I would like to state foremost that I throughly enjoyed ME3, right up until the finale. In summary, all 3 "best" endings left me with a feeling of disaster for the galaxy. They were all confusing, leaving me not with satisfaction but the burden of troubling questions. That said I would not "change" the endings. That ship has sailed. I would like the endings addressed in DLC which I will comment on at the end of the post. For the moment I would like to breakdown the ending sequence and pose the points and questions that bothered me the most.
1) Beginning with the near suicide dash to the Reaper beam unto the Citadel and Anderson/TIM resolution.
a) Minor point - I thought for sure my companions died in Harbingers final blast. This included Liara (aka my reason for living/fighting etc.) Confusingly enough they managed to board and escape on the Normandy in a closing cut scene.

Minor point - It was depressing to interrupt TIM from executing Anderson simply to have Anderson die minutes later from the gunshot I gave him via TIMs mind control.
2) Ascension to Citadel Reaper control room with Child AI
a) Major point - This was confusing. I gather that this is a incalculably old artificial intelligence whos logic rubs me the wrong way. What I don't get is why this AI (now capped with the Crucible) would suddenly allow me to choose to control, destroy, or synthesize with it. I guess since it has gone with the same gameplan the last billion years it is looking for input? Or why Shepard just goes along with whatever the AI spoon feeds him/her. Since it appears in the boy form I assume it has already scanned my brain and/or memories? Am I being tricked or manipulated?
3) Control / Destroy / Synthesis
Regardless you have no way back and with the Alliance fleets dying outside the Citadel window you must make your choice.
a) Control - Would enslaved Reapers be able to assist in rebuilding galatic infrastructure? Would this even work? Would Shepards will be enough to have a lasting control over the Reapers AI or would he eventually succumb ala a Soulstone in Diablo? My personal Shepard wouldn't believe in enslavement as a viable ending anyway.

Destroy - I lean towards this ending but destroying EDI and the Geth holds me back. Plus in my selfish need to see Liara again this is the only ending where Shepard lives as I understand it. Also the AI comments (that I tend to believe) that the cycle will eventually come again with the creation of new synthetics. Should we feel lucky that we had this semi-merciful AI that only "pruned" organics instead of eradicating all organics?
c) Synthesis - I gather this is supposed to be the optimal ending. For Joker and his sexbot anyway. Seriously though, the potential problems with this are numerous. How does this really affect a organism? Do people need to eat, sleep, reproduce anymore? Do they die of natural causes anymore? How would this affect their psychology? If everything had the same basic dna from plants to animals etc. would a single virus decimate a solar system? If everyone was basically the same would they not still war? or attempt to create a better synthetic?
4) Aftermath
Regardless which ending you choose there will be major questions about 3 main subjects that I see.
a) Remnants of Alliance fleet stuck in Sol System - Oh my. This is what I refer to as a cluster "bleep". Not a one knows what just went down inside the Citadel. Quarians, Turians, and maybe Krogan stuck in Sol with limited food supplies I imagine? Do they eventually resort to cannibalism to survive? This seems like a real powder keg to me.

Joker and Squad - Why did Joker make a mad dash to the nearest relay? Under orders from Hackett? Panic attack? Where are they? Some lush undiscovered garden world? Maybe that world from Jacobs side mission in ME2 with memory killing flora? What is he doing with EDI and my girlfriend? Besides grinning like a idiot. Oh, Joker when I catch up to you...
c) Mass Relay and Citadel destruction - This is the big one. Galactic society destroyed. Everyone land locked in their own systems. The inescapable result of any choice. I am assuming that each system has been heavily destroyed by the Reapers at this point. Now all supply lines are cut. I also assume that most home system resources have been used up,relying on goods coming in from newly settled worlds. Imagine a island nation suffering a terrible natural disaster. Half the population dead. Scarce food or medicine. Shelter consisting of mostly rubble. Disease running rampant. With no aid incoming. Ever. Maybe I'm giving this too much thought. It's only a videogame but the Mass Relay network going down spells Apocalypse to me especially after the Reaper invasion. Maybe if the Reapers were controlled or synthesized they could help open supply lines? Idk. No one does at this point.
5) Old man / Young Boy Shepard legend
a) Minor point - Where is this? Earth? Planet where SR2 crash landed? Still no mass relays eh? /sigh.
DLC
Where do we go from here? In complete honesty...I want future ME3 DLC to deal directly with these questions and concerns many of which are shared amonst the fanbase that has stood behind Bioware from the beginning. Ultimately this is a entertainment product designed to provide satisfaction within reason to the buyer. Loved the game up until the finale which as I stated before left me without that satisfaction. Now maybe Bioware has a plan. Idk. I just do not want to see DLC consisting of new armor, weapons, companion skins, etc while the concerns over the endings go unaddressed. I do not think I could bring myself to pay money for trival virtual items until that is done. In my opinon, do not change the ending. Expand on it with DLC.
Thru the whole ME3 game I saw the repercussions of my actions, please don't leave me hanging on the biggest choice to date.
Modifié par Yaegor, 20 mars 2012 - 03:36 .