On Exploding Relays.
OKies guys, people keep going "this is Not Arrival... it wasn't hit by an asteroid, it got hit by a signal beam, so its explosion is not the same!
No it is not.
Lets all just agree that we ALL do see the Relays explode.
Whatch the video again :
youtu.be/liQV1N7jXisCitadel fires signal, signal hits relay, relays charges to critial sends signal along then BLOWS up.
Note that Relays are superstructres that can withstand a Super Nova without taking any damage at all.
Refer to your Codex ; Secondary : Ilos : Mu Relay
All a Super Nova did to it while vaporising the system it was in and creating the nebular that hides the Mu Relay was to push the Relay out of position while not doing a single dent to it. (You guys USED it for crying out loud)
So to recap, the Relays in ME3 was NOT hit by a big planetoid (this makes it easier to destroy a Relay presumeably since now we have a huge butt load of mass and momentum of said mass added into the equation ... but we are talking about ME3) which means the RELAYS exploded from kinetic / momentum force or energy alone which means that force had to had more velocity and momentum to damage a structure then if it was mass AND veloctiy.
If you want to do the math, here's a link
http://www.stardestr...Explosives.html In short and in lay man's terms, a Relay can take a shockwave hit of Super Nova scale and not be structurely damaged.
Relays are tough SOBs.
A structural explosion happens when enough kinetic / momentum force is applied to compromise said structure.
Big or Small Kaboooms, kabooms must be powerful enough to rip things to shreds.
Aka, A soda can will explode if you apply xxx ammount of pressure. Does not matter if you want a big or small explosion you need xxx ammount of pressure to make a soda can explode.
Thus that EXPLODING relay you saw = ONE BIG ASS KABOOM!
Logic would dictate that if structure is not damaged by Super Nova Scale energy, energy needed to not just bend but blow apart said structure = many orders of magnitude.
REALLY REALLY big AND powerful KABOOM!
Now to understand just how powerful a Super Nova is
http://www.nature.co...s/263398a0.html Essentitally a Super Nova as close to as 20-25 light years could take out half of Earth's ozone layer.
Closer then 10 light years a good portion of Earth's atmosphere is lost
Closer then 5 light years ....
The Charon Mass relay is 4 light hours away.
Needless to say ANY system with an Exploding Mass Relay = Toast.
Any cluster with a Mass Relay = fracked up
Basically that ending we saw was producers who just wanted big fracking explosions.
Never mind the science behind it.
Ignoring their own "Issac Newton is the deadliest SOB in space" line (physics DO matter in Mass Effect)
Threw logic and common sense out the window just to have a "cool looking cut scene"
I call BS on this too.
Bioware. Redo your SCIENCE Fiction (so ya, its fiction, you have leeway to do stuff ...just not go into space fantasy) master piece and redo that craptastic ending.
Modifié par Archonsg, 18 mars 2012 - 08:42 .