407 réponses à ce sujet

[crimzontearz]

both

[darkiddd]

Because it doesn't make any sense.

[superduperkoala]

I don't mind Shepard dies at the end as long as his sacrifice is worthwhile. Committing mass genocide by blowing up all the mass relays not only isn't worthwhile, but it doesn't make ANY SENSE WHATSOEVER!

[Swisspease]

Sparatus wrote...

I hate it because the ending doesn't make sense. I wasn't expecting a happy ending. But I was expecting endings that weren't riddled with space magic and plotholes.

This

[Justicar]

Both.

Endings didn't make sense and it was sad.

[sanmar]

Both.
I want to have a choice (happy ending and an ending where the Reapers win).

[VLJ]

Both.

Nothing affected anything.

Done a playthrough where quarians live and one where they don't...it affected nothing.

And the whole, die by doing this, die by doing this or die like this was absolute bulls**t! Come on, we've spent 5 years with this character building them up to be able to take on the Reaper forces only for them to die in 3 different pathetic ways.

It just seemed like a GIANT cop out, and something that makes me a little nervous about where Bioware will be going from now on. KotOR all the way through to Mass Effect 2 were incredible. But DA 2 was alright and ME 3 was great until they killed it at the end.

Why did they not have drew karpyshyn writing this one? He did a fine job with the 2 previous games as well as the novels. Instead they got some ****got who knows f**k all about the universe finishing it up.

[RedMike512]

I hate the ending because it's not a happy ending AND because it makes no sense. However, I'd accept a non-happy ending, as long as it made sense. (It just wouldn't be my preference.)

Modifié par RedMike512, 18 mars 2012 - 01:35 .

[Siven80]

Doesnt make sense.

[Blind2Society]

This is an honest question. Who seriously wasn't expecting a happy ending? I would think that everyone who had played Mass Effect was expecting to able to choose no? Maybe your choices throughout the series and at the end wouldn't have led to a happy ending but did you honestly expect there not to be an option for one?

[Robhuzz]

Both. I hate because it doesn't make a bit of sense and because there's no way to get a happy ending, even when you do everything 'right' in all 3 games.

Modifié par Robhuzz, 18 mars 2012 - 01:36 .

[dannii2]

Doctor Uburian wrote...

Hyrule_Gal wrote...

We want a choice of endings that range from good to bad so everyone can end their game how they want to.

Just this.

Yup!

[SausageLegend]

Forced failure is probably the problem for most people. At least it is for me. ME2 essentially had two bars. A preparation bar and a succes bar, and they were directly proportional. The more you prepared for the final mission the more succesful you came out of it. You could experience a total failure, massive success and anything in between.

With ME3, regardless of preparation you can´t come out on top. You always lose. And I´m okay with losing something at the end, but the people claiming that it fits in the `dark` context of the series need to check the definition of dark. ME2´s ending is the biggest counter to this. The crew spends the entire game talking about how your mission is suicide and they probably won´t come back, and what happened? We went in, accomplished the mission flawlessly and everyone came out without a scratch. Dark my butt.

[VLJ]

sanmar wrote...
I want to have a choice (happy ending and an ending where the Reapers win).

I thought there was supposed to be an ending where they win?

They said it prior to the games release.

Yeah, http://www.nowgamer....ware.html ]here is the article saying so[/url]

Modifié par VLJ, 18 mars 2012 - 01:37 .

[Lambchopz]

I don't even find the ending sad as it stands, it just lacked emotion completely. It was disconnected. If the ending was trying to be some profound bittersweet ending, it completely failed.

There's a difference between an ending that makes you feel sad and an ending that makes you feel empty. If I'm playing through a character driven story with high stakes and bloated emotions all the way through, then I want the ending to match that. This ending fails to make me feel ANYTHING besides just 'meh'.

[Total Biscuit]

Both.

A selection of endings, including the happy ones that were foreshadowed right up to the last conversations with your crew, as well as loosing, and everything in between was what we'd been expecting and promised. Happy endings aren't unrealistic, or unpopular and they're certainly not badly written unless you write them badly.

Misery does not equal better stories.

But the endings we got, sorry, ENDING, is not only unrelentingly miserable, but also completely nonsensical and totally impossible in several places. It is appallingly badly written and totally out of keeping with the rest of the game, throwing realism and intelligence out the window.

The fact that it'd make far more sense to just be in Shepards head then really happening speaks volumes.

Modifié par Total Biscuit, 18 mars 2012 - 01:38 .

[nicksmi56]

Doesn't make sense. Although I believe a happy ending SHOULD be sn option along with a sad one

[AlectoIra]

I didn't expect a happy ending I mean I was saving the Galaxy from a race that had been able to defeat everyone before me, that having said I wanted the ending to fit with everything else I had done an not leave me damn confused as to how any of it made logical sense. An Garrus seemed to magically survive when I took him to earth for fighting good times why couldn't I some how have made my way onto the normady?

Modifié par AlectoIra, 18 mars 2012 - 01:38 .

[Robhuzz]

Blind2Society wrote...

This is an honest question. Who seriously wasn't expecting a happy ending? I would think that everyone who had played Mass Effect was expecting to able to choose no? Maybe your choices throughout the series and at the end wouldn't have led to a happy ending but did you honestly expect there not to be an option for one?

I thought about it. Then I figured with all the fanservice BioWare has given there was no way they'd make all the endings suck equally hard and remove any ending that can even remotely be called 'happy'. Shows you what I know:mellow:

Modifié par Robhuzz, 18 mars 2012 - 01:37 .

[Wattoes]

Doesn't make sense/stupidity. Space Magic. God child ext.

Technically some of the things make sense, but they just feel cheesy/retarded and forced.

I dont need a happy ending, but I do need one thats satisfying that made my journey really feel like it mattered.

[tankarmarx]

Both, I hated the lack of variety primarily, however. If you can have a ****storm ending, then you should be able to get a happier, more fulfilling ending.

I don't mind if my Shep dies since her LI was Thane anyway. But that doesn't mean I don't want to see what Mordin or Grunt are doing in some sort of epilogue. A much more concrete and definitive ending would have been better in general. Not this open-ended interpretive BS that doesn't even make any GD sense.

[Element Zero]

It makes no sense and ignores every choice I've made for 5 years. It took both Shepard and the narrative out of my hands.

[TeGhar]

One of my initial worries with the game was, that in the end we would achieve a "flawless victory". So I'm totally fine without a happy ending.

I just want an ending that makes sense and feels right. Something like Mordin or Legion got.

[VLJ]

VLJ wrote...

sanmar wrote...
I want to have a choice (happy ending and an ending where the Reapers win).

I thought there was supposed to be an ending where they win?

They said it prior to the games release.

Yeah, here it is:

http://www.nowgamer....in_bioware.html

[Motherlander]

Main reason: Plot holes (the Normandy fleeing and how Synthesis actually works) and lack of proper epilogue.

A happy ending would be a nice option, but for me it is not required as long as we can feel a sense of hope for the future.