9.5/10 easily.
Then after that horrible ending it plummets like ton of bricks.
Rate ME3 WITHOUT the Ending
Débuté par
Menalaos1971
, mars 17 2012 04:14
Retour en haut
#352
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:28
lyssalu
-
- Members
- 937 messages
4.5/10 without the ending
the resolutions of a lot of the ongoing conflicts weren't satisfying (WHAT DIDYOU DO TO THE GETH BIOWARE? SERIOUSLY?), inconsistencies abounded, and even without the stupid ending, many promises were not delivered upon. there were also a lot of hammy moments and the intended drama came across as melodrama instead. also, autodialog. i had almost no control over shepard. it was ****ing annoying.
2.5/10 with it
the resolutions of a lot of the ongoing conflicts weren't satisfying (WHAT DIDYOU DO TO THE GETH BIOWARE? SERIOUSLY?), inconsistencies abounded, and even without the stupid ending, many promises were not delivered upon. there were also a lot of hammy moments and the intended drama came across as melodrama instead. also, autodialog. i had almost no control over shepard. it was ****ing annoying.
2.5/10 with it
Modifié par lyssalu, 21 mars 2012 - 05:30 .
#353
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:30
artjom94
-
- Members
- 49 messages
9/10 - because spacebar for everything.
#355
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:32
Meytiuy
-
- Members
- 37 messages
Solid 9/10. Cries of "NOOO MY BABBIES" or "AWW LOOKIT MY BABBIES" abounded all the way through the game. Such a shame about the end 
#356
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:33
Zix13
-
- Members
- 1 839 messages
9.5/10. Best RPG I've played. With ending. -18/10... since it ruins two other 9/10 games...
#357
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:36
Jayce
-
- Members
- 972 messages
8.5/10
As good as ME2 but not as compelling.
As good as ME2 but not as compelling.
#358
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:38
CaptainJaques
-
- Members
- 69 messages
No such thing as perfection in art...
9.9/10
AND THEN THE ENDINGS
6.5/10
9.9/10
AND THEN THE ENDINGS
6.5/10
#360
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:39
D1ck1e
-
- Members
- 737 messages
This game, no, this trilogy needed an incredible ending.
5/10 tops considering the hype and expectations. I'd give 5/10 to a single book with a great story that has a bad ending, so I'm being generous by not mentionning other aspects of the game that were flawed.
Still waiting on Biowares "listening" process to prove me wrong.
5/10 tops considering the hype and expectations. I'd give 5/10 to a single book with a great story that has a bad ending, so I'm being generous by not mentionning other aspects of the game that were flawed.
Still waiting on Biowares "listening" process to prove me wrong.
#361
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:40
corkey sweet
-
- Members
- 1 218 messages
9/10 before ending
6/10 after ending
6/10 after ending
#362
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:40
Hashbeth
-
- Members
- 417 messages
9.5 out of 10 on the game (couple bugs, overall excellent)
0/10 for the ending content. You just can't excuse lackadaisical, sub-par writing from a company as talented as BioWare
Overall: 4.75/10
0/10 for the ending content. You just can't excuse lackadaisical, sub-par writing from a company as talented as BioWare
Overall: 4.75/10
Modifié par Hashbeth, 21 mars 2012 - 05:41 .
#363
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:40
IntoTheDarkness
-
- Members
- 1 014 messages
0/10 because of the god child.
Before that, 9/10. Not enough volume, not enough plot polishness, good gameplay.
Before that, 9/10. Not enough volume, not enough plot polishness, good gameplay.
#364
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:40
Sublime82
-
- Members
- 134 messages
Add in a perfect ending to the series and it would be one of my favourite games of all time.
#365
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:44
Blackbear2106
-
- Members
- 100 messages
9/10 without ending, could have been longer and more polished:P
Modifié par Blackbear2106, 21 mars 2012 - 05:44 .
#366
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:47
Kuari999
-
- Members
- 474 messages
Story without Ending 9.5/10 only missing the 10 for minor plot and import issues causing plot holes. Nothing major, but definitely not perfect.
Gameplay 9/10
Very solid game without the ending. Would rank it as one of my favorites if not for the ending. That's hard for me to say... to judge something so harshly on the last 10 minutes doesn't feel right, but well... I felt like I watched the fanfiction of a 8 year old at the end there. If the indoctrination theory pans out and they show it, I'd consider it absolute genius, but the worst PR move in the history of gaming. If it doesn't then, well... I'd probably make a point to figure out how to make it to a convention BioWare is at, bring a list of plot holes to ask about and go "what the **** happened?"
Gameplay 9/10
Very solid game without the ending. Would rank it as one of my favorites if not for the ending. That's hard for me to say... to judge something so harshly on the last 10 minutes doesn't feel right, but well... I felt like I watched the fanfiction of a 8 year old at the end there. If the indoctrination theory pans out and they show it, I'd consider it absolute genius, but the worst PR move in the history of gaming. If it doesn't then, well... I'd probably make a point to figure out how to make it to a convention BioWare is at, bring a list of plot holes to ask about and go "what the **** happened?"
#367
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:48
Sszantar
-
- Members
- 19 messages
An easy 8.5/10 for most of the ride. (I don't believe in perfect scores - perfection is unattainable. And while amazing, it still had flaws)
Had a ton of small animation glitches that bugged me, but were easily overlooked. And several other relatively small issues (a few missing voiceover lines from Femshep, no real "side" missions - just scanning for credits and War Assets, very limited opportunities to have 2-way dialogues with squadmates while on the Normandy, etc).
