688 réponses à ce sujet

[StarcloudSWG]

Up until, and including, the scene with Anderson and Shepard sitting next to each other, looking out over the battle; 9 to 9.5 out of 10.

The ending, starting with Harbinger's little illusion; 1/10.

Too short, too simple, too little information, no chance to throw the little ********'s words back into it's face, no confrontation, and you're forced to accept its choices; there are no others.

The relays blowing up. The citadel blowing up. Joker and the Normandy somehow in front of a shockwave and then landing on an alien planet. All the different races effectively stranded in Earth orbit. Galactic civilization effectively doomed to a prolonged dark age.

THIS is just a bitter ending. There's no sweet to it.

Or WORSE: the whole thing is an illusion. THAT theory doesn't make me feel ANY better.

[Berkilak]

Impossible. That's like rating a sandwich without taking a bite. It might look pretty tasty as it all comes together, but if the culmination isn't worth it, it was all for naught.

[SirCrimz]

Game of the year worthy, 10/10.

[darkiddd]

 10/10 

And then the last 10 minutes came. The horror:pinched:

[Reptilian Rob]

10/10

Makes the ending even worse knowing that...

[Menalaos1971]

StarcloudSWG wrote...
The relays blowing up. The citadel blowing up. Joker and the Normandy somehow in front of a shockwave and then landing on an alien planet. All the different races effectively stranded in Earth orbit. Galactic civilization effectively doomed to a prolonged dark age.

THIS is just a bitter ending.

Did you not understand this part?  Joker was trying to escape the approaching Alpha Relay DLC blast wave.  He kicked in the ship's FTL drive and jumped to max speed, making to another solar system that fortunately had a habitable moon, but even that far away (light years) from the blast it nearly destroyed the Normandy when it hit.  Within the Sol system everything was destroyed.  The fleet?  Vapor and Dust.  Did you get the "good" ending where the ground troops rose and cheered?  About a minute later they were dust, too.

And then all the rest of the relays exploded.  Thessia?  Palavan?  Tuchanka?  The Salarian home world?  Dust.  Did you make peace with the Quarian and Geth?  Rannoch is dust, too.

That is how I see the ending.  The only worlds not wiped clean were those not in the same system as a Relay.  All of the main worlds and major colonies are just gone.

Now, that is a bitter ending.

[Neroteyen]

Before ending 9.5 maybe even 10
After ending *Shudder* 1 maybe 2

[yahtzo]

10/10 with no ending

[Ticondurus]

9/10. Ending didn't bother me as much as others, but I'll shave 2 points off with current ending (7/10.)

Showing your war assets in action for the final confrontation (i.e. Jack and her biotic squad, Miranda/Jacob, the Rachni Queen wiping out a Reaper, the Geth in action for you, Aria's merc squads, etc.) and celebrations across all homeworlds, along with your team, after you disable the Reapers would have added a big emotional punch.

I honestly thought that when your Shephard was going up on the platform at the very end that you would find out that YOU were the Catalyst, therefore the need to sacrifice your life to kick in the Crucible and save the galaxy. That, plus the above suggestions, and I would smile for days after watching the credits roll.

[ed87]

I dont think Bioware needs a pat on the back right now given the level of disappointment, but ill bite.

9/10 - Loved the introduction of flashlights and fighting in the dark. Only negative was that even before the end i felt some of my big past decisions didnt matter. Saving rachni queen = irrelevant. And a lot of decisions were rewarded with some lazy war assets card with a score.. whoop dee doo

[goatman42]

8 or 9 out of 10 for the game. It was really good, but it could have had some better things. The galaxy map was lame and some of the side quests felt only ok.

3 out of 10 for the ending.

[Walzon]

9.5/10 - stupid miniquests, multiplayer war assets, not a lot of dialogue choices compared to other games, customization was just based off of credits, and really don't help out THAT much (although it looked cool), and pretty linear. Also, characters like Vega and Javik need their own little subplot like in me2, really did not feel a connection with those guys... Otherwise, pure awesome

[Walzon]

Ticondurus wrote...

9/10. Ending didn't bother me as much as others, but I'll shave 2 points off with current ending (7/10.)

Showing your war assets in action for the final confrontation (i.e. Jack and her biotic squad, Miranda/Jacob, the Rachni Queen wiping out a Reaper, the Geth in action for you, Aria's merc squads, etc.) and celebrations across all homeworlds, along with your team, after you disable the Reapers would have added a big emotional punch.

I honestly thought that when your Shephard was going up on the platform at the very end that you would find out that YOU were the Catalyst, therefore the need to sacrifice your life to kick in the Crucible and save the galaxy. That, plus the above suggestions, and I would smile for days after watching the credits roll.

that would be AMAZING, also when he dies, it flashes back to all characters, and before he dies, you see like "ghost" images of those who have died before, and you join them (kinda corny)

[Walzon]

Berkilak wrote...

Impossible. That's like rating a sandwich without taking a bite. It might look pretty tasty as it all comes together, but if the culmination isn't worth it, it was all for naught.

great quote

[PlumPaul93]

9-9.25, It's a great game, but it has a good amount of problems that just aren't acceptable for a single player RPG.

[RedShft]

Without Ending - 9.5/10 (I can't give it 10/10 because of some Audio problems, AI quriks and Thirdperson Combat specific design descisions)

Ending - 6/10 (It's generic, confusing and overal weak)

Overall 9/10 (Great fun, I really love this series, for 23 hours and 45 minutes of great playthough and 15 minutes of medicore ****)

[Carnage752]

9- without ending
-109637378844246646655 -with ending

[sadako]

not going to, this is just going to reinforce the fact to the devs that they can make a FPS/RPG game and give it a shoddy ending.

Modifié par sadako, 17 mars 2012 - 05:58 .

[Harmless Crunch]

9.7/10 without the ending. Would be a 10 were it not for a few annoyances.
Ending (On it's own) 3/10. Hey the music was amazing.

[Menalaos1971]

8/10 Main
0/10 Ending

[Eain]

6.5/10 main
0/10 ending

I was overall never that impressed with the game, though I was content knowing that at least it didn't suck as bad as DA2.

[Killer3000ad]

9.5/10 Without ending
-1/10 With ending.

Modifié par Killer3000ad, 17 mars 2012 - 02:32 .

[RedundantAccount]

9/10 -
(-1 for the crappy quest log)

Otherwise no complaints with everything up to the ending. LOVED it.

Modifié par RedundantAccount, 17 mars 2012 - 02:34 .

[Grand Wazoo]

I hate rating games with numbers but here goes.

7.5-8.0/10 if it wasn't for the endings. The game is beautiful, but still has it's flaws.

[frajerik]

8/10 very good game but ending ....