112 réponses à ce sujet

[xeNNN]

NO I WILL NOT WATCH LIARA DIE NO.

[Mizar_Panzar]

Rockpopple wrote...

That deleted cutscene doesn't make any sense. They get blasted by Harbinger on Earth, then somehow appear on the Normandy?

Even if you were going for an artistic speculative ending, you wouldn't leave a plothole that big to drive through. Every. Single. One. of your squadmates were on EARTH when the Harbinger attack happened. And they suddenly ALL appear on the Normandy? How does that make sense?

I guess, in the original version, you won't get the stupid scene with Normandy.

[Aesieru]

HARBINGER: THUS HURTS YOU!... A LOT

[GeneralArrow]

legion999 wrote...

So Bioware ****s up it's EA's fault? I dislike EA but come on you can't blame them for everything.

Oh but you can to a degree. Don't remember the good old day's of Neverwinter Nights, Baulder's Gate and even before that? Let's remember Dragon Age II...and the fact that Dragon Age was pratically finished before they got to EA. I sense a serious design philoshpy change and games like the Witcher and Witcher II prove they are not needed to sell units. Generally speaking though the changes to Mass Effect 2 and even Mass Effect 3 are actually good gameplaywise. I appluad Mass Effect 3 in the amount of custimization it gave me.

Though back on topic, I think that if this had been the actual ending fans would still rage and complain as it's not much better than what they had in place anyway. I think they wanted Shepard to sacrifice himself for the team and not his team sacrifice themselves for him which seems even more counter intuative than the ending they actually have in place.

Modifié par GeneralArrow, 16 mars 2012 - 06:54 .

[Alamar2078]

Holy crap that would have been a powerful scene. Honstly I would be OK with any squadmates you bring down on the run are "auto killed". It's sad but I think it would have been SOOOO AWESOME to see that in game.

Note: I also love Anderson's cut speech. I hope IF we get a DLC with more ending options that we can get things like this in there!!!!

[Bfler]

With such a scene most people would have to pick the two members they like least. I don't know, but I think it was right to cut it.

Modifié par Bfler, 16 mars 2012 - 06:55 .

[Tossska]

nooooooo!!!!!!!
button... i need this ****ing button...

[Capeo]

In the app they explain that they removed that because they worried people would be pissed that their squaddies get killed with no say in it.

[LucidStrike]

It should be noted that Bioware originally had plans for different scenarios that could happen on the run to the beam, at least one of which included your two squadmates providing cover fire while you make it to the beam, NOT dead.

Modifié par LucidStrike, 16 mars 2012 - 06:59 .

[anlk92]

Capeo wrote...

In the app they explain that they removed that because they worried people would be pissed that their squaddies get killed with no say in it.

And they didn't think people would be pissed off if their squadmates got teleported to Normandy and fled the battle? Just amazing.

I mean seriously though with such dark endings they thought this would be an issue? If you're going for a dark and sad ending at least do it properly with some emotional scenes. Don't cut off stuff like Anderson's last speech because it would be too long. Those kinds of things are what people want to see.

[Legendaryred]

LOL, everyone gonna bring the squadmates they least like

[Legendaryred]

I don't think they die though, probably seriously injured but not dead

[NUM13ER]

Interestingly enough I thought I'd actually led them to their deaths when I was shot by harbinger. I'd planned on going back to an earlier file to save them if it was the case. If this had happened however this was the solution:

"Virmire survivor. Vega. Your sacrifice..I mean...presence is required for this mission."

Modifié par NUM13ER, 16 mars 2012 - 07:17 .

[Heather Cline]

I wish they hadn't cut the Anderson dialogue especially for FemShep about her being a good mother... That was just... well awesome and should have been kept.

[Alamar2078]

For the dramatic element I may actually take Garrus and he REALLY grew on me a LOT in ME3. A real bud.

Vega comes because maybe he can tank it

Edit:  Note I'm an odd fellow sometimes.  In a few games I'd romance Ash and then leave her on Vermire just for the dramatic elements involved.  I'm sure that I'd have some Shep that would take his LI just to see how that ends.

I'm perfectly happy to see bad things happen if & when they are done well and make sense in the story.   If good things happen I'm also happy to see those as long as they also "make sense".

YMMV

Modifié par Alamar2078, 16 mars 2012 - 07:35 .

[CasbynessPC]

Capeo wrote...

In the app they explain that they removed that because they worried people would be pissed that their squaddies get killed with no say in it.

That's hilarious. The ending has everyone important to the story being killed with you having no say in it. What difference would two early deaths have made?

[Wowlock]

Well...that's just lightens my mood right up !

I always wanted to go Solo with the last mission anyways....

I still don't understand what is Bioware's fetish with killing people off like that.

[MissMaster_2]

Well I can't watch Garrus die...

[MysticSpace]

JediHealerCosmin wrote...



Ok... note to self:  if any ending DLC appears, don't bring your favorite squadmates to the final push. 

I think that would only happen if you didn't bring enough war assetes.

[Amaranthy]

Fl1xx wrote...

And this is why I didn't bring Garrus or Liara with me to Earth, just because I had the feeling one of them would die.

But they didn't even if you did bring them with you. My Liara and Garrus walked out of the Normandy at the end.

I believe this was left out because it was too random. You could bring any squadmate with you for the final mission, so you pretty much had the choice to kill any of your squadmate.

[ardias89]

Interresting...

Modifié par ardias89, 26 mars 2012 - 06:08 .

[acrb101]

LucidStrike wrote...

It should be noted that Bioware originally had plans for different scenarios that could happen on the run to the beam, at least one of which included your two squadmates providing cover fire while you make it to the beam, NOT dead.

Do you know if the players had the choice in it? I would enjoy it if you had a choice of orders somewhere along the line of:

• Fall back to the ship
• Provide cover fire
• Charge! 

I can only dream...

[ImmovableMover]

The only thing that scene would have accomplished is me reloading an earlier save and not bringing my LI and Best friend along.

Vega and Javik would be joining me instead.

[Eragondragonrider]

lol they removed that because it would make no scene with the ending if you saw Garrus and Liara walking out from the downed Normandy.