121 réponses à ce sujet

[Luigitornado]

So basically your judging a female character by her looks.

Great story, bro.

[Mandemon]

Yeah, I preferred when her hair was up. She looked more like a soldier she is.

[jumpingkaede]

novaseeker wrote...

Yeah they went over sexy with Ashley -- also her face was changed,too, made more pouty and so on. Was a bit jarring and out of character for her, I found.

Honestly, if they hadn't told me that was Ashley I might not have realized.  Eyebrows are different, expression isn't the same.  Facial structure is different.  Hair, obviously.

Modifié par jumpingkaede, 17 mars 2012 - 03:58 .

[Mr. Big Pimpin]

jumpingkaede wrote...

Walrusninja wrote...

I guess the idea was "Ash is a bit more laid back now, she's let her down". Not subtle, but true I reckon. Also this age old arguement of people being made attractive in games is daft. If you bake a cake, you don't drop it on the floor at the end and scrape it up to make sure that it's politically correct and not too pretty.

All the dudes are ripped. I don't see being healthy as a bad example to set in gaming.

It's not like she was fat and out of shape in ME1.  Or Liara was hitting the Asari buffets a little bit too often before she met Shepard.  They were all in shape and "healthy".  They were both attractive already.

Then they both went and got boob jobs. 

Not to mention how Samara, EDI, and Miranda were designed from the start.

I'm just glad they didn't try to alter Tali.

[detroitmechworks]

Luigitornado wrote...

So basically your judging a female character by her looks.

Great story, bro.

I see what you did there.

Nice try.  No, they changed the character, to make her sexier, and I liked the character better when she wasn't primarily a sex object.

[Optimus J]

ME1 Ash is better than ME3 Ash because ME1 eyebrows MOVE.
Botox face is sad.

[jumpingkaede]

Luigitornado wrote...

So basically your judging a female character by her looks.

Great story, bro.

Who liked Ashley's personality better in ME1 and ME2?  /raises hand.

Something was just off about her character in ME3.  I understand character growth but it was jarring.  Where's the Ashley that told Shepard to leave her behind and save Kaiden instead?  Where's the Ashley who would put a bullet between the eyes of a Geth at 100m?  Where was the Ashley that would talk back to Shepard if she disagreed?  She went from brave and determined and independent to being... meek? 

Did Shepard's death and temporary alliance with Cerberus shake her up that much?  I was looking forward to getting her back, avoided all the romances in my "official" playthrough, etc., but I didn't really care for Ashley that much in ME3.

[NoirLegend]

I love Ashley in everyway (ME1 = ME3)! :3

[TFulls]

i hate her no matte what

[Mr. Big Pimpin]

If anybody's wondering why Ashley changed (personality-wise), it's because she got a new writer. A bunch of other characters did too.

Modifié par Mr. Big Pimpin, 17 mars 2012 - 04:10 .

[Baine10]

Ashley is distrustful and thus unprofessional and widely discriminates against other species.

Typical human in the 21st century. For all her flaws, I just want to renegade punch her in the face. Her character has almost zero development in this edition of mass effect. No side-arguments, no side-interactions.

Unlike Liara. See the difference?

[detroitmechworks]

Baine10 wrote...

Ashley is distrustful and thus unprofessional and widely discriminates against other species.

Typical human in the 21st century. For all her flaws, I just want to renegade punch her in the face. Her character has almost zero development in this edition of mass effect. No side-arguments, no side-interactions.

Unlike Liara. See the difference?

Plus they stuck her in the Hospital for half the game...  Is it a coincidence that her Voice Actress also played Oracle in Arkham City/Asylum?

[mango smoothie]

I liked Ashley appearance in ME1 and ME3, but I do wish she had a alternate appearance that has her hair up.

[PSUHammer]

thinicer wrote...

Hammer6767 wrote...

thinicer wrote...

Bioware really sexed up Ashley in game #3.

There was not a single unattractive human character in the whole game. Everybody was thin, every man was muscular looking like they could win olympic medals, and all the women had perfect bodies.

I don't see too many soldiers or military personnel in real life that are overweight or out of shape.  

So all the human citizens on the Citadel were soldiers?

Well, there you have a point, but that is video games and television, in general.  How many soap operas have ugly people?  Why are all the doctors & nurses on Grey's Anatomy (and the spin off after it) all real attractive people?

[kegNeggs]

absolutely. it may seem like a good idea in the pics and drawings, but its just not the ashley I'd want. I prefer the poetry loving side of her - the one that doesnt care much about her hair

[Eromenos]

Ashley looked better in ME1. A professional soldier, and *gasp* clearly a woman soldier.

Now? Catsuit, high-heels, and hair down past her shoulders. I remember when some(many) people tried to excuse this appearance by claiming she's bustin' out as a pimp in her own right now that she's a Spectre. Well...she wasn't. And she doesn't. So much for that thin excuse.

ME1 Ash is better than ME3 Ash because ME1 eyebrows MOVE.
Botox face is sad. 

I couldn't put my finger on that till you mentioned it. Another good point.

She and Miranda both have bad clipping/animation issues in part because of those asinine manes of hair.

Modifié par Eromenos, 17 mars 2012 - 04:34 .

[Kalyppso]

I liked her hair down ...

[RogueBot]

I still love that poetry-quoting nerd, even though I found her appearance more endearing in ME1&2. i don't mind her looking hot, but she just doesn't look like she's even the same person. Maybe she went into deep cover and had to get plastic surgery?

[shurryy]

I regret I let her live... She's so uninteresting.
Kaidan MUST have better stories judging what I heard from ME1.

[UltmtBiz]

I like the new one not that the old one was bad.

[xeNNN]

yeah i did
but ashleys looks fine with her hair down but its not ashley with her hair down soo :/

[Iakus]

Preferred her hair up and in a real Alliance uniform.

At least she wears armor in combat. Not convinced that was originally planned.

[AwesomeDudex64]

 She makes me regret leaving Kaidan behind, especially in my femshep save. Now she has no other option but to become a lesbian.

Oh and her hair doesn't matter to me 

Modifié par AwesomeDudex64, 17 mars 2012 - 04:43 .

[SuperVulcan]

I had my Shepard romance her; her hair didn't really matter to me. I thought she looks fine regardless.