190 réponses à ce sujet

[AwesomeDudex64]

He deleted it? Ah well.

[ABCoLD]

I think one thing we should take from this conversation, this information is that MOST of the game is wonderfully written. Many parts of it are fantastic. It's a GREAT game (except for one tiny part) and I think we should all recognize and encourage those writers who contributed while offering constructive and polite criticism when needed.

[Shanook]

"Edit the Third: As this has become a springboard to attack other writers, this post is going away."

Can we please stop using this as ammunition against the other writers? I'm sure every one of them wrote something amazing. Be civil about this.

[Pallid]

Silmane wrote...

To be honest, with the backlash of the endings, what did he think was gonna happen when he posted that?

Great job, Pat, but way too soon with a post like that. Should've waited a few months, maybe years.

Or even decades.

[ed87]

Praise those not responsible for the ending. I like that

[Yalision]

This writer did an absolutely job with Mordin and the like. Would be nice to see how he would envision the ending.

[Nollan]

ABCoLD wrote...

I think one thing we should take from this conversation, this information is that MOST of the game is wonderfully written. Many parts of it are fantastic. It's a GREAT game (except for one tiny part) and I think we should all recognize and encourage those writers who contributed while offering constructive and polite criticism when needed.

I have to agree. For example, he didn't wrote Mars and it was one of my favorite parts of the games.

[Midarenkov]

Silmane wrote...

To be honest, with the backlash of the endings, what did he think was gonna happen when he posted that?

Great job, Pat, but way too soon with a post like that. Should've waited a few months, maybe years.

He posted it before people had gotten to experience the game's end. At the time Bioware could do no wrong.

[Kenthen]

I would've liked to read what Weekes wrote but too late. Thanks, assclowns.

[Myrmedus]

Yes, I think the guys at BW need to take this on board if they're feeling depressed or crestfallen: we LOVED 99% of the game, just fix that last all-important 1%!

Modifié par Myrmedus, 18 mars 2012 - 08:10 .

[vigna]

Who wrote the Tali parts in mE2 I forget?

[Noatz]

This guy has done some terrific work.

Along with the rest of the team.

Even Mac Walters. Despite the endings we really shouldn't forget THE GUY WROTE GARRUS. Anyone can make mistakes, what counts is if they fix them.

[fish of doom]

Shanook wrote...

"Edit the Third: As this has become a springboard to attack other writers, this post is going away."

Can we please stop using this as ammunition against the other writers? I'm sure every one of them wrote something amazing. Be civil about this.

i agree.

[fish of doom]

Noatz wrote...

This guy has done some terrific work.

Along with the rest of the team.

Even Mac Walters. Despite the endings we really shouldn't forget THE GUY WROTE GARRUS. Anyone can make mistakes, what counts is if they fix them.

^

[Kenthen]

Noatz wrote...

This guy has done some terrific work.

Along with the rest of the team.

Even Mac Walters. Despite the endings we really shouldn't forget THE GUY WROTE GARRUS. Anyone can make mistakes, what counts is if they fix them.

Absolutely this.

[Shanook]

Noatz wrote...

This guy has done some terrific work.

Along with the rest of the team.

Even Mac Walters. Despite the endings we really shouldn't forget THE GUY WROTE GARRUS. Anyone can make mistakes, what counts is if they fix them.

[ABCoLD]

Kenthen wrote...

I would've liked to read what Weekes wrote but too late. Thanks, assclowns.

There's a copy on page 4, keep up the trollin.

[darkiddd]

Noatz wrote...

This guy has done some terrific work.

Along with the rest of the team.

Even Mac Walters. Despite the endings we really shouldn't forget THE GUY WROTE GARRUS. Anyone can make mistakes, what counts is if they fix them.

Exactly. If the ending is bad, then it is bad no matter how many theories you come up with. Now you can do two things: fix it or leave it as it is and destroy with the last 10 minutes a franchise and a great story. 

Bioware has lost my respect but they can regain it by changing the ending. Not sure if they care about my opinion or the opinion of the majority of the fans though 

[Mr. Big Pimpin]

vigna wrote...

Who wrote the Tali parts in mE2 I forget?

Same guy.

[Denethar]

Walters is a fine writer, Garrus is an example of that. I just think he try too hard at times. You know that type that just reaches a bit out of what they are actually able to do.

[spartan5127]

Get this guy as co-lead for the fix. Mac Walters can still be at he forefront and redeem himself. As others of said, Mr. Walters isn't a bad writer, he just made a giant mistake.

[Lumenadducere]

Noatz wrote...

This guy has done some terrific work.

Along with the rest of the team.

Even Mac Walters. Despite the endings we really shouldn't forget THE GUY WROTE GARRUS. Anyone can make mistakes, what counts is if they fix them.

Going to join the others and quote as well.  Garrus was one of the best-written characters in this game, and as bad as the endings are it's important to remember the good as well as the bad.

[Lacan2]

So this guy is the one responsible for Tali's dialogue. And most of the parts I enjoyed.

Maybe he should be lead writer on the next project.

[Lawliet89]

http://webcache.goog...0&bih=993&ion=1 Google has the cache.

Or pastebin: http://pastebin.com/ZV2QhViG

[lyleoffmyspace]

The Genophage sequence was the best part of the game, Tuchanka especially.

I felt like part of a massive group working together, there was loss, struggle, friendship and emotions were so high. It was so epic and everyone worked together on it.