Aller au contenu

Photo

2H Rambling


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
15 réponses à ce sujet

#1
rio

rio
  • Members
  • 5 messages
Sorry, formating because wall of text, don't know how to add paragraphs, gimme a few mins.  Okay, I don't know how why paragraphs are not paragraphs and now I've lost interest.  On behalf of the human race, I apologize.

Testing:

After finishing the campaign on Nightmare with my 2H warrior, someone asked me about my build and so here I share.  It's not as difficult as people seem to make it out as.  I went without anyone dying but this is my second playthrough, (my first was on Normal).

Party setup:
-Alistair (tank: templar/champion)
-PC (2h: berserker/templar)
-Leliana (archer: bard/ranger)
-Wynne (healer)

So the main question people seem to ask is if they should go 2h or dw.  I don't know much about dw but I hear it is ludicrous dps, something the 2h isn't (at least, compared to other damage builds).  It's a different playstyle, I guess, I didn't play a dw rogue because I really don't want to wear the ridiculous looking light armor.  It's okay on Leliana but er, well I guess it's just not my taste.  I require massive plate.  In my head.

What 2h excels at is being an off tank.  With Indomitable, you will not get knocked down.  With massive armor, this makes you the ideal candidate to "pull" mobs because you won't get knocked down from fireballs and is safe enough to be able to take a lot of hits.

You should get 2h sweep as soon as possible because it will be important when the mobs are catching up to your healing or when your weaker party members need a taunt that Alistair doesn't have the stamina/health for.  The soonest you get this talent is level 10.

Same goes for Indomitable.  Also, Sunder Arms is a very big deal starting out.  You won't have haste so you'll be relying on Mighty Blow, Sunder Arms and Critical Strike to reset your swing timer.  Sunder Arms hits twice but doesn't force a critical and also provides a melee debuff.

As for my party selection... a lot of people seem to like having Morigan instead of Wynne which I can see as doable, but she starts off sans spirit healer and with a bunch of different things.  Also, she's a cold, ...

What I was going for is a party where I can run into a room without having to pause too much and only issue commands to the PC.  I wanted the fight to be automatic and it's worked out well for me.  You have to set up your tactics pretty well but later in the game, I only pause on very difficult fights (vs Ser Cauthrien) or when there are mages present.

I had Alistair and the PC both be templars because I megaloathe mages (unless I'm playing them).  Crushing prison on the PC or Alistair used to hurt like nothing else until I got cleansing aura.  And even then, cleansing aura will knock off haste so it is still annoying.  Basically when the fight starts, I pause and plan where Alistair will tank one side of the room and I will go on the other side.


Leliana is pretty crucial even though I didn't really plan her to be.  She started off as extra dps and support (bard song and extra tank from ranger).  I had her tactis set to kill whoever is lowest on health.  With a 2h, especially before I got haste, one swing would take a mob down to 1/8th their health and I can move on to the next mob and Leliana wuld finish whoever off.

Alistair I had to be aggressive dps who taunts whenever a mob is attacking Leliana (this tactic doesn't work too much as it doesnt check range of the mob against current position).

The key to beating nightmare without having ridiculous cc with mages is pulling.  Take the fight with ser Cauthrien for example (or a lot of the fights in the prison of that dungeon).  It will take basically all of the party to take her down, you can't be messing with the an additional 10 scattershot spamming archers and 1 mage.  I had my party run to the next room where only two guards chased us.  After killing them, I had my party wait while my PC run to let Cauthrien see me and chase me.  Only an additional two guards came and we killed them too before focusing Cauthrien down. 

By the way, I hate her, I had such high hopes for her when I saw she was actually hesitant in retreating but then she called me a churl FFtactics style, so obviously I will never let her live.

Anyway, you do have CC with this group.  Alistair has single target knockdown from shield tree.  Holy Smite seems to knock a lot of people down but I reserve that for mages.  I had Alistair have full champion so he can aoe knockdown as well for emergency heals.  I had 2h sweep, pommel strike and the rare 2h stun.  The 2h stun seems to be automatic with Mighty blow and Critical Strike but it doesn't happen too much with white hits.
Wynne had the repulsion and paralysis glyph though I think I only used it once vs a certain general in a certain alienage. 

Lastly, I want to mention how simple 2h is.  Really, all you have to do is pump strength.  I think I had a constitution of 20 but that's not really necessary.  As for gear, I used 2H Starfang (I also used Yusaris for a time) and Warden Commander's armor.  Both of these by the way, is something you can get right out of Lothering.  If you don't have DLC, you should use Wades Superior Dragonbone Plate (wade says dragonbone funny) and I guess Yusaris or Ageless?

Also, the fights are pretty simple.  Pause at the start of battle, have Alistair tank one side (the more crowded side) while you run off to either kill archers or the mages before rejoining the group.  If you think it's going to be rough, throw lifeward and regen before running in.  If you think you won't make it to the mages/archers before dying, then you should pull the mobs into a different room.  That way, you can funnel them into a very small botttleneck (doorway) and also not have to run the gauntlet to the squishy archer/mages in the back.  Other than dealing with mages and archers, I don't think you'll need to pause too much as long as you have your tactics set right.

Oh and one last thing, the most difficult part of this game on Nightmare is pre-Lothering as you basically have no healer and limited amount of healing items.  Remember to collect ALL elfroots and poultices that you come across (there's enough in the beginning area to get you to Lothering, but you will have to conserve).

After this, you should definitely making the Dalish quest a priority because you get unlimited Elfroots there.  By the way, I never bothered with crafting anything higher than the first tier potions until the end when I crafted the second tier and bought the rest.   Lesser Lyrium potions are very important for Wynne and they are unlimited and cheap from the Circle tower. 

