164 réponses à ce sujet

[darkiddd]

Mass Effect 3 without ending:

Mass effect 3
Mass Effect 1
Mass Effect 2 (and 2 is still awesome)

Mass effect 3 with ending

Mass Effect 1
Mass Effect 2
Mass Effect 3

[phouria]

2>1>3

1 is great, but there's broken game mechanics

[Harmless Crunch]

Pre ending?
3
1
2

Post ending
1
3
2

[MrAnthonyDraft]

ME2 > ME3 > ME1

[Swordfishtrombone]

For me, ME1 > ME3 > ME2

Though all of the games in the series are very good.

[Iezza]

1,3,2.

1 for RPG elements
2 for characters
3 for combat system.

[effortname]

Gameplay: ME2 = ME3 > ME1

Narrative: ME1 > ME2 > ME3

If they fixed the freaking ending, 3 would probably rank higher than 2.

[NubXL]

ME1 > ME3 > ME2

Even with its horrific ending and several other nagging problems, ME3 is much better than ME2. It improves upon the combat introduced in ME2 and draws from positive elements included in ME1. Neither of them stand up to ME1, though.

[LadyofRivendell]

ME3 - ME1 - ME2

ME2 was just missing something... I felt like I was being railroaded throughout the entire game, because I basically was.

[Hepatitis P]

-Me2
-Me
-Me3

[Dridengx]

Gameplay - 3,2,1
Story -  3,2,1
Ending - 3,2,1
Replay Value - 3,2,1

2 is only superior in NPCs, mini games and journal.

Modifié par Dridengx, 18 mars 2012 - 11:08 .

[HenchxNarf]

Gameplay: ME3, ME2, ME1
Story: ME3, ME2, ME1
Ending: ME3!!! ME2, ME1
Replay: ME3 and ME2 are tied because I played ME2 like 8 times and I'm on my third ME3. So for now they're tied.

[Spanky Magoo]

ME2 by far then ME1 and ME3 are around the same ME1 was technically flawed but the story was good ME# was technically awesome and story was great until the ending soured the whole series for me.

[Stretzal]

Before the ending
ME2
ME1/ME3 (Tied)
After the ending
ME2
ME1
ME3

[darkshadow136]

ME1
ME2
ME3 well ME3 destroys them all, when it could have been the best of them all.

[Dudeman315]

Story
ME1
ME3
ME2

Characters
ME1
ME3
ME2

Gameplay
ME1
ME3
ME2

Endings
ME1
ME2
ME3

[Aimi]

Gameplay: ME3 > ME2 > ME1
Characters: ME2 > ME3 > ME1
Story (pre-ending): ME3 > ME2 > ME1
Ending: ME2 > ME1 > ME3

[Alithinos]

I wasn't expecting to see it,I thought I was the only one that liked most ME2,then ME and ME3 less.

[Somath Cegem]

Pre Ending:- 3 > 2 > 1

Post Ending:- 2 > 1 > 3

[DiebytheSword]

Somath Cegem wrote...

Pre Ending:- 3 > 2 > 1

Post Ending:- 2 > 1 > 3

This.

[wesr]

ME2
ME1
me3

[Mole267]

ADelusiveMan wrote...

In their chronological order for me.

I concur. I liked 1 the best out of the trilogy too. I found myself asking why they removed so much in ME2 and 3.

ME1 is large in scope, and has a lot. ME2 and 3 are very simplified in comparison. I got so used to playing ME2 and 3 tho, that I had to change the controls in ME1. Default for grenades is R, and I found myself throwing a grenade when I tried to reload, which you don't even have to do in ME1. Also changed sprint to spacebar and tactical hud to shift (default is reverse).

[Massefeckt]

Okay now I've finished 3 here's my revised list

ME1
ME2

















































ME3

[Celtic Latino]

Truthfully, Mass Effect 1 & 3 are tied in first place for me

Mass Effect 3 positives (1st): 
-best combat of the three games
-evolving powers
-every squadmate is useful
-detailed interactions among squadmates, party banter is improved
-graphics are indeed the best
-romance subplot is amazing, Shepard can also be friends with squaddies and also be disagreeable
-Javik is a true squadmate and not just a click-and-dialogue character for DLC

negatives
-auto-dialogue
-romance scenes are relatively tame
-Liara required on missions way too much, she's forced too much 
-the endings

Mass Effect 1 (also 1st, slightly better than ME3 for me) positives: 
-heavier roleplaying influence
-no auto-dialogue
-Shepard can be neutral/can be interpreted with a lot of personalities
-every squadmate is useful (you need a Tech for locks/hacks, team balance is key)
-more involving sidequests/exploration
-very time consuming
-Shep can be friends without having to romance a squadmate
-romances are explicit
-Shepard can have positive or antagonistic relationships with ALL squadmates, including Liara

negatives
-character creation for male Shepard is meh


Mass Effect 2 (last for me) positives: 
-every squadmate has a detailed personal quest
-squadmates are more colorful and varied

negatives
-99% of combat is spent in cover
-only Miranda + another squadmate is useful at all
-Shepard can't just be friends without initiating romance
-Shepard is either nicey-nice or a big jerk, not as much variation as ME1 & ME3
-no weapon mods
-no real reason to talk to squadmates other than romance/loyalty mission
-romances are cheesy flings
-LoTSB forces Liara to be your friend


Mass Effect 1 & 3 vie for the top for me because both have detailed roleplaying interactions. ME3 slightly wins over because of the intersquad relationships and banter and far less staticy, plus the combat rocks. ME1 follows behind because of Shepard's vast options (paragon, neutral, renegade). ME2 just stinks, no weapon mods, squadmates aren't really that involving, more like a fps with 'roleplaying' aspects. BioWare really learned with bringing the best of both games with ME3 I will say that.

[Ticondurus]

Chrono for me as well: 1, 2, 3