688 réponses à ce sujet

[Mandemon]

9,5/10, some glitches and minor nuisances, nothing major.

[NReed106]

So many improvements were made (except the ending)
I loved how I could see the crew having their own conversations, I loved how they developed the characters (I'm Garrus Vakarian and this is my favorite spot on the Citadel), I wish the mod system for weapons was a bit more indepth but it was much better than ME2.

I loved the emotional moments in the game, I've never come as close to tears as I did seeing Thane pray for me instead of himself.

It's as close to 10/10 I've ever played (save the ending)

[TerrifiedKiz]

Without the ending it's 9/10.

[LightweightJustice]

Aesieru wrote...

6.5

Final mission doesn't matter because assets aren't actually meaningful in any manner and don't matter and are instead replaced by a generic army and fleet that dies and is not technologically compatible with the lore of the current technology out.

Game is incomplete, you waste a large amount of time building up a fleet for no reason.

Incomplete games don't get good ratings.

+1

But 7,5 in my case,  coz I love party members, the best chars made in past years.

Modifié par LightweightJustice, 17 mars 2012 - 02:48 .

[Fuzzfro]

9.5/10 Apart from ending an Amazing game.

Loses .5 for a few minor issues
-MP involvement with the SP
-Quest Journal problems
-PS3 Framerates at times

The ending would probably around a 2/10
(gains points for nice conversation with anderson)

[thesmallearth]

Everything before the last 5 minutes...brilliant

[Missy_MI]

I'd give it a 9 for sure.

Seeing so many characters, even minor ones, make an appearance in the third game was really gratifying for me as someone who played through from the beginning.

Longer NPC conversations throughout the Citadel were a nice touch as well - I found myself leaving and entering the hospital just to hear the rest of the Asari commando can-I-have-a-gun story.

As so many others have already stated, the geth/quarian and genophage pieces were fantastic - really made me feel like I was making a difference for the better in the ME universe.

I found combat to be very solid throughout and getting the chance to take over a gun turret or mech once in awhile was a nice change of pace.

Not giving it a 10 because I was disappointed in the lack of permanent squadmates (Jarvik and EDI didn't really resonate with me), and also that the Reapers just ran in and grabbed the Citadel I'd worked so hard to improve without any word of resistance.

[Andur4]

Minus the ending, 8.9, but only because I could nit-pick a bunch of stuff, like dialogue not being the greatest in some places, Tali's face, etc. An absolutely fantastic end to a trilogy!
...until the last ten-fifteen minutes, which absolutely destroy it, but that's another story.

[Synonamess]

The game before charging the beam - 9.5/10

The ending - WTF/10

[RedWulfi]

11/10

[fides5566]

10/10

[FrAgGy]

10/10

[Arathon]

6.5/10 War assets doesnt really do anything....

[Aesieru]

Also since no game can ever get a 10 and should ever get a 10, we can probably ignore every single 10 or above rating in this thread, since that doesn't even make sense.

[Giskler]

Minus the ending its 10/10 easily. SO satisfied with everything else, only very minor nitpicks besides the awful ending.

[Lawliet89]

9.5/10 really. Some awkward moments in Shepard's behaviour but otherwise a stellar game.

[ShadyKat]

9/10
Imo, ME3 was the best of the series.

[cotheer]

7/10
Some bad decisions were made.

Edited.

Modifié par cotheer, 17 mars 2012 - 03:20 .

[MonkeySeeker]

Ignoring the ending: 9/10 (the journal is an unhelpful POS)

The ending itself: 1/10 (for the pretty colours)

[Dark_Caduceus]

9/10, could have been better but it was really good.

[Chibi Buizel]

9.8/10. By far the best gaming experience I've ever had.

0/10. Drove that experience into the ground.

Modifié par Chibi Buizel, 17 mars 2012 - 03:11 .

[Nykara]

Menalaos1971 wrote...

Imagine yourself before you finished the game.  Let's say, you took a break right after firing the second missile launcher at the Reaper Destroyer in London, and that's all you knew about the game.  What would you have rated Mass Effect 3 at that point out of 10, with 10 being Perfect?

For me, I would have given this game a 9 at that point.  I would have liked a little more "RPG" in my shooter, and there were a few minor graphical hiccups in conversations, but up to that point in the game I was having an absolute blast.  I helped some old friends out, even a few to have "good deaths", and I worked my butt off the bring the largest fleet in 50,000 years to bear on my enemy.

Personally, the scene where the fleet arrives and the space battle began was freak'n epic.  I quite enjoyed the street fighting to get to the "end", too.


NOW, rate just the Ending.  There's only one Ending.  Now matter how they try to spin it, it really is just the one.

0/10.  The ending honestly ruined the entire series.  I don't have to go into the details.  They've been covered.  Had they just ended it at the TIM encounter, and then given you an ending crafted from your choices, with a DA:O wrap up for your friends and the galaxy as a whole, I would have walked away happy.  Hell, I'd have imported my next ME2 save and immediately started playing again.  But, I just can't now.  I HATE this ending that much.

Before the beam 9.5/10 I was LOVING the journey. I took off .5 for the minor bugs but im sure they could have easily been fixed, slight annoyances at best that didn't really detract from my game play experience.

After the beam 1/10

And then the comment. 'There is time for one more story' to the grandson when talking about The Shepard which gave me a flicker of hope? That the ending was all just a bad nightmare. That they had a plan. That this wasn't the end at all.

[augustburnt]

 Once again, if you go to a circus and have a great time, ride the rides, eat some cotton candy, see the clowns and go through the haunted house you probably had a great time. But when the clowns pull out AK-47s and start mowing down everybody you know, it kinda ruins the entire experience.

[LDStaredown]

The best game I have ever played. It even topped OoT, which I tought would always stand at the top. 11/10.

[NeecHMonkeY]

I would say 8/10.

The new Journal was awful and the side-quest fetch missions lacked... well, pretty much everything a decent side-quest should but the main missions and character moments were some of the best in the series.

Not just the action either, it was the quieter scenes such as Tali realizing that she had a homeworld again but was still going to leave it to come with you.

Garrus and Shepard spending the day literally shooting the sh*t on the Citadel.

Liara's Time Capsule and her goodbye.

Pretty much EDI's entire storyline.

80% of Mass Effect is brilliant, engaging and extremely emotional and that's why that other 20% (less if I let go of the side-quest and Journal disappointment) feels like I've just been punched in the guts.

Modifié par NeecHMonkeY, 17 mars 2012 - 03:14 .