210 réponses à ce sujet

[kakomu]

Sergeant Dre wrote...

I'm glad most of you don't have a job as a reviewer.

Writing off a game because of a ending? Really?

There are a lot of factors that count towards a review, not just how the game ends.

One of the issues is the story. An RPG typically requires a good story. Reviews discuss the story and how it affects the game. The ending destroys the story. A destroyed story affects the score.

[mjh417]

the game up until the last ten mins... 10/10

the last ten minutes... 0/10

[Ryuji2]

Mass Effect 3: 9.5/10

ME3's Ending: 0.5/10

[Si777]

ME3 game              9.5/10

ME3 ending               1/10

[Merchant2006]

Mass Effect 3: 97/100

Endgame: 5/100

[Gyroscopic_Trout]

Until they get back to us about the ending, Schrodinger's Game is both a ten and a one out of ten.

[CroGamer002]

Mass Effect 3 not counting endings: 98/100 - Chobot VA and some animations issues kill perfection

Mass Effect 3 endings: 15/100 - it makes me create good headcanons, but that's about it

[captainbob8383]

Before the last 15 minutes: 9.5/10
After the last 15 minutes: -30/10 = (-10/10)*3 since this 'ending' slaughter the whole trilogy.

[philippe willaume]

Zalitara wrote...

The game itself: 10/10
The ending: 2/10. It get's 1 point for actually being an ending, and 1 point for the pretty colors.

this

[Verit]

Mass Effect 3 excluding the last 10 minutes: 9/10
Mass Effect 3 Ending: 3/10

[Sc2mashimaro]

Apathy1989 wrote...

Some bugs, lazy animators not using right guns, only 3 truely excellent romances (liara, garrus, tali), effective strength affected by MP, and imbalanced difficulty curve.

I didn't have any problem with the difficulty curve, certain guns and powers were much better than others though. (Scorpion was particularly fun)

I also didn't like that the animations would jump between the guns I was actually using and the "default" guns, although this may be related to the decision to make all the guns look very different (ME1 they all looked the same within the same "class") and also have a large variety within each weapon class (ME2 worked with very few models for the guns). I completely agree with that though.

I disagree with your romance comment, however, I was a Miranda romance and while I would have loved to spend more time with her, the story justified our seperation well enough and she made plenty of attempts to contact Shepard during the game. Her characterization continued to be solid and nothing felt too out  of place except that I don't recall being able to have the "I love you" moment with her. I would get excited every time I got a message from her. I'm sure Liara, Garrus, and Tali were all excellent, as they were on-board the Normandy. I would be surprised if Ashley (or Kaiden) was all that bad, since I had a lot of interaction with her as a non-romance. I know there were some not-so-stellar ones: they simply ditched Jacob as an option (I'm not sure many were upset by that) and I've heard you didn't get a lot of time with Thane. I didn't romance Jack but I think I only saw her twice as a non-romance. Are there any I missed?

[Hobbes83]

ME3 before the ending 9.5/10
ME3 ending 2/10

[MB957]

1/10 (0/10 if you ask me..but you requested 1 thru 10...so..1 out of 10)

one drop of poison can ruin the entire well

Modifié par MB957, 16 mars 2012 - 08:59 .

[Unit-Alpha]

5/10

Buggy, ugly, and terrible ending. Otherwise excellent.

[Shortstuff820]

9/10. 4/10 with ending.

[catgirl789]

9.5/10 for a 95% perfect game that's lacking only in one fairly important department.

[saracen16]

Mass Effect 3 10/10

Mass Effect 3 ending 10/10

[DemGeth]

Mass Effect is a 9.

To buggy to rate higher

[milena87]

Before ending: the few interrupts and 2 dialogue options did bother me a bit, and I can't play the Grissom Academy quest because of a freezing issue. Other than that I thought the game was great, one of the best I've ever played.

After ending: I don't know, all I can think of is "why?"; also, it killed my interested of playing the single player again for now :/

[-Skorpious-]

9.5/10 (base)

4/10 (with ending)

[Syrellaris]

8.5 Story
10.0 Acting
8.2 Production
9.0 Graphics/Sound
10.0 Gameplay
===============
end score 9.1

With ending :  9.1

Modifié par Syrellaris, 16 mars 2012 - 09:07 .

[Pairikas]

Until end:8/10
The End: 1/10

Makes 4.5.

Not Playing MP so I had to take 50% of that

Makes Finally: 2.25 / 10

Modifié par Pairikas, 16 mars 2012 - 09:07 .

[ZodiEmish]

With the ending a 4.

If the game had crashed and I never saw the ending. 9.5

[Oilking72]

First of all, I'm not rating the ending seperately. lol.

As it stands now - 9.5/10 Could bump up if the DLC is good enough.