688 réponses à ce sujet

[Bomma72]

9.5/10.

[CJMissen]

9.5/10 one of the most enjoyable games I've ever played, controls were a bit finicky on PC though, the multicontext of interact and dodge kept stuffing around with my gamepaly enjoyment but otherwise, still fantastic

[Demonburnt]

12/10 easy

but in this current state

-3/10

Modifié par Demonburnt, 21 mars 2012 - 05:59 .

[magor1988x]

9.75 out of 10 w/out the ending & including MP. Including the ending 7 out of 10.

[NJ930]

Easily a 10/10 for me without the ending.

[Merwanor]

I would rate it 9.9/10 as I just wish they showed Tali's face when she took her mask of at her home planet, would have been such a fitting conclusion to that story and would finally show me how the quarians look like. Don't tell me I should go by the Tali romance photo, I will never accept that crap.

With the ending, it is impssible for me to rate the game, because it destroys the whole series and makes the games unreplayable. Which is extreamly sad as the game is completly amazing until that stupid ending.

Modifié par Merwanor, 21 mars 2012 - 06:02 .

[pmc]

8/10

I felt that the game was a bit too short, could have used more interesting side quests and other areas to explore aside from the citadel.

[Lambda Diamond]

without ending 9.5 because of the bugs and because multiplayer is needed which is lame!

[AddictMsk]

9/10 without the ending.

[SumoPanda17]

The game was an easy 11. just the ending....it destroyed the game for me. i was like "so thats it?"

[Takamori The Templar]

6.5/10

[Veracity]

Without the ending, 7.5/10.
- Climax and Act 3 were weak at best, and hastily drawn together.
- Game play was decent.
- Acts 1 & 2 were amazingly good.
- Lack of sidequests and explorable areas also hurt replayability quite a bit.
- World scanning for resources is really tedious and just not engaging to the player.
- Less control of Shepard's dialogue than in previous games, taking away some of the choice we loved in having.

With the ending: 3/10.

Modifié par Veracity, 21 mars 2012 - 06:12 .

[Budgier]

8/10.

I think Mass Effect 3 is the weakest of the trilogy, but of course still much better than the average game.

With the endings I'd rate Mass Effect 3 a 6/10.

[Olueq]

8/10

Most of the quests are just scanning. Theres also no exploration. I also completed it insanely fast.

Modifié par Olueq, 21 mars 2012 - 06:11 .

[Senario]

W/o ending. 8.5/10 I docked the game significant amounts of points because of the downgrade of the journal system(YU NO TELL ME WHICH SYSTEM TO GO TO), The excessive amount of fetch quests, and the lack of actual land on xx planet quests outside of the main story. Also so much Auto dialogue with a lot of the "choice oriented" dialogue belonging to major characters that you can't avoid. Like Liara's multitude of scenes compared to the lack of dialogue with other squaddies.

The inclusion of characters that ultimately didn't make much sense to me also lost it some points because of bad acting: Diana Allers, and confusion: James Vega...?? Where is the Krogan squadmate? I also was going to dock 0.3 points because control wasn't as smooth as ME2...but I replayed ME2 and realized the increased complication was for the better of the game.

Story writing obviously saved the game and kept the score high but it can only go so far.

With ending, 7.2-7.5/10 ending can ruin the ME series for you. It can un do every choice you have made without even thinking of consequences.

Modifié par Senario, 21 mars 2012 - 06:15 .

[Daerog]

While playing, felt like 10/10. After thinking about it, more like 9/10 minus the ending.

The ending... I'm not going to bother to rate it. It was amazing up to get hit by Harbinger, then just became okay/tolerable/acceptable up to the point where Hackett voices that the crucible isn't working, then it just took a complete nose dive.

[My-name-is-Paradox]

Blind2Society wrote...

I wouldn't go 10/10 but minus the ending, it's a damn good game. probably a 7 or 8.

Some things that contributed to a lower score are
- Tali hackjob
- lack of war assets in final battle
- lack of worlds to explore (no Palaven, no Hanar homeworld, no Elcor homeworld, ect.)
- lack of squadmates

Other than that (and the ending) it was excellent.

This sums up my feelings pretty well.

[macarius5]

9/10 - Great!

just minor annoyances .. technical & the side quest (overheard conversation) pop out of nowhere but does not take away the overall gameplay. (that is without the ending)

With the ending (7/10)

[EllOneillE]

95/100 Fantastic experience. Could have been my favorite videogame story ever, the perfect peak for a trilogy. They did rush and cheap out on some stuff like the aforementioned Quarian face reveal. So the missing 5 points are for little background details that could have been much better.

And then there's the ending, which invalidates a lot of what had been done in the trilogy and just doesn't fit. It makes me not want to play any ME anymore. It makes me as unhappy with the game as the game with a good ending would have made me happy. That turns the score into a negative value for the game with the end as it is at this moment.

[FortitudeSon]

10/10, absolutely incredible experience. Easily one of the best games ever made.

[JPN17]

Game: 9/10 The game was good and I thoroughly enjoyed it. There's some issues that should have been fixed before hand that weren't (the face import issue, some dialogue cutting out etc) that lower the score a bit, but overall it was one of the more fun games I've ever played.

Ending: 0/10 When 10 minutes make it so I not only can't replay this game, but the two games that preceded it, you know there is something horribly wrong.

Modifié par JPN17, 21 mars 2012 - 06:39 .

[Gchavez]

9-9.5/10 without

7-7.5/10 with

[BushbabyX]

Without: 9/10

With: 8.5/10

[Jestina]

Too linear.

Questing sucks badly.
1)Wander around citadel
2)Do boring system scans
3)Collect line/s of text
4)Repeat
A complete borefest.
The game even lacks other things such as holstering, hacking/bypassing. Too much recycled material and not enough new. The graphics/animations are just awful. Whole game feels rushed.

Don't know why they have an RPG mode because there's little RPG left in ME.

[Kayawyn4]

Without the ending, 10/10 easily. Little things like the journal could be fixed easily. The core game was amazing. With the ending, well... I can't bring myself to play it again.