238 réponses à ce sujet

[Captain Arty]

All of the other failures I can think of were failures of story, not of theme and story.

A.I. was pretty bad, but still kept to the theme, I thought, even if it was totally unrelated to the story.
Contact (the movie) didn't do the book justice, but again kept to the theme.

If Saving Private Ryan had ended the way Inglorious Bas*ards did, that might be on the same scale of the fail that was ME3.

[Gill Kaiser]

Star Wars Episode III doesn't count, because the prequels were all terrible from the very beginning. Firefly doesn't count, because that didn't have an ending, as it was cancelled mid-season.

I legitimately can't think of anything I've personally experienced that's ended worse in comparison to its general quality. Things like the Matrix Trilogy were slipping in quality all the way to the end, so you kind of saw the bad ending coming. The Mass Effect 3 ending was like a kick in the quad.

Modifié par Gill Kaiser, 26 mars 2012 - 08:49 .

[Wolven_Soul]

masseffect5 wrote...

ppeople saying this has never happened and this is the worse ending ever have no buisness playing the game because they dont ****ing know what they[ are talking about it wasnt the best ending but shepard still killed the reapers and saved the galaxy again i mean come on dosent that mean anything or do all of you perverted little babies out their sad that you lost a person from a video game that you ja** of* to i mean really i hate reading people saying bioware sucks because of this. i was really happy watching every reaper get taken away and destroyed and if you didnt love it you arent a mass effeect fan and you have no buisness playing the game

I am going to try to answer your childish and incoherent rant as best I can. 

So because we are passionate enough about this game serious to come here and talk about why we did not like the ending, and usually in a much more adult manner than what you just did, we are not fans of the game?  In fact, I would say that we are some of the most ardent and passionate fans of the Mass Effect serious because we come here and voice our discontent.  If we were not fans and did not care, we simply would not bother. 

[Wolven_Soul]

Renoscott wrote...

how about a ending to this stupid threds?

No one is forcing you to read it.

[Captain Arty]

Gill Kaiser wrote...

Star Wars Episode III doesn't count, because the prequels were all terrible from the very beginning. Firefly doesn't count, because that didn't have an ending, as it was cancelled mid-season.

I legitimately can't think of anything I've personally experienced that's ended worse in comparison to its general quality. Things like the Matrix Trilogy were slipping in quality all the way to the end, so you kind of saw the bad ending coming. The Mass Effect 3 ending was like a kick in the quad.

I'd say a kick in the nads. From behind. Without warning. By a person wearing a pointy shoe.

[the_secondhammer]

Phaedros wrote...

Nothing. Has. Ever. Come. Close.

[VendettaI154]

Guys, come on. Battlestar did not end as badly as ME3, that's just insulting.

[Renoscott]

poundoffleshaa wrote...

Renoscott wrote...

how about a ending to this stupid threds?

I have always thought the ending of a pair of shoes had real soul. 

....what?

[masseffectfan94]

Caesar2001 wrote...

Neverwinter Nights 2, before DLC. Rocks fall, everybody dies.
Fallout 3, before DLC. Radiation, you die.

I'm just sayin'...

I see what you did there.

[Starschwar]

On the subject of Battlestar, how about the *original* BSG continuity? Or rather, the end of Galactica 1980. That had obnoxious space children, a major character stranded on an unknown world, and a generally poor outlook for the future. Hmm...

[Captain Arty]

masseffectfan94 wrote...

Caesar2001 wrote...

Neverwinter Nights 2, before DLC. Rocks fall, everybody dies.
Fallout 3, before DLC. Radiation, you die.

I'm just sayin'...

I see what you did there.

Subtly. I like it.

[vlherg]

The Hindenburg crashed and burned just a little worse than the ME3 ending.

What? Too soon?

A lot of the stuff being suggested wasn't as bad as ME3.
Shows like Firefly & Sarah Connor Chronicles I will excuse as they got axed so didn't have the chance to wrap up properly.
Fallout 3 (pre BS), KOTOR 2, Neverwinter 2, all provided us with some sort of epilogues to other characters and the world.
Lost and BSG provided some degree of closure for characters
Enterprise was pretty bad , also killed off a much loved character for no good reason but although the presentation of the episode was awful (The holodeck nonsense), it did at least lead to a coherent end with the birth of the Federation.

