Aller au contenu

Photo

Checkmate: Why Your Opinion Simply Doesn't Matter


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
385 réponses à ce sujet

#1
MintyCool

MintyCool
  • Members
  • 451 messages
Checkmate: Why in the End Your Opinion Simply Doesn't Matter

Your decisions are tainted by the emotional investments you accumulate, and the more you invest in something the harder it becomes to abandon it.

The Pleasures of Not Knowing:

If you were a consistent member on the Mass Effect forums between the 1st and 2nd, or 2nd and 3rd installments, you would be known as a Knowingness Addict.

You are desperate to consume anything relating to this saga. Whether it be books, comics, etc. When a leak occured or a screenshot was released you would swarm like a pack of cockroaches to analyze it.

During this time you would receive opinions, rants, and raves from others. When hundreds of strangers enter our thoughts, a tiny part of our own self assessment is diminished. You are denying yourself the pleasure of the discovery.

After ME3 was released, what did you do once you finished the tale? More than likely, you went back and either watched the alternative endings on YouTube or replayed alternate paths yourself. Again, fueled only by needing to know everything, desperate to know all other choices one could make.

You ended up learning everything about the man behind the curtain, did you feel better? No, it only fueled your impulses for a more potent fix.

You bend unknowingly to your impulses. You replace others experiences with your own. Under the right conditions, you are prone to losing your individuality by becoming absorbed into a mob mentality. You became part of the Mass Effect Hivemind.

Why In The End Your Opinion Doesn't Matter:

In the end, Bioware views you as a guaranteed asset.

View it in the same light as a diehard sports fan that is upset with his popular team; in protest, he decides to not attend any more games. Does ownership care? No. Why? It's because someone else will fill that void with-in seconds, enjoying the game instead of you. Overtime, your willpower will shatter and you'll end up becoming a fan again the next chance you get.

Bioware is the RPG equivalent to a popular sports team like the Chicago Bulls. When it comes down to it, and everyone is buying the new Bioware AAA blockbuster; your impulses will give way and your brain will be firing synapses at a constant pace... desperate for that fix.

You will dance with the devil, and Bioware knows it.

You may have noticed the outcry about the ending is already dissipating, why?

It takes work to be angry; you're intellectually incapable of focusing for a long enough period of time to actually cause change. Most of you are incapable of even reading to this point of the article. The majority of these people are peers/allies who have joined your cause.

At the moment, the public views you as the political equivalent to the Occupy Wall street crowd. You are a joke. You come up with ridiculous theories that only spook conspirators' would believe; you introduce props and cheap gags like charities that only smudge up your message. You are simply noise.

In the end all of this is great news because; the last 15 minutes of this tale are actually quite good...

Why The Ending Works:

1. Shepard, war torn and exhausted, leaped into the crucibles energy source sacrificing his life to intertwine existences between synthetics and organics.

A few hours ago, this is how my tale ended after five years of Mass Effect; and I was quite satisfied with the ending.

2. The writing team behind Mass Effect 3 was able to elevate the narrative premise by weaving a philosophical debate about the relationship between organic and synthetic coexistence. The entire story throughout the third
addition is laced with the ideas of life, harmony, and self preservation.

More than ever, the story has morphed into a game about big themes and big ideas.

Just some of the thoughts explored throughout this game...

EDI and free will, Synthetic dominance, Lineage, Genophage, Causality, Geth/quarian conflict, Determinism, Legacy - Miranda's father, Synchronicity and Kaiden, False Theology-Asari Prothean Gods, personal fulfillment, etc.

Compared to the previous installments that may have skimmed over some of these topics, all the philosophical and sociological debates/conflicts in this iteration have the main goal of bolstering the main theme of Mass Effect 3,

The existence of The Creators vs. The Created.

3. Two camps are formed because of this instance. The story the writers wish to tell, and the fans who feel entitled to observe the story they themselves envisioned.