So, there it is, my rambling on about nightmare mode with 2h.  I figured there's not a lot of talk about it as most people seem to go mages or dw so I hope someone finds it at somewhat amusing. 
Someone told me that 3 mages and a tank is the way to go but that's not my style.  Also, that someone looked like Sten.  Sten is creepy.

Hooray. 
Also, that Hespith girl is creepy.  Also, Loghain is cool.  Though not as cool as Duncan. 
Also, if you don't take the purple pills, do not take the red and the blue pills together.  Not the same thing.  I am hungry.

Modifié par sils621, 29 novembre 2009 - 04:59 .


#2
Driggan

Driggan
  • Members
  • 123 messages
Cheater.

Modifié par Driggan, 29 novembre 2009 - 04:45 .


#3
brelrande

brelrande
  • Members
  • 145 messages
Awesome post Sils. was thinking about rolling a 2h W, or a dw W, think im gonna go with a 2H sounds fun.

So if Alistair is your tank im assuming he is using 1H with shield correct ?

Ive always had a problem with setting tactics, think i need to play around with this some more before i try out Nightmare

#4
rio

rio
  • Members
  • 5 messages
Ya, Alistair is my tank, he is awesome. I like corny witty one liners.



I just had Alistair running with so many sustained that I didn't need to micro him that much. I had him using Shield Wall, Threaten and Rally. Occasionally, I would use the AoE knockdown if he's in trouble. Stamina was a real problem for him, but I didn't bother getting into it as he is sufficient.



He had Juggernaut set with Keening Blade and Fade Wall/Duncan's Shield in the end.



He's not as good as Shale as a tank in the beginning because you need to pump so much strength for him to wear Juggernaut and afterwards dex to get shield talents, but late game he is beast.

#5
brelrande

brelrande
  • Members
  • 145 messages
another question what race was your PC, is there a race that is preferred for a 2H style ?

#6
rio

rio
  • Members
  • 5 messages
I guess dwarves would make the best 2H race, I think they start out with a talent in it. I know human noble warriors start with shield bash free, and city elf starts with dual sweep?. I picked dalish elf which starts with pinning shot (lol) because I hear it's the worst origin story.



I ended the game level 22 I think with all the 2h talents and warrior skills maxed out so it doesn't really matter. It can be done and easily with dalish which is probably the worst race for 2h. If you want to min/max, pick dwarf, you will have a free 2h talent as well as some magic resistance?



As for the str,dex difference... it doesn't make much of a difference. At the end of the game I had about 80 strength which was more than enough to get the job done.




#7
Belrian

Belrian
  • Members
  • 7 messages
Actually no combination starts out with anything in 2Handers. I've played through a lot of times now. Dwarves get either shields or Dual wield for commoners, Elves are archery or roguish talents, and humans are shields too. So, if you want a 2hander character the best would probably be a dwarf as previously said, accepting the fact that you'll have some useless talents to start.

#8
Forumtroll

Forumtroll
  • Members
  • 323 messages
Dwarfs can +1 STR, +1 DEX, and +2 CON. Elves get +2 MAG and +2 WILL. Humans get +1 of everything. As a 2H warrior (since no race starts with talents in 2H) I'd pick humans for the WILL and STR bonuses plus starting with rank three combat skill.

#9
Belrian

Belrian
  • Members
  • 7 messages
Good point..personally I think it's really odd how all 3 of Endrin's sons have 2 handed weapons, yet, as a noble you start with talents using a shield..heh

#10
Forumtroll

Forumtroll
  • Members
  • 323 messages
You find that weird? Harrowmont uses a mage staff.

#11
Cuthlan

Cuthlan
  • Members
  • 2 427 messages
That is, to the small details, the exact party I used on my "main" playthrough. 2h templar/berserker (human noble?), Alistair was a templar/champion, Leliana was a bard/ranger, and Wynne was a spirit healer/arcane warrior (although I never did put her in heavy armor...).



It is an exceptional party build for being a good guy. All of the companions are on the same page morally, and in combat they all work together well.

#12
Cuthlan

Cuthlan
  • Members
  • 2 427 messages
One suggestion I would make... Chasind Great Maul from Gorim in Denerim does more damage than Starfang, and has significantly more armor penetration. And it gives a ton of bonus stamina (+75 and +1 in combat regen, I think).



I love how Starfang looks, though... I have both slotted up with Grandmaster runes on my warrior, just because I could.

#13
rio

rio
  • Members
  • 5 messages
Cool, if you go for the maul, that means you can give Starfang 1h to Alistair early instead of waiting for Keening Blade. I had him use Topsider's Honor but that was pretty far advanced in before that. Starfang looks so awesome.



Also, some equipment you should know about if you're going 2h haste + bloodthirst. There's a ring, Lifegiver, in Orzammar that gives health regen. The merchant at party camp also sells Spellward which is a neck that also gives health regen. With these two, I can run around with haste + bloodthirst while exploring without taking heals. I should have given them both to Alistair but.... wtf I'm the hero amirite?



Sorry, didn't know dwarves didn't get 2h talents. I thought they would. I can't play as one though, I just... I can't do it.

#14
brelrande

brelrande
  • Members
  • 145 messages
awesome thanks for the tips people.

think im gonna go with human noble or dwarf noble, although im not a big fan of the stinky short guys :P

and ive already done a human noble, its weird though id rather do that again that any other, since its all so familiar to me, makes it feel more natural O_o

#15
Cuthlan

Cuthlan
  • Members
  • 2 427 messages
Not weird at all... having played all of the origins, Human Noble is the most touching to me, and the one I connect to the most.

#16
brelrande

brelrande
  • Members
  • 145 messages
agreed. ive just completed the dwarf noble origin, very, very well done i thought.

wondering the roads with a gorgeous sword and nothing but rags on, not at all what i expected.