But it was easily the most emotionally powerful game I've ever played (props to the character writers and voice actors for really bringing it to life). Combat was far better than in previous installments. While playing, my complaints completely disappeared off the radar.
Then the ending came in like a punch to the nuts, and completely shattered my bubble. Spent the better part of 2 days in a daze while my mind was running over and over it, obsessively trying to make it fit.
Eventually I solidified my own personal headcanon and purged the "real" finish from my mind, which allowed me to happily replay it several more times (nearly done with playthrough #6 now).
Ending score: 1.5/10
The first time I have ever given anything less than a 4/10, in my entire life.
At the end of the day, looking at the whole package, I have to give the game a 6/10. Greatness brought down to the level of mediocrity by a left hook out of nowhere at the last second.
Had a ton of small animation glitches that bugged me, but were easily overlooked. And several other relatively small issues (a few missing voiceover lines from Femshep, no real "side" missions - just scanning for credits and War Assets, very limited opportunities to have 2-way dialogues with squadmates while on the Normandy, etc).
But it was easily the most emotionally powerful game I've ever played (props to the character writers and voice actors for really bringing it to life). Combat was far better than in previous installments. While playing, my complaints completely disappeared off the radar.
Then the ending came in like a punch to the nuts, and completely shattered my bubble. Spent the better part of 2 days in a daze while my mind was running over and over it, obsessively trying to make it fit.
Eventually I solidified my own personal headcanon and purged the "real" finish from my mind, which allowed me to happily replay it several more times (nearly done with playthrough #6 now).
Ending score: 1.5/10
The first time I have ever given anything less than a 4/10, in my entire life.
At the end of the day, looking at the whole package, I have to give the game a 6/10. Greatness brought down to the level of mediocrity by a left hook out of nowhere at the last second.
#368
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:49
TheNexus
-
- Members
- 565 messages
10/10.
Issues like the journal system are so minor compared to how well the game does practically everything else. Bioware had the daunting task of bringing the stories of ME1 and ME2 together in a cohesive and engaging fashion, and minus the ending they did just that. Not to mention that they improved EVERYTHING from ME2, from gameplay and dialogue fluidity to loading times. It is truly one of the best games I have ever played and it is really a shame about the ending. I still have faith Bioware will learn from this though, they've proven they can make some of the best games out there.
If you just look at the opening scene when Shepard is talking to Anderson on Earth, the conversation and the way Shepard and Anderson react and move in the environment is some of the most fluid animations I've ever seen in any video game, period.
Issues like the journal system are so minor compared to how well the game does practically everything else. Bioware had the daunting task of bringing the stories of ME1 and ME2 together in a cohesive and engaging fashion, and minus the ending they did just that. Not to mention that they improved EVERYTHING from ME2, from gameplay and dialogue fluidity to loading times. It is truly one of the best games I have ever played and it is really a shame about the ending. I still have faith Bioware will learn from this though, they've proven they can make some of the best games out there.
If you just look at the opening scene when Shepard is talking to Anderson on Earth, the conversation and the way Shepard and Anderson react and move in the environment is some of the most fluid animations I've ever seen in any video game, period.
Modifié par TheNexus, 21 mars 2012 - 05:51 .
#369
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:50
LilyasAvalon
-
- Members
- 5 076 messages
8/10
I was pretty upset about the removal of neutral dialogue and lack of female turians, if you give me female turians however, it bumps it up to a 9/10.
With the endings however, it gets bashed to a pitiful 3/10, 1/10 if you judge the ENTIRE series, not just ME3.
I was pretty upset about the removal of neutral dialogue and lack of female turians, if you give me female turians however, it bumps it up to a 9/10.
With the endings however, it gets bashed to a pitiful 3/10, 1/10 if you judge the ENTIRE series, not just ME3.
#370
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:52
Shadow2G
-
- Members
- 56 messages
9/10 without the ending. An epic gaming and science fiction experience right up until the last 10 minutes, IMO.
#372
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:54
HaesoME3
-
- Members
- 165 messages
1/10 - because the game would not have a proper ending. Not 0/10 because then at least it wouldn't have vent boy and deus ex machina copy/pasted almost perfectly.
#373
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:56
f34nor
-
- Members
- 7 messages
without the ending..? masterpiece...... 10/10
Modifié par f34nor, 21 mars 2012 - 05:57 .
#374
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:57
Powerpetzi
-
- Members
- 223 messages
9.5/10 for the game up to ... up to the point where Shep meets Star Child. Even the resolution with TIM was great IMO.
1/10 from Star Child onwards. I wanted to give 0/10, but end up awarding a point for decent visual and sound effects.
1/10 from Star Child onwards. I wanted to give 0/10, but end up awarding a point for decent visual and sound effects.
#375
Posté 21 mars 2012 - 05:57
juliannacorn
-
- Members
- 53 messages
B.E. - 9/10
A.E. - 1/10
That one guy was right, with his poo-centered ice cream metaphor. Doesn't matter how good the ice cream is, you're only going to think about the poo in retrospect.
A.E. - 1/10
That one guy was right, with his poo-centered ice cream metaphor. Doesn't matter how good the ice cream is, you're only going to think about the poo in retrospect.
