688 réponses à ce sujet

[Rilke21]

I would give it a solid 10. With the ending, I would ask for a refund.

[Daverid]

10/10 .. Without a Doubt .. And if Indoctrination Theory proves correct and they put it in as DLC and it's SATISFYING.. Then my current 8/10 goes back to 10.

That game was unbelievably awesome ... Like sure there less "Run-Ins" with Side characters from ME2 (There was heaps of Run-Ins with Side Characters from ME1 in ME2) ... But the Combat was near perfected. Dialogue Choices felt similar to ME2 and 1 ... There was HEAPS more Paragon/Renegade Choices that actually did something cool or meaningful. I cried like a little Girl multiple Times over Deaths Like; Mordin, Legion, Thane ... The new "Overhear Conversations" to pick up quests was really cool .. Like sure you couldn't investigate more into what they were doing, but you generally got to hear more of the story if you walked away and walked back to them.

The little Minor Annoyances I had with the game (Beside the HUGE one being the Ending) was NEVER enough for me to downrate the game even 0.1% ... Every Epic moment made up for the MINOR flaws and again, they were extremely Minor, to the point of even talking about them is being absurdly 'Nitpicky'.

This is why people, like me, are So Fired up about the Endings .. Because the game was just SO BEAUTIFUL ... That to see it, and the previous 2 as well, get tarnished (Not completely Spoilt but definitely Tarnished) by this Abomination of an Ending just is so frustrating.

[SchizoTyler]

Sywen wrote...

without ending 9/10 journal, side quests and auto dialogue annoyed me

Exactly this.

The no updates journal annoyed me to no end and is worth taking off a .5 on its own.

I could discount the ridiculous number of fetch quests if I didn't HAVE to do them in order to get enough war assets to get the "best ending", but because I have to do them, they become tedious. This combined with the crappy journal... *moans in displeasure*

Then the auto dialogue just felt wrong. Half the squad dialogue on the Normandy wasn't even cut scene dialogue, it lost a little bit of its awe factor compared to the other 2 games in the trilogy. As a new IP I wouldn't have minded it so much, but because it is suddenly changed like this in the third part of a trilogy it felt out of place.

Modifié par SchizoTyler, 21 mars 2012 - 10:06 .

[Swisspease]

ME3 without ending 9.5/10
ME3 with endings 0.5/10
ME1, ME2, ME3 without ME3 ending 10/10
ME1, ME2, ME3 with ME3 ending 4/10

[WaterWar]

Without ending: 9,5/10.
It was an amazing, thrilling, at times heartbreaking ride. I enjoyed every minute of it.
It was amazing to see how your actions in the past two games had influence on the options available to you.
Favourite moments: Reunion with LI (Liara), peace between Geth and Quarians, curing the genophage and all the small chit-chatting the crew did between missions. I really loved how much more in-depth the characters were. They wandered around your ship, they went on shore leaves where you could dance with them, shot bottles and much more. Really impressive.
I also loved the faster pace that the combat had. You really felt that your 'Throw' biotic ball could knock people miles away. All the powers really had a nice punch to it.
The sounds and voice acting were all top notch!
A few minor downsides: few, but hilarious, graphical glitches.

[Jere85]

9.5 without, 0 with the ending, it totally gutterballs the whole franchise.

Couldnt do the 10 because of some graphical flaws

Modifié par Jere85, 21 mars 2012 - 09:59 .

[Arctic Silence]

10/10 without the ending for sure.

[Omega Torsk]

9/10

Things that could improve that rating include fixing bugs, making the journal easier to understand (so many side quests, so little direction), and adding content that was missed [something that can easily be implemented with DLC. For example, more romances, more romance interactions, more squadmates, missing characters from the previous games being given roles in this game, cosmetic things (ie: being able to actually use that poker table in the lounge. Lol), etc].

However, the ending makes me throw that rating across the room, toss my arms up, and walk out...

Modifié par Omega Torsk, 21 mars 2012 - 10:17 .

[Echo_V]

Kind of hard since i can't remember much besides the bad ending....but i will try

8/10

i loved it, so many great moments which made me tear up! really touching! especially mordins and legions deaths. Brilliant!

i also played the multiplayer quite a few times AND I enjoyed it.

BUT 2 points deduction for the poorly done thane romance, well and every other continued ME2 romance besides tali and garrus. I mean you can't even call it romance. Slack off much?

and NO, it's not about thanes "death", I'm complaining about the romance scene(s)!!

[Lietuvis]

10/10 without discussion. With the ending included 3/10, it ruined whole franchise for me

[Orumon]

9.6 out of 10. Easy. Until the ending which knocks it way down to 4.

[GothamLord]

8/10

Graphic Glitches and lack of ME2 character support.

[Warden130]

Without ending: 9.8/10
With ending: 9/10

I don't see how it ruins the whole game for people. But oh well, I can easily still enjoy regardless of the ending.

[dorktainian]

before rushing towards the light in london, 10/10

Stagger towards the light, add Star Kid & the 'supposed' ending and I wouldnt even give it a 4/10 cos it makes no sense at all.

[sadako]

Not that chronic a fan

Branches for NPC interaction resulting in various outcomes, taking into consideration some of the things you did in ME1 and ME2
30/10, it was that awesome.

Journal system
0/10

Ending
0/10

Average score : 10/10

[Nighthunteer]

9/10

[AvagerShepard]

8/10.
I would give it 9/10 but the auto dialogue options and the fact that you gather a big army and then doesn't have an epic battle where you see Makos and hammerhead storming the reapers, as well as the Krogans, Turians etc made it 8/10.

With the ending: 6/10

[BaKaNoOB]

Game 10/10
End -200/10

[Silasqtx]

10/10, even if:

Some animations could've been done better.
Sometimes facial expressions don't express what the VA was saying/meaning.
I would've loved more missions (not go-fetch missions) but that's nitpicking.
Journal is not useful.
Sometimes lots of auto-dialogue but I can understand that. We're in the middle of a war, I (Shepard) would personally don't care if they want their eggs scrambled or deviled.

The story kept me from rating it 9/10.

Modifié par Silasqtx, 21 mars 2012 - 10:18 .

[puppy maclove]

8.5 / 10 (MP been forced on us is a let down, ie to get the best ending is BS)

The ending really does take the stuffing out of the whole series. Loses its replay-ability.

[SKiLLYWiLLY2]

8.5/10

[Freestate2nd]

8/10
I miss:
more hubs (only citadel,return to illos aka normandy crash could be enjojable and omega)
Some vehicle mission (not necessary mako or hammerhead,some better or surprising like the shadow broker aerocab chase scene)
More me2 squad relevance
Better romance scenes.
Some type of suicide mission 2 that involves the fleets,war assets and squadies for the ending.
No final boss!
Tim´s relevance is poor!
Some space battle gameplay.

Modifié par Freestate2nd, 21 mars 2012 - 10:21 .

[Tamcia]

9.2/10


Miss exploration with Mako/Hammer

Miss RPG elements. 

Wanted bigger zones, more enemies etc.

More conversations with characters.

Modifié par Tamcia, 21 mars 2012 - 10:21 .