131 réponses à ce sujet

[Nikitn]

The ME3 ending was **** not because of the hopelessness, but because of the lack of: logic, choises, a  proper conclusion and a decent spacebattle scene.

Do many of you disagree? Would you accept this deus-ex monstrosity of an ending just if your shepard and his mates lived happily ever after? If so, shame on you. Don't get me wrong. I wouldn't mind it if a happy outcome was possible, if difficult to attain, but the lack of this is in no way the real issue.

Just felt I had 2 clear the air.

Modifié par Nikitn, 17 mars 2012 - 11:12 .

[MythicLegands]

HOW DARE YOU.....reapers are beyond your comprehension

[M.D]

People want choice.

[loungeshep]

People also want these threads to end.

Support Changing the ending so that we can be free of these threads.

Support Change. Support End.

[TekFanX]

Personally I prefer happy endings.
Also I don't mind deus ex machinas, if placed properly.

But I agree: The endings, as they are now, won't become good just by adding a happy ending.
The questions "When were the (dead) squadmates from earth resurrected and beamed onto the normandy?" and "Why is Joker suddenly fleeing from combat, in contrast to the character as we know it?" shouldn't stand open as they are now.
I'd also like to know how the biggest fleet ever around earth suddenly disappeared. There isn't even enough debris around, to suggest they got gunned down by the reapers.

[Kanner]

Penny-Arcade are vicious bastards. That should not surprise anyone, it's basically what they're paid for. =/

[XRelakX]

M.D wrote...

People want choice.

And i want my own island.. your point?

[NinjaRogue]

Bioware promised choice. Not an Island

[The Force Within]

For the millionth time its not about how happy or sad the endings are. Its the problem that all of the choices the player had made throughout the saga not having any meaningful impact on the end game. Being railroaded into generic 'samey' endings creates a situation where everybody's Shepard can all end the same way. This flies in the face of what the Mass Effect trilogy was all about. Choice and consequence.

[Plaguemaster]

Across the Mass Effect franchise my Renegade Shepard killed, stole, murdered, commited acts of genocide and other atrocities, also lied and betrayed. So no, I would not like to see the Everyone is Happy in land of fairies ending. I want to see results and consequences of my actions - krogans crawling on their planets and suffering from genophage, last rachni placed in museum( or last franken-queen enslaved), Cerberus reborn from their surviving Collector base, human Council resrored and Jack by my side, laughing at my foes' downfall.
Should BioWare somehow do something like that for all our previous decisions, both renegade and Paragon ones. at leaast for key ones - I will buy and recommend BioWare's next products to all my friends and co-workers.

[Rickin10]

XRelakX wrote...

M.D wrote...

People want choice.

And i want my own island.. your point?

Were you promised an island?

[BatarianBob]

The insane Reaper motive could just be dismissed as the machine equivalent of senility. Whatever the Reapers original motives were, they've been burried beneath aeons of synthetic dementia. Just chopping out the nonsensical Normandy segment and leaving the fate of the ship and squad mates to our imaginations might elevate the ending to a C-.

XRelakX wrote...

M.D wrote...

People want choice.

And i want my own island.. your point?

Bioware built their reputation on making games with choices.  The Mass Effect series was built on choices.  That's what people had every reason to think they were paying for.

If you bought an island, you should get an island.

Modifié par Taranatar9, 17 mars 2012 - 11:37 .

[Overule]

Is it too much to ask for choices, happy endings, AND unhappy endings? It seems to me like that'd be the way you'd handle a series built on player choices.

[adawg828]

The ending makes zero sense thats why I don't like it.

[DLC On The Disc]

I don't know how the people can stand spouting that "You guys just want a happy ending" nonsense. Personally, I find that much straw to be very itchy.

[sorentoft]

You can have both.

[Subject M]

Nikitn wrote...

The ME3 ending was **** not because of the hopelessness, but because of the lack of: logic, choises, a  proper conclusion and a decent spacebattle scene.

Do many of you disagree? Would you accept this deus-ex monstrosity of an ending just if your shepard and his mates lived happily ever after? If so, shame on you. Don't get me wrong. I wouldn't mind it if a happy outcome was possible, if difficult to attain, but the lack of this is in no way the real issue.

Just felt I had 2 clear the air.

Hello Nikitn.

I think its safe to say that no-one wants an illogical ending. A lot of people want happy endings. These ending are really not that happy since Earth is pretty much in very a bad shape, millions are dead, and it will take a loooooong time to clean up and rebuild, No one is comming out without serious scars, but some of us want the option of our Shepard spending time rebuilding  the galactic community with friends, allies and LI.

Yes, such an ending should be difficult to attain. You should have to work HARD for it.

Modifié par Subject M, 18 mars 2012 - 12:06 .

[alikilar]

would be cool if there was a happy ending and a sad ending based on the choices u made not based on the choices u make in the last 2 minutes but still im in the Bioware bandwagon for future games.

[thunderhawk862002]

I want a mixture of endings that are all logical and conclusive. I'd like to see a happy one as well as one where the reapers win.

[Haasth]

I don't want a happy ending.
I want an ending that makes sense, isn't filled with a ridiculous amount of plot holes and oversights and gives me some choice.

[ttchip]

I still don't see how ending the cycle - which happens either way - is an unhappy ending in the grand scheme of things.

Edit: I'm deliberately avoiding 'Hurr durr ending sucks'-comments.

Modifié par ttchip, 18 mars 2012 - 12:11 .

[chengthao]

who cares if i want a happy ending . . . but i'd sacrifice a happy ending with a good ending any day, this ending wasn't good