars 2012 - 10:34
AveryChim
-
- Members
- 297 messages
ME2 > ME1 > ME3
ME2 was just.... a wonderful wonderful game. The loyalty missions were some of the best story telling quests around. Romances were great and the suicide mission always feels gripping no matter how how many times I've played it. Some of my favorite characters and moments come from ME2.
ME1 is the most open game, which is something it's sequels lack. Very beefy amount of character dialgue and exposition on the universe. Mako sections were fun! Planet exploration was fun! Tons of customisation for both weapons and skills. Still, I found it wasn't as polished as its successors. Gameplay felt weird and there were alot of bugs.
ME3 is a great game, but overall fails to capture the magic of ME2. Combat arguably is the best in the series and Multiplayer is a blast! There are also some really awesome moments in the game on Tuchanka (Mordin and Lt Victus) and Rannoch. The characters are unfortunately not as engaging as they were in ME2 and, of course, the endings... sigh...
ME2 was just.... a wonderful wonderful game. The loyalty missions were some of the best story telling quests around. Romances were great and the suicide mission always feels gripping no matter how how many times I've played it. Some of my favorite characters and moments come from ME2.
ME1 is the most open game, which is something it's sequels lack. Very beefy amount of character dialgue and exposition on the universe. Mako sections were fun! Planet exploration was fun! Tons of customisation for both weapons and skills. Still, I found it wasn't as polished as its successors. Gameplay felt weird and there were alot of bugs.
ME3 is a great game, but overall fails to capture the magic of ME2. Combat arguably is the best in the series and Multiplayer is a blast! There are also some really awesome moments in the game on Tuchanka (Mordin and Lt Victus) and Rannoch. The characters are unfortunately not as engaging as they were in ME2 and, of course, the endings... sigh...
Modifié par AveryChim, 14 mars 2012 - 10:42 .