The writers, it seems, realized the message that they wanted people to take from this third installment. This had the team shifting the narrative focus to a more elevated dynamic.

The coexistence of Synthetics vs. Organics.

4. To this end, Mass Effect 3 succeeds in weaving a narrative from beginning to end. To say otherwise is disingenuous.

Philosophical themes trounce the Neanderthal-dopamine induced urges people wish to see in this addition. Especially in the end game where this theme becomes the stories main focal point.

Honestly is a cameo appearance from Wrex for the 50th time really going to add anything to the finality of this story? No.

5. Unfortunately I find a Star Wars Syndrome happening with this series. A fan base digesting every bit of corn fructose they can gulp down. Needing everything to be spelled out; desperate to know every last bit of information.

Why must one need to see Tali's face? Why do we need to know a detailed history of the Protheans? How come we need to see the Rachni and Krogan attack the enemy? Isn't the struggle of loss and war already inferred multiple times throughout the story? The focus of the end game is obviously being developed on a much deeper/different theme.

Midichlorians anyone? You do not need to know how exactly the force works...

This desperate need to dig up plot holes and inconsistencies from the hard core is entirely unhealthy for the series and its fans. All stories have inconsistencies, stories you tell to your friends are punched up exaggerations of what really happened. Your Facebook account is not a mirror image of the life you lead, but the life you wish you lived.

You had the chance to say goodbye to the entire main cast in one way or another. Multiple times is it mentioned/inferred that all races are about to battle the Reapers.

Needing to know a detailed resolution of what happens to everyone in the galaxy only dilutes the escapist reality the writers created.

Some things are better left to the imagination. Less is more and allowing the mind to explore possibilities is one of the great strengths of human thought.

6. In the end, it would seem the Bioware writing team effectively succeeded in what they wanted to say in the Mass Effect saga. This is something I can respect. Instead of appeasing to the vocal mob; they finished the story on their own terms.

Mass Effect became a tale about cultural synthesis. The Mass Effect team was finally able to find this series a voice. Knowing this, makes me content that I have finished this series in its entirety in the way it was meant to be seen.

And I enjoyed every minute of it.

Modifié par MintyCool, 15 mars 2012 - 04:32 .


#2
ElectronicPostingInterface

ElectronicPostingInterface
  • Members
  • 3 789 messages
It's cute you think you're the arbiter of all things with your condescending little "checkmate" title.

"In the end, Bioware views you as a guaranteed asset."

What a horribly flawed assumption on their part.

My opinion may not change anything, but collectively tarnishing your brand can change a lot about your future beyond this failure.

Modifié par PKchu, 15 mars 2012 - 01:14 .


#3
FabricatedWookie

FabricatedWookie
  • Members
  • 503 messages
Don't care

#4
GBGriffin

GBGriffin
  • Members
  • 2 259 messages
I'm sorry that you wasted your time in typing out a lengthy post, only for it to be skimmed and undoubtedly buried beneath other topics. ;_;

#5
nitefyre410

nitefyre410
  • Members
  • 8 944 messages
Funny you using Checkmate
...when this is not even Chess ... its Igo.

nice try.

#6
the red boon

the red boon
  • Members
  • 465 messages
Yes I'm glad you believe corporations are flawless entities, good for you.
On a side note, I'm gonna laugh when there is change in our favor.

#7
Silent Rage

Silent Rage
  • Members
  • 502 messages
So. What color did you pick?

#8
MintyCool

MintyCool
  • Members
  • 451 messages

GBGriffin wrote...

I'm sorry that you wasted your time in typing out a lengthy post, only for it to be skimmed and undoubtedly buried beneath other topics. ;_;


The Misconception: When your beliefs are challenged with facts, you alter your opinions and incorporate the new information into your thinking.

The Truth: When your deepest convictions are challenged by contradictory evidence, your beliefs get stronger.

- David McRaney

---

Winning.

Modifié par MintyCool, 15 mars 2012 - 01:21 .