Mass Effect 3 we got nothing A nonsense ending that created massive plotholes, bore no relation to the rest of the series and no closure. That's before we even get into the broken promises.

Modifié par vlherg, 26 mars 2012 - 09:15 .

[Sinnick03]

Veramocor wrote...

Ultima IX. Origin was bought by EA and they had to rush it through horrible ending. Avatar ends up 'ascending' into a beam of light and a wave of blue energy goes across the land to stop the Guardian destroying Britannia and its inhabitants.

So basically EA indoctrinates good RPG publishers and makes them ship out junk.

Ending:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sZt_UTfVSak
Wave of energy:

Well that ending sounds horrifyingly familiar.

[gmboy902]

Badly from a fair standpoint, Mafia II had a poor ending. The story was good, but you weren't really involved so much as a bystander.

With Mass Effect 3 you have higher expectations, just like how I had higher expectations for Dragon Age 2. Dragon Age 2 was a solid game with solid mechanics, addicting enough gameplay, and a story with some thought in it. But it didn't stand up to Origins. And Mass Effect 3's ending, even if decent by other games' standards, completely destroyed the story of Mass Effect.

Judging purely on the endings, there are others, but judging based on how the endings match up to and affect the overall story, I can't think of any.

[Grumpy-Mcfart]

most of the examples on this page

Modifié par Grumpy-Mcfart, 26 mars 2012 - 09:08 .

[sydranark]

1) Chuck
2) Lost
3) Army of Two: The 40th Day

[UKJackMan]

Enterprise they let Trip and Tpols baby die then killed Trip then binned the series.

[Cyph3rX]

Renoscott wrote...

poundoffleshaa wrote...

Renoscott wrote...

how about a ending to this stupid threds?

I have always thought the ending of a pair of shoes had real soul. 

....what?

Whoosh.

[Renoscott]

Cyph3rX wrote...

Renoscott wrote...

poundoffleshaa wrote...

Renoscott wrote...

how about a ending to this stupid threds?

I have always thought the ending of a pair of shoes had real soul. 

....what?

Whoosh.

I got his implcation it just....Im the one being steped on? rather then a group of people who from day 1 who wanted to burn Biowares office down?

[Renoscott]

sydranark wrote...

1) Chuck
2) Lost
3) Army of Two: The 40th Day

Why did you remind me of Army of two....THAT hole game was depressing.

[Bomma72]

Ultramonkey88 wrote...

The Godfather

Difference is that Godfather 3 was crap from begining to end.  Except for Zah-Zah.  I liked that part.  

[PandaThing]

At least Battlestar Galactica explained its stupid ending somewhat, and had decent foreshadowing.

When Babylon Five thought it was over (end of season four) they aired a really horrible episode called 'The Deconstruction of Falling Stars'. It had similar 'everything we accomplished was futile' vibe to it.

Thank god they got another season.

[Flextt]

Captain Arty wrote...

masseffectfan94 wrote...

Caesar2001 wrote...

Neverwinter Nights 2, before DLC. Rocks fall, everybody dies.
Fallout 3, before DLC. Radiation, you die.

I'm just sayin'...

I see what you did there.

Subtly. I like it.

It's not so easy, but I really don't see a point in listing Fallout 3 here. You knew what you had achieved and how it would benefit the Capital Wasteland. And that benefit would be meaningful in the future, with or without you.

[Starschwar]

Bomma72 wrote...

Ultramonkey88 wrote...

The Godfather

Difference is that Godfather 3 was crap from begining to end.  Except for Zah-Zah.  I liked that part.  

And really, Godfather 3 - as terrible as it was - doesn't end in a manner that's particularly different from 2.  Michael's been consumed by the lifestyle he once wished to have nothing to do with, and it cost him everything he really cared about.  3 just had a few more specifics.

[Count Viceroy]

Compared to their general quality, nothing even comes close to the epic failure that is mass effect 3. Not even dragon age 2 was as bad as this.