#9
AlterEgo3561

AlterEgo3561
  • Members
  • 44 messages
I wanted to read but was crushed beneath the wall...

#10
demin8891

demin8891
  • Members
  • 293 messages
So, in other words, what you're saying is this Image IPB

#11
GorrilaKing

GorrilaKing
  • Members
  • 250 messages
Still holding the line. I'm too old to still become upset because of people deriding my opinion.
*yawn*

#12
WhiteVV1ings

WhiteVV1ings
  • Members
  • 464 messages
No human being is flawless, so the idea you think companies are without fault is illogical.

#13
Der Estr Bune

Der Estr Bune
  • Members
  • 323 messages
"Needing to know a detailed resolution of what happens to everyone in the galaxy only dilutes the escapist reality the writers created.

Some things are better left to the imagination. Less is more and allowing the mind to explore possibilities is one of the great strengths of human thought."

I'm not going to try responding to this whole thing, but I will look at this part. I agree, if they wanted to stay ambiguous, I'd probably be more okay with it (only a little, though). If it had cut to black, and just given me a shot of the Normandy to tell me they're still alive, I could deal with it. But putting in a scene that shows everyone acting out-of-character, and dropping them off on an unknown planet with no conceivable way off? That's not "left to the imagination", it's just poorly written. The only thing it leaves to the imagination is, "Who thought this was a good idea"?

#14
Vasparian

Vasparian
  • Members
  • 396 messages
All I saw was blah blah I am pretentious and condescending.

#15
Ryven

Ryven
  • Members
  • 410 messages
You said checkmate. So. You win?

#16
Nekroso22

Nekroso22
  • Members
  • 68 messages

1. Shepard, war torn and exhausted, leaped into the crucibles energy source sacrificing his life to intertwine existences between synthetics and organics.

A few hours ago, this is how my tale ended after five years of Mass Effect; and I was quite satisfied with the ending.


How very nice for you. Shame you weren't the only person playing the game.

2. The writing team behind Mass Effect 3 was able to elevate the narrative premise by weaving a philosophical debate about the relationship between organic and synthetic coexistence. The entire story throughout the third addition is laced with the ideas of life, harmony, and self preservation.

More than ever, the story has morphed into a game about big themes and big ideas.


The story was morhped into a hamfisted, pseudo-philosophical art movie in the last ten minutes of the game. To say that the whole series was entirely about "organics vs. synthetics" is to ignore basically every major plot point in every one of the games.

3. Two camps are formed because of this instance. The story the writers wish to tell, and the fans who feel entitled to observe the story they themselves envisioned.

The writers, it seems, realized the message that they wanted people to take from this third installment. This had the team shifting the narrative focus to a more elevated dynamic.

The coexistence of Synthetics vs. Organics.


Again, this was never really a big theme in the Mass Effect games. Also, nice use of "entitled." It lets me know that you haven't been around here long enough to know that argument is bogus.

4. To this end, Mass Effect 3 succeeds in weaving a narrative from beginning to end. To say otherwise is disingenuous.

Philosophical themes trounce the Neanderthal-dopamine induced urges people wish to see in this addition. Especially in the end game where this theme becomes the stories main focal point.


I'm not one for ad-hominem attacks, but that just made me laugh. Again, you've obviously not familiarized yourself with the arguments presented by the community. Mass Effect succeeds in weaving a narrative from beginning to about five minutes before the end. If you want to call pointing out obvious plot holes "disengenuous," by all means continue embarassing yourself.

5. Unfortunately I find a Star Wars Syndrome happening with this series. A fan base digesting every bit of corn fructose they can gulp down. Needing everything to be spelled out; desperate to know every last bit of information.

Midichlorians anyone? You do not need to know how exactly the force works...


...You think Star Wars fans liked midichlorians? I honestly don't know how to respond to that.

This desperate need to dig up plot holes and inconsistencies from the hard core is entirely unhealthy for the series and its fans. All stories have inconsistencies, stories you tell to your friends are punched up exaggerations of what really happened. Your Facebook account is not a mirror image of the life you lead, but the life you wish you lived.


And now you're comparing Mass Effect 3 to a Facebook account? It's not like the plot holes in the ending are difficult to pick out.

#17
ket_shee

ket_shee
  • Members
  • 283 messages
Cool story, bro.

I'm not sure if you've even read other peoples opinions, yet alone consider them, but you are far off on my stance at least. Glad the ending works for you, a lot of people have disagreed though. Argue subjectivity until the end of time if that is what you wish. That's not my issue with Mass Effect 3.

But hey, thanks for refueling my rage, it's people like you that make Holding the Line so much fun.

#18
Paparob

Paparob
  • Members
  • 498 messages
Cool story bro.

#19
Eyeshield21

Eyeshield21
  • Members
  • 892 messages
 Image IPB
pretty much sums up the end.
Your point is invalid(somebody probably put this up, but whatever)

Modifié par Eyeshield21, 15 mars 2012 - 01:23 .


#20
lasertank

lasertank
  • Members
  • 630 messages
As a matter of fact, Sir Conan actually revived Shelock Holmes due to the reaction of its fanbase. If you create some characters, which appealed a lot of supporters, then they are no longer writer's possessions.

#21
kunzite

kunzite
  • Members
  • 205 messages
Despite your arguments, I did manage to read the whole article. And while I respect that you might feel this way, I disagree with the assumptions.

Bioware might view us as a guaranteed asset. They would be wrong. There is nothing guaranteeing my continued patronage, and most importantly, my financial support of their products, except for something called Brand Loyalty.

Bioware had a reputation of making high quality, if not the highest quality, games available. But if they believe that making products on their own terms is more important than making games their customers would enjoy and wish to purchase and support, then this 'guaranteed asset' will be guaranteed to be an asset to some other company that makes products I enjoy. And yes, this is a generalization, but the premise is the point.

#22
deathscythe517

deathscythe517
  • Members
  • 539 messages
You know why we don't take people from your side seriously? It's a little thing called a superiority complex, you think that by making yet another topic you'll somehow bring about some kind of startling revelation when you're just beating a dead horse. Topics not related to the ending get answered quickly, topics involving decrying the horribleness of the ending manage to carry on, but all these 'fact: your movement is stupid' topics get buried into oblivion...

I WONDER WHY?

Maybe if you show the same amount of respect for us as we have shown everyone else instead of pretending to be some kind of higher intelligence when you're really just cheerleading for Bioware, and that's what it comes down to isn't it? You're trying to put down angry customers into just shutting up, why spend money on a PR department when you've got people who'll defend you no matter how nonexistent or paper thin the reasons, they're giving you money and you can treat them as a deniable asset - they aren't speaking for the company but hey you can look the other way for them at least.

Condense your counter-points into a megathread like we have instead of trying to stand out and be the 'voice of reason'. When you're just being cynical, contrary, and overall not half as original as you think you are.

#23
Lmaoboat

Lmaoboat
  • Members
  • 1 021 messages
Funny you should mention the Star Wars Prequels since the ending is pretty much having Jar Jar show up during the climax of Return of the Jedi.

#24
Dark Penitant

Dark Penitant
  • Members
  • 205 messages
I stopped listening the instant you compared us to Occupy, and tried to portray that in a negative light. Nice try, though.

#25
SLPr0

SLPr0
  • Members
  • 1 396 messages
I am not a guaranteed asset. I will not be buying anything further from this company.

So you can take your entire argument, smash it up into a little ball and stick it where the sun doesn't shine.

Maybe BioWare has enough "guaranteed assets" not to care about the loss of my patronage. But yanno, I'm not the one that has to care about that. I just move on with my life and find games that don't build me up simply to confuse and enrage me.

BioWare does have competition. I will be choosing the competition from here on out.